REVIEW: 'Sherlock Holmes:A Game Of Shadows' - Robert Downey Jr, Jude Law, Noomi Rapace,

First Posted: 16/12/11 16:04 GMT Updated: 19/12/11 12:02 GMT

When the first Sherlock appeared at the cinema, the welcome surprise was that Guy Ritchie, whose career had appeared to experience waning success in inverse proportion to his marital status - had NOT messed it up.

Instead, his proven metier - the swift, close-up depiction of violence and slip-of-the-eye detail put to best effect in Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels - seemed to have found a natural home in providing this master detective with a fresh, vivid treatment.

There's a lot more here of what we enjoyed the first time around. Sherlock Holmes (Robert Downey Jr) and his sidekick Dr Watson (Jude Law) continue their bumbling efforts to foil Victorian villainy, using Holmes' peerless powers of deduction, Watson's resilience and loyalty - and when all that fails, a swift left hook.

This time, with an obviously bigger budget in director Guy Ritchie's purse, our pair's efforts take them much further afield than the picturesque London of the first - to Austria, Paris and, finally, the Reichenbach Falls in Switzerland.

Any self-respecting Holmes-o-phile will recognise this final destination means our hero is destined for a showdown and so it proves - Moriarty is indeed in the building.

Make no mistake. With all the action around them, firing muskets, collapsing watchtowers, this is really one big bromance between Holmes and Watson. There are women around, but they are dispatched with casual abandon - in the new Mrs Watson's case, literally thrown from the train, momma-style - until they team up with exotic foreigner (played with panache by original Dragon Tattoo star Noomi Rapace).

This makes for a Road to Morocco affair, with our team increasingly camping it up along the way. Downey Jr has all the tools of a serious actor - his face is astonishing, capable of conveying compassion, mischief, sadness, arrogance and love.

But he's also an astonishing ham, and here, aided by a dress and a fast-moving train, he's in his element. No wonder there's talk of a Some Like It Hot remake for these two.

There are some new players. As well as Rapace, Jared Harris is uncharismatic but capable as an early-revealed Moriarty. And Stephen Fry slips seamlessly into the team, and out of all his clothes - yes, really! - as Sherlock's more conventional brother Mycroft.

And Ritchie still loves his toys. Huge set pieces are shoe-horned into the narrative, with a few scenes going on a bit too long to get in all the effects, sometimes at the expense of the pace. But the stringey music zips along, and Jude Law isn't annoying. This is great, pre-Christmas family fare.

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows is in cinemas from today. Here are some stills from the film...

1  of  7
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
Noomi Rapace, Robert Downey Jr and Jude Law star in Guy Ritchie's 'Sherlock: A Game of Shadows'. Photos: Warner Bros

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK ENTERTAINMENT

When the first Sherlock appeared at the cinema, the welcome surprise was that Guy Ritchie, whose career had appeared to experience waning success in inverse proportion to his marital status - had NOT ...
When the first Sherlock appeared at the cinema, the welcome surprise was that Guy Ritchie, whose career had appeared to experience waning success in inverse proportion to his marital status - had NOT ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:50 AM on 12/23/2011
It's not Sherklock Holmes and Watson is NOT a "sidekick". You're thinking of Roy Rogers and
Trigger. This has nothing to do wiith Sherliock Holmes. Would you go see it if they called it, "Downey
and Friends"? Maybe. I hope the Doyles are not in trouble but, if not, they gave away several Historical
characters, stories and respect,. Read Conan Doyle. Start with "The Valley of Fear", altho Holmes
comes in about 2/3 of the way. It won't matter. Then, "Sign of Four". And no one else did "Basker-
vills" better. This is like Bush in a flight suit. No matter what you call it, it is--or is not.
10:19 AM on 12/21/2011
The fact that the first was a cheesy waste of time, leads me to not want to see this one.
05:58 PM on 12/19/2011
I hated it. But I'm not a Sherlock fan and that's why. But to give it due credit. Guy Ritchie did an excellent job directing. Best directed film I've seen in a long time.
05:45 AM on 12/23/2011
This is NOT Sherlock Holmes. And Watson is NOT a "sidekick". You're thinking of Roy Rogers
and Trigger. Read 'em. Really. Holmes is not, "Oh, literature, I have to read it". Trust me, have I ever steered you wrong? Are you going to hang THAT over me forever? One time..., Jeez. OK, OK,start with "Valley of Fear". It's not horror stuff, just taut and taut well. Holmes doesn't arrive for
2/3, but it's fine,. Then, "Sign of Four" AND NO ONE ever repeated "Baskerville"as well.
Compliments were rare for Watson but, Holmes was heard to say,once, to Scotland Yard (not Lestrade),"If I were in a fight, with the odds badly against me, I would want Watson there. He's
staunch, fearless,quick thinking, and was the best shot in India". (Of course Watson would ask, "Exactly HOW BADLY AGAINST YOU"? Watson was not a"Trump"). Would you go to this movie called, "Downey and Friends"? So, go on. No kiddin'. I'll circle back. AVRAM
07:07 PM on 12/17/2011
Amazing how polished the feel of this film is compared to the first; Richie has found his stride. Read my full review: http://bit.ly/rYKc0X
05:38 PM on 12/17/2011
the first film was an ok film in its own right, i just thought if he rewrote everything why did he bother calling them sherlock and dr watson? robert downey jr is nice as always.
he's just not sherlock. the best sherlock to me is jeremy brett in the granada series, and today a close second and rightdown brilliant is cumberbatch for bbc.
03:21 PM on 12/17/2011
Watched the movie last night, and have to say there were moments when I burst out laughing - very unexpected:) I felt the characters were more settled in their skin, giving space for relaxed performances. I don't agree though, that Jared Harris was uncharismatic, rather his tight lipped, suppressed rage was quite convincing. The dullest villain, ever in history, had to be Mathieu Amalric in The Quantum of Solice! OMG! I was sooooo scared he might steal my bottle of Evian....dull as ditch water.

Guy Ritchie's talent seemed to have returned since not under the spell of the Wicked Witch of the West.......'''I'll get you my pretty ones, and your little movie too!!!!'''

Anyways, yes, good movie treat and now looking forward to MI3 - Ghost Protocol x
01:14 PM on 12/17/2011
I never even read any Sherlock Holmes book but I loved Guy Ritchie movies like Snatch and Rock n Rolla ... so I didn't know what to expect when I saw the first Holmes movie. I liked it quite a lot, but worried about the new one being a 'Sherlock Holmes goes to Europe' remake.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheWanderer
Above us only sky
05:00 PM on 12/16/2011
Moriarty.