Review: 'Frozen Planet' Final Episode - Warming Temperatures Affecting Polar Regions And The Whole World

Frozen Planet

First Posted: 07/12/11 21:50 GMT Updated: 07/12/11 23:54 GMT

Well, the classicists told us long ago that with great beauty there must co-exist great loss. Sure enough, having seduced us with images of bumbling bears, posturing penguins and impossibly cute polar cubs for the past six weeks, Frozen Planet signed off last night with an unblinking exposition of how quickly this ice-scape may all be consigned to history.

Sir David Attenborough and his team were very careful not to lay blame with any culprit for the changes in the regions; instead, they contented themselves with a devastating visual catalogue of proof that global warming currently exists - whatever doubters may say - and will go on to have worldwide repercussions.

We saw many creatures affected. In the north, we watched polar bears on a hunt for food, with prospect of success determined by the ice beneath their feet. As it fragments and shrinks, so does their chance of survival. We learned that neither mother nor cubs may feed again until spring - this, with longer summers of no ice and dwindling bear populations.

Meanwhile, on the other side of the world, penguins not often seen around the pole at certain times of year, flocked to the new waters.

Attenborough's compassion and admiration was by no means limited to the animal world. He also spent time with native Inuits, forced to adapt their rituals to the changing environment.

And, from our sofas, we watched the endeavours of people who've made it their lives' work to learn about the region, and the creatures within it. A team stood on freezing ice to weigh a mother polar bear to monitor her health, and someone evidently spent many, many hours in hopefully fur-lined boots to supervise a camera charting glacier movement over four years.

But these adventurers all seemed sedate when measured against the intrepid pair lowering themselves on ropes down a vertiginous abyss. These two were intent on collecting ice deposited 10,000 years ago - they were truly abseiling back in time.

Attenborough made the point that the warming of the poles is not a disaster for everyone. The Northwest Passage, cleared of ice in 2007 for the first time in history, promised a faster, cheaper route between the world's two biggest oceans. And some creatures, such as the bowhead whale, could benefit too. It is clear that, for others, only those who can adapt will survive.

Meanwhile, we watched, astonished, as 75 million tonnes of thousand-year-old Greenland glacier fell into the sea.

We saw all this beauty and fragility before Attenborough calmly told us, "The poles - north and south - may seem very remote, but what is happening here is bound to have an effect on all of us around the world."

It is a point he has made often, that if the ice continues to disappear at the current rate, temperatures will rise all over the world, and threaten people's coastal homes.

And he finished with a question: "Animals are adapting, but can we respond?"

In the midst of all this uncertainty and fragility, both of the environment and the creatures within it, it is definitely worth noting the quality of this series continuing up until the very last scene - with photography, music and passionate script combining to transform a complicated scientific story into a natural fairytale.

And at the centre of it all, the totem - Sir David Attenborough lying on the ice, speaking in hushed tones, watching a polar bear and seal mother and pup. It is three decades since we saw him in Africa crouching yards away from great apes, but his curiosity and transcendent wonder at the world around him is as contagious and inspiring as ever. Can we have another 60 years, please?

Check out our Slideshow of some of the most dramatic images from the final episode of Frozen Planet below...

1  of  15
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
Frozen Planet, Episode 7, Wednesday 7 December 2011. Picture: PA

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK ENTERTAINMENT

Well, the classicists told us long ago that with great beauty there must co-exist great loss. Sure enough, having seduced us with images of bumbling bears, posturing penguins and impossibly cute polar...
Well, the classicists told us long ago that with great beauty there must co-exist great loss. Sure enough, having seduced us with images of bumbling bears, posturing penguins and impossibly cute polar...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard2
04:52 AM on 12/19/2011
There was much excitement over the revelation that David Attenborough’s Frozen Planet had “faked” a scene where polar bear cubs, actually born in a Dutch zoo, seemed to be in Arctic wilderness. Yet no interest at all was aroused by a much more serious misrepresentation – of the speed at which ice is melting at the poles.

I was criticised for pointing this out last week, but as anyone can see, from satellite-based charts on the Cryosphere Today website, the extent of polar sea ice was last year 1.6 million square kilometres greater than its average over the last 30 years – something which could never have been guessed from Attenborough’s dramatic film sequences, carefully chosen to convey the very different message the BBC wanted us to believe. -c. booker
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:50 PM on 12/19/2011
Hey, Richard2: LTNS !

Have you noticed your fellow SHILL, netdr, already has 1280 posts and 91 fans in less than 8 weeks? If he gets paid by the post, he's making lots more than you.

But it's still smarter of you to desperatel­y avoid eventual civil legal liability by staying at the fringes of telling outright lies, at least since I've mentioned this issue to you, part way through your 2700 HuffPo posts. Before that, umm...you weren't quite so scrupulous.

And yes, they keep copies.

But I agree with you that netdr isn't smart enough to realize the eventual, potential legal consequenc­es of his flagrant and incessant lying.

Either way, the right-wing think tanks that hired you PR agents aren't going to lift a finger to protect you when it eventually hits the fan. That much I can assure by way of human nature, especially right-wing human nature, the most indelible kind.

You know it, and we know it.

Ta Ta, Richard2 !
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:14 AM on 12/20/2011
Bravo!
photo
gallon
Those who fail to remember history are, um
01:00 AM on 12/20/2011
Richard2: " from satellite-­based charts on the Cryosphere Today website, the extent of polar sea ice was last year 1.6 million square kilometres greater than its average over the last 30 years "

Not that we don't believe a professional denier, R2, but perhaps you have a link for that claim?

The long term trend is for a waning ice cap. It sounds like you are claiming the ice cap is at a record high? What is wrong with this picture?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard2
01:17 PM on 12/12/2011
It emerged yesterday a key scene from the hit BBC series showing a polar bear tending her newborn cubs was filmed in a zoo using fake snow.

Mixing real Arctic shots with zoo scenes, documentary makers fooled the audience into believing the footage was gathered by intrepid cameramen in the brutal sub-zero wilderness.

It was actually filmed from the comfort of a wildlife park enclosure using bears in a man-made wood den.

In the carefully worded Frozen Planet commentary, Sir David Attenborough's script failed to explain how the moving scene was made. The truth behind the trickery is only revealed in a hard-to-find video among dozens of clips on the BBC website.

Yesterday, John Whittingdale, chairman of the Commons culture, media and sport committee, said it was "hugely disappointing" that viewers were misled.
photo
gallon
Those who fail to remember history are, um
01:08 AM on 12/20/2011
References. References. There is a strong record around here of deniers just making up stuff.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:18 AM on 12/20/2011
Why is it that deniers have absolutely no capacity to value the natural world as more than a mere commodity for their own excess? It would be easy for deniers to prove they are sincere in their denial if only they had sensibilities that are unselfish. Tell us about any trend in the natural world that would suggest you are informed, rather than a paid ideological hack who lacks all substance required to know his error.
06:01 PM on 12/11/2011
I would love to read a story about an environment without the word "fragile" in it.

Aren't thee any "robust" climates ?

Of course there are just no one wants to admit it.
photo
gallon
Those who fail to remember history are, um
01:00 AM on 12/20/2011
Texas. Texas claims they have seen this all before. Therefore Texas must not be so fragile.
01:18 AM on 12/20/2011
For once you have posted something I agree with.

The climate in Texas has been warming and drying overall since long before the white man came here.

You are finally learning something ?
photo
gallon
Those who fail to remember history are, um
02:06 AM on 12/20/2011
You obviously didn't perceive the sarcasm. Texas is as fragile as anywere else. Texas is now desertifying.

Desertification: The next dust bowl, Nature, vol. 478, pp. 450–451, Oct 27 2011.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard2
04:19 PM on 12/11/2011
Attenborough should have addressed the recent controversy about the Greenland ice sheet as presented in the new Times Atlas of the World. The new atlas displayed significant retreat of the ice sheet on Greenland over a very short period of time. However, scientists, and googlers, objected, as there was copious evidence that the ice had declined by an insignificant amount.

So what is David Attenborough's position on this issue? Who does he thinks is reporting reality, the net Times Atlas, or the scientists who objected to the distortion of reality? On what side of this fence does he stand?

"Sir David’s dramatic shots of Greenland may have tried to convey that its huge ice cap is rapidly melting. But a detailed study five years ago estimated the proportion of its ice lost by melting around its periphery at only seven thousandths of 1 per cent of the total, suggesting that it could make little significant difference to sea levels for thousands of years. All we might have asked for, to go with those stunning film sequences, was a rather more balanced picture of what is happening. That Sir David and the BBC did not give us." - C. Booker
photo
gallon
Those who fail to remember history are, um
01:07 AM on 12/20/2011
Let's see your reference for this, R2.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MikeWebster
Always happy.
07:08 AM on 12/09/2011
Attenborough is definitely one of the greatest science communicators there has ever been. And he's a good guy as well.
cantabria
my default position is wrong
12:54 AM on 12/08/2011
More pretty pictures from DA and his dardevil crew.
12:22 AM on 12/08/2011
Revolution needs the R knocking off... everything needs to evolve and that takes time.( Dinosaurs need not apply!)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Lane
12:00 PM on 12/08/2011
My parrot evolved from dinosaurs.
12:42 AM on 12/10/2011
Indeed! So did my stinky green "terror-bird."