White Working Class Britons Feel Alienated And Disenfranchised, Claims Joseph Rowntree Foundation Report

White Working Class Alienated

Huffington Post UK   Dina Rickman Posted: 28/11/11 00:00 GMT

Working class white Britons feel alienated, disenfranchised and last-in-line for resources such as social housing, according to research published by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation.

The report, which interviewed white working class people in Birmingham, Coventry and London found they felt disconnected from the political process and felt their voices were not heard.

Participants complained they could not express their opinions “because they're 'racist” or representatives in local government were not listening to them.

One woman from Aston said: “They are all Asian at the council – it's like no one can understand us. It's hard, a joke round here, I hate it.”

Some also complained resources were closed off to them and there was a widespread perception that those in other communities had preferential treatment for council houses.

Harris Beider, who authored the report said white working class people wanted to “be valued” and “connected to government".

“It is important to confound the negative stereotypes and understand that people in these communities feel their voices are not listened to, and that they have no stake in their community. They want to be valued, heard and connected to government.”

Owen Jones, author of 'Chavs: The Demonisation of the working classes' said the report showed “just how voiceless and unrepresented many working-class communities are”.

“For example, I'm a writer, and I'm white, but I would never consent to the identity 'white writer'. I've met countless people who proudly call themselves 'working-class', but never 'white working-class'. Working-class communities also tend to be far more ethnically mixed than middle-class areas - and, particularly somewhere like London, lots of cultural mixing takes place. In lots of ways, 'white working-class' is an imposed label."

Some participants complained of being stereotyped as “on the giro” or “thick” as a result of the working class label.
One woman from Birmingham said being working class was not about “money”: “It's about people who have always worked, live in a council area and gfrown up with working class values”.

The findings come in the wake of a study by BritainThinks which warned that fewer than a quarter of Britons self-define as working class.

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation Chief Executive, Julia Unwin CBE, said: “We know there are real concerns that many people in traditional white working-class areas are becoming increasingly disconnected with the political system and feel their views, experiences and interests are ignored by policy makers. This research highlights the real potential we have to grasp opportunities to engage with and support many of those who feel let down and ‘last in line’.”

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

Working class white Britons feel alienated, disenfranchised and last-in-line for resources such as social housing, according to research published by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation. The report, whi...
Working class white Britons feel alienated, disenfranchised and last-in-line for resources such as social housing, according to research published by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation. The report, whi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 50
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
06:27 PM on 11/28/2011
No one is disenfranchised in this country, or alienated either, they are just to lazy to get out of their arm chair and become involved with their communities, you just have to look and see how many bother to exercise their right to vote in local and general elections, and then have the gall to complain about the Council or Government.
08:38 PM on 11/28/2011
How do you know what people think. I think not. You dont know how many people voted in these areas. Would you like to live in a tower block and have to pay for your electricty by meter .
05:34 PM on 12/23/2011
i'm guessing you're being sarcastic . if you're not i fancy that some of the delusions of your patients are rubbing off on you
05:06 PM on 11/28/2011
Racist, looking for blame? I've discussed on my little blog how so many are so quick to blame 'the system' without looking first at their own shortcomings. I really believe if you aspire to anything you need to start with being able to read. If you can read you can learn what goes on outside your own environment, if you can read, you can write, if you can write you can articulate your dreams and start a process of getting out of an environment you have no desire to stay in. Working class is an old term to describe those 'in service' or engaged in menial labour. Sadly so many of the working class now are misnamed perhaps. If it was down to me I would invest a huge amount in making sure people can read from an early age. My grandmother washed the family laundry in a stream because the family lived in a corrugated iron shack with no hot or cold running water. My mum taught me to read the minute she felt I was able. I chose not to pay attention in school and rebel instead, but I could read and therefore I managed to forge something of a life for myself even though I had no qualifications. I do not enjoy good looks, discernable talent or great intellect but I can express and idea and sometimes just that and a desire to better yourself gets you on a road out of the mire. Little steps.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:23 PM on 11/28/2011
“They are all Asian at the council – "

See here how democracy works - you get off your lazy backside, stop complaining, get to know your community and run for council. If lots of people feel the same way you do, they vote for you. If they don't, they won't.

If you lose and you feel strongly enough, you get to know your community EVEN BETTER, find out what people's main concerns REALLY are and run for council again. And this time, you might win.

Or you could sit around whingeing about those Asians taking part in the democratic process, while you are left with your thwarted sense of entitlement.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Euroview
04:57 PM on 11/28/2011
Well said!
05:38 PM on 12/23/2011
yeah lets have 20 odd million people running for council eh . the logic of the (brainwashed) educated people in this country never ceases to amaze me
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
minimemo
Can I be your friend...if they let me out...
12:16 PM on 11/28/2011
Was only a matter of time really before discourse and disharmony came out. The entire country has been subject to an enforced 'mixing' of cultures and 'told' we are to be multi-cultural. However, those who come here to live, in the main stay within their own cultural grouping and don't mix, is not what I think the socialist politicians thought would happen!! We now have cultural enclaves and no-go areas up and down the country and for the most part, it has not been for the better! The problems will only get worse the longer the recession lasts. The country is seeing a rise in diseases that had previously been eliminated in the UK like TB and rickets. The open door policy is for the most being detrimental to the health and wealth of the country in general and just about every high street in the UK now looks like it belongs firmly in the third world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Euroview
04:56 PM on 11/28/2011
To the ignorant it might appear that we have been "told" that we are to be multi-cultural.

These Islands have been multi-cultural since before the Viking invasions. There has always been an assimilation of different peoples here with the Royal Family being a prime example of the "foreign" make up of our population.

The irony is that those who try to stir up discontent don't even know that, and in their ignorance even adopt the flag of St George as their emblem ....... of course they don't know that St. George was from Anatolia (now part of modern day Turkey).
05:30 PM on 12/23/2011
to the ignorant it might appear that we have NOT been told that we are multicultural. All you need is ears and eyes . All i ever hear from middles class media types and politicians is that multicultarism and diversity is our strength. Myself i agree with the german leader who says it don't work only ignorant people would think otherwise.
photo
the grange gorman
Rachel Corrie is the greatest person since Lennon
07:34 PM on 11/28/2011
There are no "no-go areas" in the City in which i live
09:43 AM on 11/28/2011
As I keep saying, we get who we vote for. We determine who runs the country so it's up to us to change things. I don't mind anyone coming to this country.. as long as those who want them here.. house them, feed them and pay all their bills including health. Won't be many here then.
09:15 AM on 11/28/2011
A question to the Joseph Rowntree Foundation: How do you measure "whiteness"?

Is it something like this: "One the scale 1 to 10 please indicate the whiteness of your skin..."

Working class and internationalism have always gone together. Remember, Lenin?

Do not alienate working class people from each other based on skin colour!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
ideaville
I have sexdaily, I mean dyslexia, Danm!
08:38 AM on 11/28/2011
I recently flew into Birmingham Airport via Dubia, it was hard to tell the difference!
photo
the grange gorman
Rachel Corrie is the greatest person since Lennon
07:44 PM on 11/28/2011
brum has better kebab shops...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:46 AM on 11/28/2011
Welcome to the world -
05:18 AM on 11/28/2011
As an Island immigration has been a constant feature of the history of the 'UK'. The diffenerce now is that modern transportation and information/communication methods mean that migratory patterns are not carried out by a few 'brave souls' but by anyone who can get on a plane, boat, or any other form of transportation.

I work with clients looking for employment/training, and last week met a Kosovan who had been here (in London) 12 years, had never worked (being unable to when first here as a refugee) and who told me, in very poor English, that his work experience in Kosovo/Albania was a Shepherd/Goat Herder - not much call for that, in North London!

Allowing illiterate and unskilled people to come to the UK is very nice for those employing menial low-paid labour, but it is one of the reasons that the 'White Working Class' are now ignored, overlooked and vilivied - they have become little more than a problematic drain on resources that are being used to, house, and employ the cheap labour now performing the roles the 'salt of the earth' used to be kept, in poverty, to undertake.

A question I'd like to pose to our MPs is this: "How many foreign workers are challenging for your jobs?"

I'd like to think that this is an opinion offered to stimulate debate, but I await the stereotypical accusations of racism, and hope that the educated can see beyond the demonisation of free-thought?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Itsbeenalongday
Eliminating poverty is smart business
05:56 AM on 11/28/2011
There are about as many "foreigners" working in the UK (around a couple of million) as there are Brits working overseas in foreign countries. I think Gordon Brown mentioned something along those lines once.
06:16 AM on 11/28/2011
Is that the same Gordon Brown, the socialist, who thinks that free movement of anyone to anywhere is the way forward?

Please do not confuse the retoric of a bufoon who was 'placed' into the position of Prime Minister with an accurate image of what is going on - shall I tell you the one about the Bulgarian woman of 23 who has been here since she was 10 (13 years) and who now has 5 children, no husband, and pulled a face like someone sucking a lemon when I suggested that I could look for work for her to do...don't worry about the comings and goings of a migratory labour force, and don't believe the stories that immigration provides valuable workers whilst it conveniently ignores the criminality of the 'other visitors' to the UK - check out the numbers of non-uk nationals in our courts and prisons - a cost being met by UK tax payers.

Two million doesn't even cover the moivement of people in the Eastern European EU diaspoea!
11:17 AM on 11/28/2011
So, there are 2 million Britons spread across the world working in different countries whilst there are 2 million "foreigners" working in this single small country -mmm!
This comment has been removed.
01:09 AM on 11/28/2011
There are 2 billion people living on less than $2 a day in the world.

How do you balance immigration with the economy and the number of jobs?

How many fish can you put in a fish bowl before they begin to eat each other?

The worlds endless population growth is not sustainable. Did we not learn anything from Easter Island?
04:48 AM on 11/28/2011
The only thing we learned definitively from Easter Island was that the Easter Islanders were really good at making moais.
12:34 AM on 11/28/2011
Many of the Asians were born in Britain and know of no other country. They speak English with a local accent and to say they cannot understand others in the community is ridiculous.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
inthedesert
Those who never question will fall for anything.
12:32 AM on 11/28/2011
Hey folks..this is EXACTLY what is happening in America but with the Mexicans. This is why Anglos are fed up with not only illegals but legal Mexicans too. You visit any welfare office in America and you will see nothing but brown faces and hear nothing but Spanish. People are fed up.
MA2AW
Anti-Obama on everything
02:20 AM on 11/28/2011
You forgot about having to push 1 for english.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Johnny Galileo
03:37 AM on 11/28/2011
You don't get off the farm much, do you Tex?
05:36 AM on 11/28/2011
And you don't get off your high horse much, do you Johnnyboy?
12:31 AM on 11/28/2011
a perfect example of tower hamlets, east london
12:14 AM on 11/28/2011
this is so true!i also live in birmingham and believe me asian people make up the majority of workers and bosses in the council & government offices
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EQ8Rhomes
02:24 AM on 11/28/2011
@Cefn Out of birmingham: WHY? Please explain. Do the Asians work? Are they punctual and efficient and effective in their work? If not, complain to the authorities and replace them by getting their jobs because you are qualified.
11:10 AM on 03/05/2012
yes asians work, within thier own cash societies. within thier community, if no work there they take over everywhere else. just to reiterate, this isnt racisism (go look it up) this is being observationalist.in bham where i live you see asians driving sports cars all day long, clearly not at work. there are areas where i live that are purely asian.they were not affected by ressecion. mainly because of thier cash mini economy. dont attack me based on what ive observed.