Society Of Editors Warn Against Anonymity For Accused Teachers

Teachers Anonymity

First Posted: 18/10/11 18:42 BST Updated: 18/12/11 10:12 GMT   PA

Proposals to give anonymity to teachers accused of committing crimes against pupils such as assault would place a serious inhibition on the right to freedom of speech and could leave children at risk, the Society of Editors has warned.

The society's executive director, Bob Satchwell, raised the alert in a letter to all members of the House of Lords, which is considering the Education Bill.

Clause 13 of the Bill would, if enacted, give automatic anonymity to any teacher accused of committing an offence against a pupil, whether the accusation was made by the child or on his or her behalf.

"It will be a criminal offence for anyone - pupil, parent, police, school, local authority, whistle-blower, media - even to inform parents or public that an identified teacher has admitted that the allegation is true and has resigned, or been disciplined, or even cautioned for the offence," Mr Satchwell said in his letter.

"It would also be an offence to report that the identified teacher had been exonerated."

Lord Phillips and Lord Black had both raised these issues during the summer, and Lord Phillips was now proposing amendments to the Bill, which the society believed deserved support.

Mr Satchwell went on: "Lord Phillips believes the proposals would be a gross inhibition on freedom of speech: it would set a very dangerous precedent as people could be convicted for telling the truth."

The society appreciated teachers' fears about false accusations, but the most important issue was to protect children.

Mr Satchwell wrote: "Other media organisations share our concern that no one, including parents, could even discuss or raise the allegations publicly, without committing a criminal offence.

"To avoid prosecution, they would have to persuade a court to lift the reporting restrictions (even then, the court can only lift them in the 'interests of justice' with regard to the teacher's welfare, not on wider public interest grounds) or get the teacher's written consent, unless criminal charges are brought (or the Education Secretary/General Teaching Council for Wales publish information about disciplinary action which they have undertaken)."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

Proposals to give anonymity to teachers accused of committing crimes against pupils such as assault would place a serious inhibition on the right to freedom of speech and could leave children at risk,...
Proposals to give anonymity to teachers accused of committing crimes against pupils such as assault would place a serious inhibition on the right to freedom of speech and could leave children at risk,...
Filed by Lucy Sherriff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 2
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:25 PM on 10/18/2011
I can see their point, but on the other hand the current system works under the presumption of guilt, as child protection is at stake. The teacher is removed from teaching duties until the case is closed, but there have been reports of teachers who've been completely exonerated and the allegation has been proven to have been malicious, who've still found themselves effectively blacklisted and unable to secure another job within the profession.

Heck, when they're being trained, teachers are told that if a pupil wants to have a word after a lesson, it may not be sufficient to leave the door open, or even to stand next to the doorway if the adjoining corridor is quiet. Basically any situation where a teacher and single pupil are in the same room together is to be avoided.

But the other extreme of threatening criminal action against anyone who dares mention the teacher's name seems rather heavy handed, especially as the teacher's identity will quickly spread through the school grapevine - if a teacher suddenly disappears from all classes with no explanation given, it won't take a genius to add the proverbial two and two...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
rtgmath
There has got to be a better way!
08:15 PM on 10/18/2011
Ahhh, guilty upon being accused. Guilty by rumor even if exonerated. Guilty even if not charged with a crime! Guilty upon hearsay.

And all Teachers who do not want to live under such a system need to quit en-mass and let the system wither on the vine. We may be teachers, but we need justice, too. The children need justice, but no one should be presumed guilty without due process -- in the US or in the UK or anywhere in the world.