Affair Baby At Risk Of 'Honour Killing' Must Be Adopted, Says Court Of Appeal


First Posted: 21/12/11 11:58 Updated: 21/12/11 12:14   PA

A baby at risk of becoming the victim of an "honour killing" because she was born as the result of her Muslim mother's secret affair must be adopted to keep her safe, the Court of Appeal ruled today.

Three senior judges rejected a bid by the one-year-old girl's natural father to have her come and live with him and his wife.

The child's natural mother is in favour of adoption so that her own family will not find out about the birth.

Lord Justice Munby, Lady Justice Black and Lord Justice Kitchin said in a joint judgment the case involved "exceptionally difficult adoption proceedings".

The judges imposed unusually wide reporting restrictions banning the publication of all names and locations linked to the case because of the continuing dangers faced by mother and child.

The appeal court rejected an appeal by the father "F" against a decision of High Court Family Division judge Mrs Justice Parker last July refusing him a residence order allowing the baby to come and live with him.

The judge ordered that "baby Q" should be adopted by a couple, also Muslim, from the same country as the mother, but from a different community.

She found there would be "a very significant risk of two and two being put together" if the child went to the father because Q was quite obviously not the child of his wife, who had a child of her own.

If the child's maternal grandfather found out about the affair "it would be a matter of intense almost unimaginable shame to him and his family", said the judge.

The appeal court said today: "It was plainly the judge's view that this might provoke action to preserve the family's honour."

The mother had consented to the adoption by the couple, who had been looking after her since December 2010.

The appeal judges ruled: "In the particular circumstances of this case, the judge rightly regarded the risk of physical harm to Q and M (her mother) as being of major importance."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

A baby at risk of becoming the victim of an "honour killing" because she was born as the result of her Muslim mother's secret affair must be adopted to keep her safe, the Court of Appeal ruled today. ...
A baby at risk of becoming the victim of an "honour killing" because she was born as the result of her Muslim mother's secret affair must be adopted to keep her safe, the Court of Appeal ruled today. ...
Filed by Paul Vale  |  Report Corrections
 
 
  • Comments
  • 162
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
20:47 on 27/12/2011
Wow.

Talk about respecting the father's rights.
13:22 on 22/12/2011
It seems my comment saying that Britain doesn't want Muslim extremists was removed, it seems then that the people that run our lives ie the media want Muslim extremists because it good media.
15:53 on 24/12/2011
Islam does not give permission to any individual to kill a family or clan member based on belief that the victim brought dishonour upon the family, clan, or community. Only the Islamic Court can carry out the punishments set out by the Shariah.
20:52 on 24/12/2011
And this evil group Shariah or set of laws seem to think that they are bigger than the law of the land.

They have no part in our Britain.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
floodberg
Attorney (ret.)
04:15 on 22/12/2011
HP MODS, I POSTED A COMMENT AN HOUR AGO. 

AND AN EMAIL TO TECH AND MODERATION.

PLEASE DIG IT OUT OF THE DIGITAL TRASH AND POST IT. 

IT'S CLEAN, OT, COMPLIES WITH YOUR REGULATIONS.
02:35 on 22/12/2011
murder is what it is..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PimlicoTab
00:53 on 22/12/2011
And the fathers rights are at the bottom of the pile, as usual!
00:49 on 22/12/2011
Everyone who is allowed to enter the UK to live should first be made to understand the spirit of our laws and general rules. They should then sign a covenant to say that, regardless of their birth country's laws or customs, they will abide by our laws, as we would have to do in their homeland. Failure to do so should then automatically result in deportation, after appropriate punishment, back to their country of origin regardless of any dangers they may face, or ties they have here. If they have family here then that family have the option to return with the deportee to that country.
I don't care what religion ,colour or creed they are, if they wish to settle in our country then respect us and our laws.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
23:32 on 21/12/2011
difficult situation, right outcome. But why Muslim? stop this nonsense now!
23:12 on 21/12/2011
I find this staggering..considering the father wanted to have his child live with him. Just because the judge thought there might be people who wanted to harm the child..she will now have to live in adoption?
I know there has been cases of honour killing within certain communities..but surely this is taking the biscuit? The judges in this country come up with some strange rulings. No one would harm that child even if they knew about her roots...and if they did i'm a judge somewhere would give them a slap on the hand and a couple of years in a 5 star jail.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PimlicoTab
00:52 on 22/12/2011
Honour killing is practised even in the UK. Why did I give consent to using the word honour, this is just plain murder. These people do not belong here..................
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Scairp
09:13 on 22/12/2011
It's been practised in the U.S as well. There are very few cases that I can think of but it has happened here. It shouldn't happen anywhere and to think that even in the 21st century women and children have to worry that their own families would kill them over some archaic idea of family honor being sullied is simply appalling. Will these people ever drag themselves out of the middle ages?
23:08 on 21/12/2011
Why are we importing this medieval barbarism.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
saviour1263
22:02 on 21/12/2011
Oh for gods sake HP all i said was there is a law against threatening children ,there is a law against murder ,there is a law against hurting children ,this child has human rights and should not be in hiding for fear of having these broken ,where are these rights ,the man should not be allowed too hide in anonimity ,if he is a danger too babies children adults then he should never be here ,this "man" should not be in a civilised society ie .....ours
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
saviour1263
21:44 on 21/12/2011
So if i got this right a baby has too be in hiding for the rest of his / her life because a man might kill them ,isn't there a law against this type of thing ,doesn't the childs "human rights" count for anything .There should be a petition to get this so called " man" out of the country as he is dangerous too children ,you can't just murder someone or threaten it , every "animal" that supports murder (honour killings) should not even live in a civilised country .
22:28 on 21/12/2011
She won't be in hiding 99.9.9999999999999999% of the worlds population will know her for who ever she is.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
saviour1263
23:00 on 21/12/2011
This isnt right tho is it ,we are a civilised country that is being kicked back to the stone age and the government are doing nothing ,this type of thing doesnt belong here ,therefore the man doesnt belong here , noone should be living in fear of "honour killings" not in this country , what is the government in "power" for ,why are they ignoring whats looking at them in the eye , put this with everything else and what do you get corruption going to the very top ,murder,MPs expenses , banking corruption, the EU, immigration, and so much more, how much more can the citizens of this country take without something breaking .
21:20 on 21/12/2011
There is no religion in the world that supports forced marriage or honour based violence. Honour violence is a crime.
There is no honour in the commission of murder, rape, kidnap and the many other acts, behaviour and conduct which make up "violence in the name of so-called honour".
21:19 on 21/12/2011
One thing is for sure, Muslim here or any where else in the world, are believer of such belief of honour killing. If their female fall in love with other faith male/female they would kill their son/daughter.They rule their kids lives by fear policy and when the kids do go out, they actually carry that out. Islam was rulling people on name of fear of death if not adopted or excepted Islam.

Yes it is the case but for boys Muslims, what they say? Go and get her ruin her if she do not except Allah rule? Why Muslims cannot except other faith when their daughter or son marry other faith male/female?

God is for all and one thing is for sure different country have different god and it is true as much name of Allah, Christ and rest so why Muslim cannot except this facts?

Just like Muslims wish their kids must learn their Holly book after school, why don't they teach their kids along side their holly book to say it is sin to follow other male/female for relationship and affair or marrige?

Fairness must be for all and equal so pray and pray for peace for all kind.

How many time we have learn honour killing when their male/female go away from their religion and marry others? Few time other faith male/female we have read but most of the population is most of them are Muslims.
21:26 on 21/12/2011
@godchild, your post was so infested with grammatical & spelling errors, whatever you were trying to say eventually got lost in it
21:16 on 21/12/2011
LOL @ ENGLAND

THEY GOT WHAT THEY DESERVED.
21:00 on 21/12/2011
IM A MUSLIM AND IM AGAINST HONOUR KILLING.... BUT STOP PICKING ON MUSLIMS..

YOU'D BE SURPRISED TO WHAT HAPPENED DURING THE TIME OF MOSES AND JESUS (PEACE BE UPON THEM)

LIVE AND LET LIVE
21:37 on 21/12/2011
you have had a pop at me , so pls watch this an give me your veiws , www.youtube.com/watch?v=-KWeDHEPvuU
00:47 on 22/12/2011
You need to tell your muslim community, live and let live.Certainly not the rest of us, who abide by the law of the land.
Remember Ken Bingly? The twin towers, the London tube, the London bus attack. Along with the numerous crimes articled in the press.Honour killings belong in an uncivilised age or country. I am absolutely sick of hearing about these benefit cheats who preach against our soldiers and our way of life and when faced with deportation, squeal they cannot leave this country for fear of their lives in their beloved muslim countries. Where is the respect from muslims to Christians, non existant. You say "stop picking on muslims" , unfortunately its the other way around. When was the last time a Christian here in the UK abducted a muslim and beheaded him? Never happened and not likely to either, as well you know.