Health And Safety 'Convenient Excuse' To Avoid School Field Trips, MPs Warn

Science Committee Report

First Posted: 14/09/2011 10:55 Updated: 13/11/2011 09:12

Health and safety concerns are being used as a "convenient excuse" by schools to avoid practicals and field trips for students, in moves that could threaten the next generation of scientists, MPs have warned.

A science and technology committee voiced fears in a report published Wednesday that secondary school students are not receiving the practical education necessary to produce future scientists.

The Commons science and technology select committee said health and safety concerns were being used as a "convenient excuse" for avoiding practicals and field trips. But they found no credible evidence that the experiments and trips could cause a hazard to students.

"We began this inquiry because of a perception health and safety concerns are preventing science practicals in schools and fieldwork. What we found was the perception was to a large extent misconceived", the report stated.

The pressures of managing a busy curriculum and lack of time to get out of the classroom were both cited as excuses for the decline of practical science, which was described by the committee as "dull or non-existent".

Chair of the committee Andrew Miller said: "This is worrying. If the UK is to be confident of producing the next generation of scientists, then schools - encouraged by the government - must overcome the perceived and real barriers to providing high quality practicals, fieldwork and field trips."

The committee recommended a bigger focus on what happens after teachers have been recruited to the profession. MPs said practical skills and knowledge must be maintained and developed so a high quality of science education could be delivered to students.

"Science is a practical subject", the report added. "If students are to follow a scientific career, they need to understand how the facts have been gathered.

"They cannot and should not do this exclusively second hand."

Despite an increase in the number of students taking science GCSEs, the committee urged the government to continue to encourage pupils to study the subject.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

Health and safety concerns are being used as a "convenient excuse" by schools to avoid practicals and field trips for students, in moves that could threaten the next generation of scientists, MPs have...
Health and safety concerns are being used as a "convenient excuse" by schools to avoid practicals and field trips for students, in moves that could threaten the next generation of scientists, MPs have...
Filed by Lucy Sherriff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 3
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
22:29 on 14/09/2011
There is little wrong with the H & S Act except the codes and guides to it are open to interpretation.

Everything is fine until something goes wrong, then litigation, both from the HSE and ambulance chasers steps in.

How do you think these fire officers feel after their colleagues were killed http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/feb/28/fire-service-managers-manslaughter-charges

Everthing is fine until something goes wrong.

I couldn't beleive the comments of Michael Gregory, reviewing lawyer in the CPS special crime division He said: "Following a thorough investigation by Warwickshire police and the Health and Safety Executive, I have reviewed the evidence in this case very carefully and I have decided that there is sufficient evidence and it is in the public interest to charge themanagers"

I wonder how many times has Mr Gregory has been faced with making decisions about sending his colleagues, his friends probably into fires and then knowing they lost their lives In the public interest, indeed.

Perhaps this case is why firefighters seem to fight fires from the outside of the buildings nowadays. It must be costing this country millions in lost infrastructure, because some overeducated pen pusher decides that it is in the "public Interest" to prosecute these heroes.

I don't blame teachers who don't want to do field trips, especially if they get the balme if an idiot 14 year old decided to jump off a bridge and injured himself after being told to sit down
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
17:47 on 14/09/2011
Yes indeed it is a great excuse to use "Health and Safety" to get out of doing nothing, the usual political corectness gone mad.
22:06 on 14/09/2011
Somebody help me, please.
First the story includes this quote,
"We began this inquiry because of a perception health and safety concerns are preventing science practicals in schools and fieldwork. What we found was the perception was to a large extent misconceived"
So the 'perception' is false, i.e. health and safety concerns are NOT preventing practicals and fieldwork and the entire story is based on this misconception?! Or is it the 'concern' that is 'misconceived'?
And now Lawyer13 indicates that "it is a great excuse... to get out of doing nothing"--i.e. they are in fact doing activities?!
I am confused...