Pupil Reduced To Tears As 'Wildfowling' Trip Turns Into Duck Shoot

Shooting School Trip

Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 01/12/11 11:58 Updated: 01/12/11 11:58

As Ray Poolman packed his 10-year-old daughter Danielle off with a little chair and binoculars to go on a birdwatching trip, little did they know what lay ahead.

But the schoolgirl arrived home later that day in floods of tears after being subjected to a "harrowing" hunting experience. Instead of lessons on the "different species of wildfowl" and "conservation of the landscape", as promised by the school, the Year Six pupils witnessed birds being shot and killed for sport.

Ashbeach primary school in Cambridgeshire has now come under fire for not making the purpose of the trip clear.

A letter sent to parents in November detailed an excursion to Welney Marshes in Norfolk, organised by Ely and District Wildfowlers' Association. Pupils would see dogs and "equipment used for the sport" and the school reassured the children would be safely out of the way during the "wildfowling demonstration".

The letter made no reference to guns or shooting and Poolman said it talked about seeing an "evening flight", "which you would think would be birds all coming in back to roost, which probably looks nice".

Poolman, a keen fisherman, said both he and his daughter both thought the day out was solely a birdwatching trip.

"She wasn't expecting anyone to shoot ducks. It turned out to be a very harrowing trip for her.

"The letter should have had words like shooting and live ammunition and made clear that birds could be killed," he complained. "Then the parent can make an informed decision".

But the school has defended the trip saying no child told staff they were distressed, the Daily Telegraph reported.

Head teacher Shirley Stapleton said there "appeared to have been a misunderstanding".

"It is not just 'let's go out and shoot ducks'; there is a whole conservation issue which the school deals with."

The trip, she explained, was part of a programme to educate the pupils about their rural heritage. Next month the pupils will take part in the village's "Plough Monday" traditions, which involves dressing up as "plough witches" and leading a straw bear through the streets.

However Poolman maintained his daughter had suffered a traumatic, and unnecessary, experience.

"They allowed children to witness the death of an animal.

"Ramsey might be rural but we have a Tesco - people don't need to walk around killing animals to survive any more."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

As Ray Poolman packed his 10-year-old daughter Danielle off with a little chair and binoculars to go on a birdwatching trip, little did they know what lay ahead. But the schoolgirl arrived home la...
As Ray Poolman packed his 10-year-old daughter Danielle off with a little chair and binoculars to go on a birdwatching trip, little did they know what lay ahead. But the schoolgirl arrived home la...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 40
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:30 on 04/12/2011
You are all wrong, and right, but missing the point. It's not about shooting ducks, it's not about wimps, guns, war, being top of the food chain, or any of the other rubbish that's been posted. It's about children, or to be precise, a child, who clearly wasn't ready to be confronted with the shooting of a duck. Each child is different, each parent has their own ideas and providing they are doing their best for the child then we should accept that their views on such matters will vary. Let kids be kids; there is a Santa, a tooth fairy and a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. There's nothing wrong in introducing a child to the truth about hunting and shooting sports, but it should be done when they are ready to get it balanced in their minds, and not being ready does not mean they are wimps or that the parents are sheltering them from the truth. It's about timing, and we should respect the fact that this particular child was confronted with an event that she wasn't expecting or ready for. If your looking to blame someone for this girls distress, then the fact that the trip was aimed at that particular age group carried an inherent risk that some of the children may have been shocked and upset by what occurred. The school should have ensured the trip was appropriate for the age group.
20:58 on 03/12/2011
School : Hello we would like to bring a class to see some birds please...."okay would you like them to watch us shoot some ducks? school: oh yes that would be okay i'll arrange it...what a dumb school! Fancy not checking what was going on, haha! I bet they had to fill out the dreaded blue consent forms. Are you allergic to Feathers if so tick box. This is what schools have become PC for some things and then defend something that clearly is not right and say its okay...they said it was a misunderstanding? yes it was, the school misunderstood the day out...BIG TIME!!
13:20 on 02/12/2011
What a Stupid Story!!! Why not take them to an Abattoir??? May be we will have more Carrot Crunches than Meat Eaters??? We are all Carnivores for goodness sakes!! What's wrong in shooting an animal if you are going to eat it???? My mum used to say Mint Sauce every time we passed a field full of sheep, now its Curry Sauce, how things have changed since then but that’s another story!!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mondayboy
Rebel with a cause
11:58 on 02/12/2011
goo will hunting
11:58 on 02/12/2011
waitress, I would like some duck ala orange please!
03:39 on 02/12/2011
While I don't have a strong opinion on the event itself either way, I do believe strongly in full disclosure for informed decisions. Especially for children. What if you signed for your dog to be neutered and the vet docked their tail and cropped their ears? Don't you think you should have been made aware? It is not the event itself. It is about disclosure and consent and the option to participate or not.
20:57 on 01/12/2011
Its hunting. Get over it child. Someone should toughin the child up a little bit. Like a parent.
11:00 on 03/12/2011
This isn't the dark ages - I hope you don't have children.
19:14 on 01/12/2011
So many kids really believe that their food all comes from the grocery store. What happens before the grocery store...they have no idea. I work for a "petting zoo" farm where we take farm animals to schools. Those kids have no idea what a real turkey looks like. When you point at "Tom" and tell them "This is what you eat for Thanksgiving" they look at you like you are stupid. Some wimpy schools don't even WANT us to associate turkety with "Tom" or bacon with "Wilbur" or "KFC with a real chicken...too much tramatising for the kids. 30 years ago the school used to give kids an excused absence on the first day of hunting season. Now they don't even want you to talk about it...not to mention that awful G word......gun.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
19:39 on 01/12/2011
True.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
emerging pattern
19:44 on 01/12/2011
If you want to talk 30 years ago, let's look at some other less than progressive attitudes and practices that were "normal" atthat time , too. Context.

While I agree that people in general should be aware of where ther food comes from, killing a wild animal that has to survive in the wild is really tacky -- especially when farmed food gets thrown out every week. Done in teh context of a school kids' outing... really stu.pid.
20:38 on 01/12/2011
It's about British heritage though, conservation and something specific to their area, they should be learning about where they come from or we all end up as nationwide clones. Her father is a fisherman, he should fully understand the interest of keeping heritage sports and activities alive.
09:19 on 02/12/2011
So animals killed in capivity is somehow "killing-lite" and completely diffrent from animals killed in their wild habitat? Killing is killing. Just remember that at sometime in the past, these captive animals came from wild stock.

Personally I love how "progressive" just seems to be a way of implying that what we do NOW is somehow inherantly better than what we did then, only because it is currently being done. Our "progressive" attitude also seems to have formed wonderful things such as widespread obesity. (Not saying obesity is related to farming/hunting - just that what is here and now is not always better then the past)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kevin Arthus
18:57 on 01/12/2011
Next month, a trip to the farm.
20:33 on 01/12/2011
or an abbatoir!
18:27 on 01/12/2011
I'm sorry but what exactly did he think 'Wildfowling' meant?? Is he a vegetarian?? No I think not, does he know where his food in Tesco comes from?? Ignorance is not bliss, it's stupidity.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
19:39 on 01/12/2011
Exactly.
22:19 on 01/12/2011
What was wrong with putting the words 'There will be a live Wildfowling demonstration which will include the use of firearms and live ammunition. Be advised that live animals may be killed during this demonstration?"

Why so nebulous? Why the weasel-words? Why couldn't they just say up front what was going to happen and allow parents to make a fully-informed decision?
This comment has been removed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
16:46 on 01/12/2011
I think the fathers making more out of this than his child. IMO. Hunting has always been and will always be a part of our culture. This said, the school should have been more informative and detailed about the event's planned activities so the parents could make an informed decision.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
emerging pattern
19:49 on 01/12/2011
"hunting has always been and will always be a part of our culture"

People used to say that about segregation...just might want to think a bit before using absolutes like "always.".

By the way: hunting to survive is a WHOLE different animal fromhunting for "sport", even when it's sanitized by 'well we eat what we kill".
11:58 on 02/12/2011
Its just me, but letting an animal live a natural life in its own habitat, with whatever freewill that animal can muster up until I kill it and eat it sounds a whole lot more humane than living in a cage your entire life just to be eaten.

Fact is that an animal IS going to die so I can eat it - one sounds humane, the other sounds like a miserable existance.
15:44 on 01/12/2011
Does he not take his daughter fishing? Are fish not animals? Does he know the definition of the word "overreaction?" So many questions...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dennis NJ
14:55 on 01/12/2011
Meanwhile 10 year old school children in Iraq and Afghanistan and a multitude of other places, 10 year olds don't have a school and witness their family members, friends and neighbors being shot and killed for oil and money
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
13:40 on 01/12/2011
I fear when I read stories like this, heaven help us if we ever have another war, with whimps like this
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
19:36 on 01/12/2011
Your'e right mate - heaven help us.
photo
brooklyncitizen
Quaerite primum regnum dei
04:49 on 02/12/2011
sounds like you are looking forward to more opportunities to use your guns.it is the height of ignorance to equate going to war with killing animals for sport.
you know who the wimps are? men that use guns to kill defenseless animals...just because they think killing is fun.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
05:46 on 02/12/2011
I do not have a gun, nor an I looking forward to a war, but I despair at how are children are becoming so pc and wimps man has always killed animals and birds for food, and what's wrong with that, certainly not a case to break down in tears what ever your age.
11:53 on 02/12/2011
Its more an issue of this being a part of life. If you want to see it or not, death is a real thing that needs to be accepted and confronted. The world is not rainbows and puppys. His point was not "an excuse to use his gun" but more a point of how sheltered our current generation has become. AND war is, at least for the forseable future, a part of our life (and larger culture). If your child cannot deal with this, well... the world has alot of surprises instore then.

Now I can understand how the kid was upset - sure. The parent should be taking this as a chance to explain - not freak out on the school.
13:28 on 01/12/2011
People need to save the word "harrowing" for stuff like, surviving a nuclear holocaust, or having been tortured. This was upsetting at best.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
13:39 on 01/12/2011
F & F well said.
photo
brooklyncitizen
Quaerite primum regnum dei
15:35 on 02/12/2011
And you know that because you have the mind and emotional maturity of a small child?
is that it?