Paul Donnachie, Scottish Student, Found Guilty Of Racism After Abusing Israeli Flag

Israeli Flag

First Posted: 24/08/11 14:04 BST Updated: 24/10/11 11:12 BST

A Scottish student has been found guilty of a racist breach of the peace after he "insulted" an Israeli flag and called a Jewish student a terrorist, in a landmark case that has been described as "profoundly ignorant" by some campaigners.

Paul Donnachie, an 18-year-old studying at St Andrews University, was found guilty by a Scottish court on Tuesday, following a complaint by a Jewish-American student at the campus.

Chanan Reitblat said his privacy had been invaded when Donnachie and fellow student Samuel Colchester entered his room, rubbed his hand first on his genitals and then on an Israeli flag.

"Paul put his hands down his pants, pulled off a pubic hair and rubbed it over my flag. Sam did the same thing," Reitblat said.

Donnachie also told him Israel was a terrorist state and the flag was a terrorist symbol.

After finding Donnachie guilty, Sheriff Charlie Macnair said the student had racial motivations for his actions.

"I consider your behaviour did evince malice towards Mr Reitblat because of his presumed membership of Israel. I'm satisfied you said Israel was a terrorist state and the flag was a terrorist symbol and I also hold that you said that Mr Reitblat was a terrorist," Macnair told the court.

The decision was a landmark ruling as the judge decided that attacking someone's Jewish identity based on their identification with Israel was racist.

Donnachie has defended his actions as "not malicious" and intends to appeal his conviction.

"I'm not contending that my action toward the flag was commendable or dignified, but it was a political expression,” he said during his testimony.

Following the verdict he said: "This is a ridiculous conviction. I'm a member of anti-racism campaigns, and I am devastated that as someone who has fought against racism I have been tarnished in this way."

The Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign (SPSC) said Tuesday's judgement was one of "profound ignorance" and attacked the prosecution for attempting to "conflate legitimate political criticism of the State of Israel with racism."

Upon hearing the verdict members of the SPSC are reported to have shouted "scandal" from the public gallery.

Reitblat was studying for one term at St Andrews University as part of his university degree at Yeshiva University in New York.

He had fled as a child with his family to the US in an attempt to escape the then-severe Jewish oppression in communist Lithuania.

Donnachie has been expelled from St Andrews. The case against the second student, Colchester, was found not proven but he has been suspended from the university for his part in the incident.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

A Scottish student has been found guilty of a racist breach of the peace after he "insulted" an Israeli flag and called a Jewish student a terrorist, in a landmark case that has been described as "pro...
A Scottish student has been found guilty of a racist breach of the peace after he "insulted" an Israeli flag and called a Jewish student a terrorist, in a landmark case that has been described as "pro...
Filed by Ned Simons  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
Talab
I tot i taw a putty tat
07:10 PM on 09/02/2011
Did this happen in israel or the UK .... no wonder we americans fought for our freedom if you can be convicted of disrespect for a contemptible regime in another country
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alois SaintMartin
aloistmartinsequinox.blogspot.com
08:42 AM on 08/25/2011
Another Ungrateful Spolied Englishman who`s appetite for Beer and Blood overshadows his Fruedian Fear of The Father ...
08:40 AM on 08/25/2011
Great story, the biter bit.
Its's great to see a left wing so called 'anti racist' being told he does not have the monoploy of righteousness. That these people are just as bigoted and so as liable to 'hate' crime offences as anyone other bigot.

That said, this and similar offences should never be in court. It is not the first and won't be the last time students insult each other or their beliefs and it is daft to think the world can be force changed. But still the rabid left and their vociferous 'anti' anything they don't like do need slapping down occaisionally and to be reminded the law must work both ways.

If another Scottish student was to insult a PLO student and his flag, the left wing students would soon be baying for blood demanding he was prosecuted and thrown out of the kindergarten.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LaFemmeSASE
02:03 AM on 08/25/2011
Offensive- YES
Crude- YES
Nasty- YES
Filthy- YES
Racist- NO

If you can be convicted on calling Israel terrorist, then many HuffPo commentators would be behind bars.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles Bertrand Jr
challange11
01:37 AM on 08/25/2011
Yep.....I agreee... a punch in the nose was more real.....manned up. yep... seems right.
photo
An Independent Woman
Honni soit que mal y pense
08:50 PM on 08/24/2011
The Scot, crude behavior. The Yank, litigious behavior. If I were the Yank I just would have just popped him in the nose, but, alas, why settle something directly when you can go to court? Both guys should have manned-up.
07:46 PM on 08/24/2011
Pretty terrible. Why is the Israeli flag the only flag you can get a prison sentence in the UK for insulting? You can't even get a sentence for insulting the Union Jack.

It's not even a racist act since judaism isn't a race it's a religion. You wouldn't get a criminal record for desecrating the symbols of scientology so why is judaism so protected?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Want2knowY
04:53 PM on 08/25/2011
Jews, in most of Europe, were more than just a religion. They were a distinct ethnic group with their own language and culture. You need to look a little deeper into history on this one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Flyingpigs
01:44 AM on 09/02/2011
DNA says otherwise! Its a race! One thing Hitler was correct...
07:20 PM on 08/24/2011
So... just so I'm sure I understand the assertion being made here. If I adopt the jewish religion, I am also joining the "race" of jew? What race would I be if I converted to catholic? Am I a non-person because I'm an atheist?

I'll burn down my city the day such a law is passed. WTF is wrong with this world?
06:34 PM on 08/24/2011
The Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign (SPSC) - I wish I had made this up...I imagine a shipment of Haggis arriving in the West Bank....

As for putting your hand down your pants as political statement... Blind faith? Although millions of guilt-ridden lads across the world will jump on this political...ahhhh... movement.
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aroddo
02:55 PM on 08/24/2011
I wouldn't call them guilty of racism ... this seems more like a case of rectum cavum to me, which is quite typical for kids in that age.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ramon Moreno
Read below.
06:44 PM on 08/24/2011
Kids from one to ninety-two.
02:38 PM on 08/24/2011
"This is a ridiculous conviction. I'm a member of anti-racism campaigns, and I am devastated that as someone who has fought against racism I have been tarnished in this way."'

No mate, what's ridiculous is putting your hands down your pants and rubbing it on someone else's belongings. Whatever floats your boat, if that kind of thing does it for you then so be it - just don't involve others in your sick past-times.I kind of understand why you'd want to do that kind of thing - after all, a real man wouldn't stoop so low so you probably need to check on your manhood every so often - might explain a few things if it wasn't actually there.

Oh and I'm sure those anti-racist campaigns which you boast to belong to are extremely proud to have you as a member.
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.