Wind Turbine Fire During Scottish Gales Was 'Freak Incident'

Wind Turbine Fire

First Posted: 09/12/11 14:15 Updated: 09/12/11 14:15   PA

Renewable energy experts have dismissed an incident where a wind turbine caught fire in gale force winds as a "freak" occurrence.

The 328ft (100m) tall turbine, at Ardrossan Wind Farm, near the A78 in North Ayrshire, was destroyed after it exploded into flames which could be seen "far and wide".

Charles Anglin, of RenewableUK, the trade and professional body for the UK wind and marine renewables industries, stressed that wind turbines were regularly subjected to "some pretty tough conditions" without problems.

He said: "There's some pretty freak weather going on and any piece of large power generating equipment can be subject to freak accidents or mechanical faults.

"But there's an excellent health and safety record, and it was only a small fire in a field that was put out before the fire brigade got there, and no one was hurt. In stressful situations any power equipment may develop faults, and that's true of gas, nuclear, oil, and is also true of wind."

Forecasters said conditions would offer some respite from the hurricane winds which have battered parts of the country.

Scotland and northern England have been the worst-affected areas with a top wind speed of 165mph recorded on the summit of the Cairngorms in Aberdeenshire on Thursday, according to the Met Office.

It led to thousands of schools closing and cut off power to tens of thousands of homes, but forecasters said the worst of the winds will be confined to north-east Scotland and the Shetland Isles. All major bridges were closed in Scotland as wind blew over an articulated lorry on the A87 in Glenshiel in the Highlands, but the driver was not hurt.

ScottishPower said it had reconnected more than 18,000 customers who lost power because of more than 100 individual faults. Meanwhile, Scottish Hydro said that at the storm's peak, around 105,000 customers were left without power as a result of more than 400 separate major incidents affecting the electricity network in the north of Scotland and Western and Northern Isles. It said work was continuing to restore electricity to more than 70,000 customers.

Meanwhile, PricewaterhouseCoopers warned that the bad weather could be cooling the Scottish economy by around £100 million as the early closure of shops, power outages, road closures delaying or halting deliveries, and employees taking time off take their toll.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

Renewable energy experts have dismissed an incident where a wind turbine caught fire in gale force winds as a "freak" occurrence. The 328ft (100m) tall turbine, at Ardrossan Wind Farm, near the A78...
Renewable energy experts have dismissed an incident where a wind turbine caught fire in gale force winds as a "freak" occurrence. The 328ft (100m) tall turbine, at Ardrossan Wind Farm, near the A78...
Filed by Felicity A Morse  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
21:56 on 18/04/2012
This comment is being processed and should appear shortly.

The real story here is that the power lines to a nearby nuclear plant were also blown down in the wind storm costing Scotland an estimated 17 gigawatts of generating capacity.

With 165,000 wind turbines around the world and 185 'wind turbine fire incidents' counted by anti-wind group Caithness (including an unrelated electrical panel fire and a telephone pole fire on wind farms), this amounts to less than 0.001% likelihood of a modern wind turbine catching fire in its 20 year life span.

While spectacular video, wind turbine fires are irrelevant.
http://www.quora.com/Wind-Power/How-significant-was-the-Ardrossan-wind-turbine-fire/answer/Mike-Barnard
21:54 on 18/04/2012
The real story here is that the power lines to a nearby nuclear plant were also blown down in the wind storm costing Scotland an estimated 17 gigawatts of generating capacity.

With 165,000 wind turbines around the world and 185 'wind turbine fire incidents' counted by anti-wind group Caithness (including an unrelated electrical panel fire and a telephone pole fire on wind farms), this amounts to
09:25 on 27/01/2012
feel free to correct me but these blades are made of fiber glass , under heavy loads fiber glass suffers stress cracks .
09:20 on 27/01/2012
some one has not done their home work this happens more often than not !
08:38 on 10/12/2011
no it was not a [freak accident ] quite a few of these over rev in high winds and the motors burn out :
21:33 on 09/12/2011
It is either a result of foreign engineering or someone forgot that you reduce sail in stormy weather?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
00:59 on 10/12/2011
Foreign engineering? Surely engineering is engineering isn't it? The engineering may be flawed, hence the failure but not simply because "it's foreign" ergo it must fail as a result! .......thats tantamount to some kind of racism isn't it?
09:24 on 10/12/2011
May be I should have said manfacturing?
09:25 on 10/12/2011
Or Design???
21:20 on 09/12/2011
One burst into flames a couple of years ago in Yorkshire and lost its blades - it had been struck by lightening - and several have had blade failures due to hidden faults in the blades leading to creeping fracture and eventual failure - but 4 failures out of circa 4000 turbines in operation the UK is fairly insignificant .

The real interesting test would be for example the failure rate in Denmark that has thousands in operation for many years - the Danes are the world leaders in this technology - their number of failures and the reasons for the failures would give a usefull insight into the long term viability of the technology - it might be safe to over design for up to 200 mph winds .
22:27 on 09/12/2011
not only the danes but norway has a tricky little number that turns saline and freshwater in electricity. FANFREAKYTASTIC
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
00:42 on 10/12/2011
A tree at the bottom of our garden burst into flames, it too had been struck by lightening! Some of the trees at the bottom of the garden have been there for many decades, one came down in the great storm of '86, the reason for this? it was very windy. The long term viability of trees however remains intact, this is due to the superior design characteristics, honed over many generations but the occasional failure will still occur due to factors we are unable to determine at this time although some unsubstantiated theories have been proposed an element of mystery remains and the truth is we may never have a definitive answer except to say trees will be trees!
19:48 on 09/12/2011
I would have thought the wind would have blown the fire out:O)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
00:04 on 10/12/2011
Whereas I wouldn't have. ;-))
19:23 on 09/12/2011
And so it begins. To how many more turbines will this 'freak accident' happen, one wonders? Yet another example of corporate greed producing expensive, shoddy rubbish and triumphing over commonsense. Winds of this speed will become more frequent (if we are to believe what we hear about climate change in the first place) and so why is the technology not built to the appropriate standard in the first place? Cutting corners on quality costs lives, or will certainly do so in the future if this continues! Freak accident, my eye!
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
18:26 on 09/12/2011
Just had a look at the picture again. Con or mistake? The picture is of another of these massive structures that crashed to the ground during the same day. The Burning turbines were charred and most of the thing was actually destroyed. Freak incident when one turbine fails- What is when 2 fail?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
00:00 on 10/12/2011
Two freaking, freakishly freaky, freakish, freak incidents? "The Burning turbines were charred"......now that kind of thing is freakquently the case and not at all freaky....what is freaking freaky is the word "freak".....and before any of you freaks ask......I am.... frequently!.....so what?
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
20:53 on 14/12/2011
And your point is?
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
18:23 on 09/12/2011
My earlier comment was in response to lone wolf who appears to have a political agenda although I can't see why?
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
18:20 on 09/12/2011
Great idea Install wind turbines on every residential home. In the Tornada belt? Did you read the article. These things are unreliable and you would have car workers making them! Besides all that the American government have opted out of CO2 reduction and can't subsidise renewables. Oil rules apparently.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Mickey Mouse 1
There are no lies or deceit on a chess board.
18:03 on 09/12/2011
The turbine was probably embarressed about how much taxpayers money is being used in subsidies to make wind generation viable..
17:51 on 09/12/2011
I suspect a bearing or bearings wornout, I wonder how often they are checked. probably too costly to replace aswell,the truth is i dont think this energy source is sustainable. You never hear the truth on these matters, but I suspect the right questions are never asked, aliboy
17:48 on 09/12/2011
Moral of the story do not shelter under a wind turbine in a storm, You are safer under a hedge or wall?
19:18 on 09/12/2011
In reality you're probably safer camped next to a conventional power station - or even, I suspect, a nuclear one, bar earthquakes and tsunamis, and they're an awful lot rarer in Scotland than high winds.

The renewables spokesman's excuse of "some pretty freak weather going on" is very feeble. About every ten years is not "freak weather": it's uncommon, certainly, but worryingly regular nevertheless.