Kabul Attack Underlines Western Failure In Afghanistan, Former Envoy Says

Kabul Attack

First Posted: 20/08/11 17:24 Updated: 20/10/11 11:12   PA

PRESS ASSOCATION -- The Taliban attack on the British Council offices in Kabul has underlined the failure of the western strategy in Afghanistan, the UK's former special envoy to the country has warned.

Sir Sherard Cowper-Coles said claims Afghan forces would be able to take over responsibility for security after 2014 - as Britain and America are planning - had been exposed as a "fantasy".

Once international forces pull out, he warned the country would be plunged into a bloody civil war - in which the rival parties "fight themselves to a standstill" unless there was a political settlement with the Taliban.

"The strategy is not working. It is a fantasy to imagine that the Afghan security forces are going to be able to secure Afghanistan any time these ten years. They won't be able to secure Afghanistan unless there is a new political and regional settlement," he told the BBC Radio 4 Today programme.

"If Hillary Clinton was doing her job properly as America's chief diplomat she would be bringing together the regional foreign ministers and saying it's Ramadan, it's the Muslim holy month, we should be bringing this ridiculous violence to an end.

"It is about talking to all the regional powers, it is about talking to all internal factions and bringing them all together in an Afghan-style peace process. It will be messy, it will be difficult but the military approach is clearly not working."

Sir Sherard, who has been an increasingly outspoken critic of US policy in Afghanistan since leaving the Foreign Office, said the Americans needed to take the lead in finding a settlement.

"There is a deal to be done but it needs leadership by the United States and the United Nations, its needs imagination, and above all it needs political courage and political will in Washington," he said.

Taliban suicide bombers killed at least eight people, including a New Zealand special forces soldier and three Afghan security guards, after storming the British Council's offices.

Foreign Office minister Alistair Burt said he was "deeply saddened" by the soldier's death, and thanked New Zealand for its role in bringing the "dreadful incident" to an end.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

PRESS ASSOCATION -- The Taliban attack on the British Council offices in Kabul has underlined the failure of the western strategy in Afghanistan, the UK's former special envoy to the country has warne...
PRESS ASSOCATION -- The Taliban attack on the British Council offices in Kabul has underlined the failure of the western strategy in Afghanistan, the UK's former special envoy to the country has warne...
Filed by Michael Rundle  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
ewldest
I don't care "whose" war it is - end it now
14:43 on 21/08/2011
Of course once foereign colonialists leave Afghanistan will plunge into bloody civil war - but that will happen whenever we leave, noiw or a hundred years from now; Our military industrialists know that and sell arms to both sides, directly or, through Pakistan, indirectly; the insurgents know that and know they can wait us out; the corrupt Kabul cabal knows it and so bleeds every tax-dollar it can out of us while we're there. This whole thing is nothing more than a savage money orgy for multinationals and their political mercenaries in Western governments. We must call for an end not only to this wasteful war but to the military industrial neocolonialism that has mired us in it.
21:57 on 20/08/2011
The moderators that know the policy of AOL is to censor the post to achieve their agenda's and to benefit a foreign government have a responsibility as patriotic American's to report such activities. For this violates the first tenet of a Democracy free speech which is guaranteed under the First Amendment.
21:57 on 20/08/2011
Without fail, following every little incidence the British, U.S. and NATO commanders take opportunity to shove into our faces the need for our forces to remain in Afghanistan and Iraq. It more than obvious that their plans are to bring the general public along with their already defined plans to maintain a western presence in the two countries for the next twenty years. What we have happening, right before our eyes, is nothing short of an extension of the U.S. “Eminent domain theory, now being imposed on the Middle East. This places the Iranian nuclear weapon issue clearly in focus because it is this simple probability that would cause a serious affront to their overall plans. They’ve defanged Iraq, are working currently to defang Libya and Syria (if Syria falls they’ve captured Lebanon, except for Hezbollah and it has no nuclear weapons) and with some serious focus may be able to buy new governances in Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt and Yemen. Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar and UAE already have the ring in their noses economically.
21:55 on 20/08/2011
Reality is that we are a Christian nation controlled by Israel and we are trying to impose our will on Iraq and Afghanistan, Moslem nations. Sheep do you really think this is a plan for success? I think not. The whole root of the problem is the Middle East conflict. We support Israel, a apartheid regime in Palestine, that makes us a enemy of the Moslems and they know it
23:33 on 20/08/2011
Improving your manners might be a step towards communication with others.

What is with the ''sheep'' ?

Who do you think you are?
21:04 on 20/08/2011
Tell the taliban that once they're back in town, that if they don't shape up that our drones will be monitoring them and they should beware.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Greg Sureck
19:27 on 20/08/2011
yes, it's all true pull out of Afganistan Now, Right now. It's a waste of human life. Let Afganies do as they wish
23:34 on 20/08/2011
I agree. But there is not a Western politician willing to admit failure. Except Ron Paul.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edward Lucie-Smith
Art historian, photographer, poet
16:54 on 20/08/2011
Sir Sherard Cowper-Coles is stating the obvious, It's a lost war. The Afghan government the allies are wasting blood and money supporting is not going to last an instant after they are gone. And go they must - they now have almost no choice in the matter.
23:35 on 20/08/2011
But the choice is fight hopelessly or admit error. So they fight on. Politicians change and a new cycle begins.