Frozen Planet Row: Mark Thompson, BBC Director General, Says Newspapers Giving TV Show A Hard Time After Leveson

Frozen Planet

First Posted: 13/12/11 19:56 GMT Updated: 13/12/11 21:16 GMT   PA

Newspapers are giving wildlife series Frozen Planet a hard time in revenge for the BBC's coverage of the Leveson Inquiry, director-general Mark Thompson has suggested.

The BBC has been criticised for "fakery" after including scenes of a polar bear with her newborn cubs which were actually filmed in a zoo, without informing viewers on screen.

Speaking to MPs, Mr Thompson quoted from a newspaper editorial and alluded to the story being prominence in retaliation for BBC coverage of the hearings into press ethics. He said: "I do rather wonder whether this was about polar bears or Lord Leveson and other matters."

Footage of the cub was made in a zoo and was mixed with real wild scenes.

Veteran broadcaster Sir David Attenborough defended the material, saying it would have been too dangerous to film such scenes in the animal's den. He said including an explanation in the narration would have ruined the atmosphere.

Speaking to the Media Select Committee, BBC Trust chairman Lord Patten said: "The alternative would have been either dead bears, or dead people with cameras." He pointed out the story behind the footage had been publicly available on the BBC website since November 7.

Mr Thompson added: "Those that want to find out how it's made can find out how it's made."

They told MPs that just 32 people had "raised an objection" to the way the footage had been included in the show.

Mr Thompson said: "For the overwhelming majority of the public there is no evidence that it was spoilt for them. And moreover when we asked them the question about whether they want to be reminded constantly about how the programme is made as it goes along, they said they would prefer that we didn't."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

Newspapers are giving wildlife series Frozen Planet a hard time in revenge for the BBC's coverage of the Leveson Inquiry, director-general Mark Thompson has suggested. The BBC has been criticise...
Newspapers are giving wildlife series Frozen Planet a hard time in revenge for the BBC's coverage of the Leveson Inquiry, director-general Mark Thompson has suggested. The BBC has been criticise...
Filed by Dina Rickman  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FanaticRealist
Romney's Dog: 21st Century Schrodinger's Cat
10:59 AM on 12/14/2011
If the press want to give the BBC a hard time by way of "revenge", they can send their paparazzi and journalists to the Arctic Circle and see what happens when you confront a polar bear in its own environment.

It would be more entertaining than the Olympics. Give the journo a 100-metre head start and see how long it takes for the bear to have him/her on a griddle pan with some chips and broccoli on the side.
10:11 AM on 12/14/2011
Sets ups and camera trickery have long been a part of Television. I can recall the BBC explaining how scenes were captured, sometimes in a studio, because getting actual footage in the wild would be virtually impossible.

So much of programming is television-centric. Go to a live event and the view will be nothing like it is on television.

I can recall the fuss about the Chinese use of CGI in the opening ceremony for the Olympics. The fact was that not a single live spectator could actually have experienced a shot apparently from a traveling plane or helicopter and the only ones to view this tracking shot were the television audience who would have no way of knowing whether the shot was real or manufactured unless they were told.

Are these delicate flowers who complain also concerned that in many weather reports the forecaster is standing in front of green screen and pointing at nothing when delivering a forecast?
06:53 AM on 12/14/2011
For the sake of openness, the BBC should have indicated that it was a mock up in the text of the film. This is not the way to do things and once again shows the governance issues at the BBC are in need of a radical overhaul. - Jermey Clarkson, Jonathon Ross, Russell Brand and others.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
fumes
Midnight Toker
11:05 PM on 12/13/2011
a reality program..

made up to look like ''reality''..

for consumers.

well that's never happened before..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
minimemo
Can I be your friend...if they let me out...
10:54 PM on 12/13/2011
I was more offended in the perpetuation of the climate change myth!
10:03 PM on 12/13/2011
Some BBC boss should have had the nous to declare immediately that all future versions would be captioned, over relevant scenes, saying filmed in zoo etc. Arrogance of BBC is such they did not choose to do so and kill the story. Thus this pointless carry-on.
photo
AlanDente
Noses: made to hold glasses
11:37 PM on 12/13/2011
It's not arrogance to stick to your thought-out position just because it's not as easy as folding and apologising for something you don't feel you need to apologise for.

The papers have dictated what is right and wrong for long enough. Time to stand up to the bullies with reasoned argument.