Single-Sex Classes Are 'Better For Girls', University Of Essex Research Claims

Single Sex Classes

First Posted: 27/12/11 12:39 GMT Updated: 27/12/11 12:45 GMT   PA

Girls do significantly better in single-sex classes, research claimed today.

The academics who compiled the research said that girls who showed less confidence in the classroom may also be less competitive in the job market.

The research was carried out on around 800 economics and business studies students at the University of Essex.

The research was designed to build upon the findings of earlier experiments with school-age pupils which showed girls were more willing to take risks and to be competitive when placed in single-sex groups.

Last year researchers Dr Patrick Nolen and Professor Alison Booth divided first-year undergraduates into three groups for introductory courses in economics - some all-girls, some all-boys and some mixed.

And while there was no effect on the exam scores of the boys' groups and the mixed groups, the girls' groups saw a 7.5% boost in their average marks.

A major part of that improvement was linked to attendance - girls were much more likely to turn up for classes if they were placed in single-sex groups.

On average, girls in single-sex groups attended 71% of the compulsory classes, while girls in mixed groups attended just 63%.

That explained about half the difference between their scores and those of girls in mixed groups.

However, the experiment showed that while single-sex classes for girls led to better exam scores, there was no significant effect on their coursework marks.

Dr Nolen, of the university's department of economics, said women and girls who were risk-averse might be less likely to compete for promotion at work in the future, and that could affect their chances of success.

"I would like to see policy makers think about this," he said.

"We should be investigating it and intervening pre-market in the environment in which students learn."

The university students were asked if they were willing to take part in an experiment, but were not given details of the research.

Student Corina Musat, 20, said that when she was placed in an all-girls' group she simply assumed there were more girls than boys on the course.

"I think the atmosphere was more friendly and we bonded because we were all girls," she said.

Undergraduate Emilia Matei, 20, said: "I think it was the best class I had last year.

"I don't know whether it was because it was a single-sex class or whether it was the teaching.

"In the all-girls' class, you didn't have to have that much courage to go to the blackboard and answer the question."

The earlier experiments on which this research was based were conducted with 260 teenagers from two girls' schools, two boys' schools and four co-educational schools in Suffolk and Essex.

They showed girls who went to single-sex schools were more competitive, even when they were in a mixed-sex environment.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

Girls do significantly better in single-sex classes, research claimed today. The academics who compiled the research said that girls who showed less confidence in the classroom may also be less com...
Girls do significantly better in single-sex classes, research claimed today. The academics who compiled the research said that girls who showed less confidence in the classroom may also be less com...
Filed by Michael Rundle  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kehlan Sutai Inigan
06:00 PM on 12/28/2011
This is not really new. I remember being told this over 20 years ago while still at school. "Girls tend to do better academically when there are no boys in the classroom to distract them. Boys on the other hand tend to do better in mixed classes as they try to impress the girls...." ( no, I dont have the facts and figures to back up that statement, Its what a teacher told me when I asked why some schools still segregate the sexes. I just offer it as evidence that the concept is not a new one)

Actually, if the research backs that up, it sort of creates a difficult situation.... girls do better without boys, but the boys need the girls to do well... its sort of hard to have it both ways. I'm not sure if I would like to say which system is best.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
onwisconsin
Trust women; protect choice.
11:44 PM on 12/27/2011
Every other major study has shown the exact opposite. It will be interesting reading.
11:24 PM on 12/27/2011
This is great! I would imagine that single-sex education of boys / young men will also have a similarly positive effect on them.
09:17 PM on 12/27/2011
Why does the image show a couple of immigrant kids? Whats wrong with showing indigenous students?
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
07:47 PM on 12/27/2011
Better? Life is about a lot more than test scores.

The teachers should take special care to help the shy kids, all the shy kids, learn to stand up in front of an audience, the class, the teacher and work effectively. This is a vital job and life skill.

The toastmaster teach folks how to do this for instance, and it should be a part of kids early teaching.
11:50 PM on 12/27/2011
You are so right, Genders! I couldn't have said it better myself. Why are they measuring the success of these experiments according to competitive spirit? That's the first thing that struck me as wrong here. We shouldn't be teaching our kids how to compete with each other, we should be teaching them how to get along with each other, how to solve problems together, and other important life skills. As you mentioned the ability to speak up for yourself is something that has to be developed in some kids....I was one of them. I was well into adulthood before I realized that not speaking up actually caused more problems. I also was in an experimental classroom in the 8th grade (1969-70 aahhhhh!!!!). We had homeroom with the boys but the rest of our day was split. I don't think we were more competitive but I'm sure we were more attentive, as much as 13 year old girls can be! It was interesting and I found it much less distracting.
And then there are the kids that should be taught when to be quiet and listen. That is also a necessary life skill.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nicky Hardy
Keep it 100
03:14 AM on 12/28/2011
Genders and Angela you both said it right. I made so many mistakes in my teens and 20's due to lack of social skills and not speaking up for myself.
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
05:03 AM on 12/28/2011
FF. you got it. I had to learn to shut up. ;)