Moors Murderer Ian Brady 'Can Have Public Mental Health Tribunal', Judge Rules

Ian Brady

First Posted: 09/12/11 11:14 Updated: 09/12/11 12:02   PA

Moors Murderer Ian Brady will have his mental health tribunal hearing held in public, a judge has ruled.

It will be only the second time that such a hearing has been held in public. No date has been set.

Judge Robert Atherton granted permission in October for the hearing to be held in public, but it can only now be reported for the first time.

Brady and his partner, Myra Hindley, were responsible for the murders of five children in the 1960s. They lured children and teenagers to their deaths, with victims sexually tortured before being buried on Saddleworth Moor above Manchester.

Pauline Reade, 16, disappeared on her way to a dance on July 12 1963 and John Kilbride, 12, was snatched in November the same year. Keith Bennett was snatched on June 16 1964 after he left home to visit his grandmother; Lesley Ann Downey, 10, was lured away from a funfair on Boxing Day 1964; and Edward Evans, 17, was killed in October 1965.

Brady was given life at Chester Assizes in 1966 for the murders of John, Lesley Ann and Edward. Hindley was convicted of killing Lesley Ann and Edward and shielding Brady after John's murder, and jailed for life.

In 1987 the pair finally admitted killing Keith and Pauline. Both were taken back to Saddleworth Moor in 1987 to help police find the remains of the missing victims but only Pauline's body was found.

Hindley died in jail in November 2002, aged 60. Brady has spent the last 25 years at the high-security Ashworth Hospital.

Brady, who was born in Glasgow, wants to be transferred to a Scottish prison and be allowed to die.

The hearing will be a rare chance to see the Moors Murderer in public.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

Moors Murderer Ian Brady will have his mental health tribunal hearing held in public, a judge has ruled. It will be only the second time that such a hearing has been held in public. No date has bee...
Moors Murderer Ian Brady will have his mental health tribunal hearing held in public, a judge has ruled. It will be only the second time that such a hearing has been held in public. No date has bee...
Filed by Michael Rundle  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 54
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:12 on 11/12/2011
I notice that another of my comments has not been allowed by the self appointed lefties who monitor H & P. Appart from that their aweful system creates CPU Overload..Send them back where they belong ..the useless states of america !
09:11 on 11/12/2011
when he tells Winnie where her child is give him what he wants but not until then he knows where that babe is...its his last way of holding on to something....but let the swine die after he has given that mother peace to bury her son decently...in fact euthanise him...he is no good to anyone ...what those two did to those children was horrendous...I don't forget what I read and this would be only half of what went on...bless you Winnie and your family pity this has come at Christmas it must be so hard for you all...he knows what he is doing the sly swine chose the time well didn't he...our thoughts and blessings are with you and you family...
20:59 on 10/12/2011
When you take away the human rights of another such as the rights of these children to grow up and live a safe and happy life then your own rights should be taken too. To think how much money both he and Hindley have cost the tax payer to house, feed, entertain and give medical care to over the years not to mention the legal fees. The UK is too soft on criminals.If the death penalty can't be brought back then I say have those who are against the death penalty pay for the living expenses of the murderers and pedos ....... I suspect then that many would switch sides to pro death penalty pretty fast.
19:20 on 10/12/2011
For those on here calling for the return of the death penaly, just look at a couple of cases that have been in the news in the past week - The "Cardiff Three" involved 3 people wrongly convicted of the murder of Lynnette White, and a man has now been charged with the murder of Rachel Manning, six years after her fiance was released from prison, having also been wrongly convicted of murder.

In both cases, had the death penalty been in force, 4 innocent people would have been dead and any posthumous pardon would be small comfort to their families.

State sanctioned murder is never justified (and can't be reversed on appeal!)
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tracingagent
18:12 on 10/12/2011
I have heard the tapes, and seen the photographs involving Brady & Hindley when I attended a CID Course at Mather Avenue, Liverpool whilst serving in the Lancashire Constabulary.
Both of these 'monsters' should have been executed, and anyone who says they should not need to see a shrink.
I will never forget what I saw, and what I heard.
18:10 on 10/12/2011
Why not a public execution?
17:31 on 10/12/2011
I note some ( many) comments are removed on this topic. I also not comment are allowed on this but not on other things. To my mind there can be nothing in this world more abhorrent than child murder, And yet comment on it we may.
To say the allowing or not comments policy on Huffington Post needs explanation & radical clarification ( is questionable ) puts it at its mildest.
We, the subscribers, are being treated with great contempt !
11:15 on 11/12/2011
Tell us clearly which can & cannot be commented on & if not commentable, why not !
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
17:22 on 10/12/2011
hang the filth
16:38 on 10/12/2011
Keep him in Ashworth Hospital, as a pateint he will continue to be force fed, let him into the prison system and he cannot be prevented from starving himself to death. Let Hell wait a little and give him the misery of a life which is denied the right to choose death as an option.
11:20 on 10/12/2011
What Hindley and Bradey did were awful crimes. Had there been the death penalty, Brady would be dead and would not be carrying out the punishment for his crimes. He would have been forgotton as would those poor children who he murdered.

The threat of the death penalty does not stop people killing. See the article about the former policeman. The threat of the death penalty would not have stopped him from what he pobably did to his family and neither does it stop other murders. It is noticable that at the time of writing, nobody has made any comment on that thread, probably because it was so shocking.

As for revenge, locking up people, taking away their liberty is what a civilised society does.

If one of my family had been subjected to some of the things that Brady did, I would want the worst for him. But it is society as a whole who determines the punishment and that is the way it should be, or else we would be going back to burning witches at the stake.
14:51 on 10/12/2011
the death penalty for muder was abolished in 1969 and ever since then murder has risen every year ( fact ) . the death penalty will not stop people killing but it will stop muderers being released to kill again and this has happened many times in the past . as for being a civillised society well think again as the crime figures in the uk show somehting else . i would say that we have very soft judges and thats a big problem in the uk . getting back to brady if there was any justice he would have died years ago he and hindley were vile and evil
16:41 on 10/12/2011
This is not a fact. What is a fact is that child murder has stayed at a fairly constant level. The death penalty does not deter child killers,
01:15 on 10/12/2011
how sad..these childrens families must relive that horrible again..they should be flogged and dipped in tar..or simply hang them by the gallows..pure scum..these children never got to live to adulthood instead their lifes were cut short..rip...with respect luka..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christos Palmer
Χριστός Παλμερ
23:05 on 09/12/2011
Hasn't he died yet?
21:04 on 09/12/2011
That picture is nearly 50 years old, I doubt he looks like that now, he could possibly walk down the street unrecognised!
This comment has been removed.
20:11 on 09/12/2011
Its a tragedy that these two sub humans were ever spawned, but sadly, they were. It was a tragedy they ever got together to do the heinous things they did.
It was a tragedy that they were sentenced just about a year after capital punishment was banned in the UK. Three weeks in the condemned cells, a short walk, bags over heads and a rope round their necks, trapdoor opens, vermin are dead, unmarked grave in quicklime. God bless all the parents whos kids they murdered, THEY had life sentences, their kids were sentenced to death, Hindley and Brady got life, thats not justice.
16:46 on 10/12/2011
The problem is that they are not sub human they are all too human. Part of the problem is that we see them as monsters when they are sick, pathetic, deluded, psychopaths. But if they hadn't been caught Hindley and Brady would have been the quiet couple next door.