Joanna Yeates Trial: Chaplain Tells Court Of Vincent Tabak's Confession

Chaplain Tells Of Vincent Tabaks Confession

First Posted: 18/10/11 15:16 BST Updated: 18/10/11 18:18 BST   PA

Joanna Yeates's killer admitted his crime to a prison chaplain but was angry when told his confession would be passed on, a court has been told.

Salvation Army member Peter Brotherton told the jury he shook hands with Vincent Tabak before the defendant told him: "I have got something to tell you that is going to shock you."

Tabak, who admits manslaughter but denies murder, had been under 24-hour supervision at HMP Long Lartin, and was said to have told Mr Brotherton of his plan to plead guilty on February 8 - three weeks after his arrest.

Appearing in the witness box at Bristol Crown Court, Mr Brotherton said he decided he could not keep the information secret because Tabak was not religious.

Mr Brotherton, who has been visiting prisoners since 1975, said "there was a little bit of anger" in Tabak's voice after the chaplain said he would have to pass on the information. Tabak, was said to have made the confession on their third encounter.

"I'm not going to tell you anything else," Tabak was said to have told Mr Brotherton. When Tabak told him he had something that was going to "shock you", Mr Brotherton was said to have replied: "You tell me and we will see."

After Tabak said "I am going to change my plea", Mr Brotherton asked him: "Are you sorry what you have done?" Tabak was said to have replied: "Yes."

During cross-examination, Tabak's QC William Clegg claimed Mr Brotherton's comments differed from a statement he gave on February 16.

Mr Clegg said: "Let me suggest to you there was no suggestion of 'changing my plea'. 'I am going to plead guilty' - that's what he said. "You said 'What for?'. And he said 'For the crime I have done'."

When the barrister suggested some of his evidence on Tuesday was wrong, Mr Brotherton replied: "If that's what you say, I would agree with you."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

Joanna Yeates's killer admitted his crime to a prison chaplain but was angry when told his confession would be passed on, a court has been told. Salvation Army member Peter Brotherton told the jury...
Joanna Yeates's killer admitted his crime to a prison chaplain but was angry when told his confession would be passed on, a court has been told. Salvation Army member Peter Brotherton told the jury...
Filed by Lucy Sherriff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 2
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
floodberg
Attorney (ret.)
03:39 PM on 10/20/2011
FYI; there are strict limits on what is 'privileged' (not able to be disclosed) under priest-penitent rules, it is not an absolute privilege, or even one of the stronger ones.  Every profession that has a 'privilege' (lawyers, doctors, therapists, priests, Parliamentary,  etc.) knows the rules (or should).  Simply speaking to a priest with the expectation of confidentiality is not nearly sufficient for the privilege to operate. 

Most people have concerns when speaking to a medical professional; for heavens sake, begin the conversation with your doctor by asking him what the rules are.  They're accustomed to being asked, and more than happy to tell you.  When in doubt ask a licensed, experienced barrister (UK) or full attorney (US); we know the rules by heart.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
07:55 AM on 10/19/2011
This may well be the vital evidence which will undo the plea of Manslaughter for Tabak, I do hope so