Minimum Price For Alcohol: David Cameron Orders Plans To Curb Binge Drinking

David Cameron

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 28/12/2011 11:18 Updated: 30/12/2011 18:29

David Cameron has ordered plans to be drawn up for imposing a minimum price for alcohol, overruling the advice of health secretary Andrew Lansley, more than a year after he first promised to take action.

According to the Daily Telegraph, the prime minister wants a 40-50p minimum price per unit of alcohol in shops and supermarkets in England as part of a "big bang" approach to tackle Britain's boozy culture, with a Whitehall source saying Cameron believed "something pretty radical" had to be done to tackle the issue, and that the "voluntary approach has not worked".

The news comes some 16 months after Cameron said he was supportive of local councils imposing minimum prices on the sale of alcohol, although with the move looking to cost drinkers an additional £700m a year - the extra tax revenue will go to the NHS - not everyone is happy.

Lansley, for one, was reported to favour that voluntary approach, and has previously warned that a legal minimum could breach European competition rules - a view shared by the business department.

An alternate system that taxes drinks based on the number of alcoholic units is also said to be under consideration and is preferred by Home Secretary Theresa May.

A government spokesman said that "no decisions" had yet been made on the forthcoming alcohol strategy.

The alcohol industry reacted angrily to the plan. A spokesman for drinks company Diageo told the Financial Times that there was "no credible evidence from anywhere in the world that it is an effective measure in reducing alcohol related harm".

However supermarket giant Tesco has previously said it would welcome moves to impose a minimum price. In 2010 Lucy Neville-Rolfe, Tesco's director for corporate affairs, said it could "deal with the problem at the lower end".

The SNP administration in Scotland is currently attempting to push through legislation for a minimum price.

The suggestion that a minimum price could be imposed has also drawn the ire of some Tory backbenchers. Philip Davies told the Daily Mirror the proposal was “the most ludicrous thing the government has ever suggested”.

But the move was welcomed by some local health professionals including Debra Malone, public health consultant for NHS Bolton, who said she was "highly supportive" of the plan.

“It would help protect the most vulnerable, particularly young people who at the moment can buy alcohol with their pocket money," she told This Is Lancashire.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

David Cameron has ordered plans to be drawn up for imposing a minimum price for alcohol, overruling the advice of health secretary Andrew Lansley, more than a year after he first promised to take acti...
David Cameron has ordered plans to be drawn up for imposing a minimum price for alcohol, overruling the advice of health secretary Andrew Lansley, more than a year after he first promised to take acti...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 116
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dombeyandson
10:01 on 02/01/2012
"...David Cameron has ordered plans to be drawn up for imposing a minimum price for alcohol, overruling the advice of health secretary Andrew Lansley..."
WIll this mean only the traditional reprobates will be able to afford to drink in the future? What about MPs and their subsidised bars in the Commons? Soon the price will be out of reach and drunk as a lord will have real meaning.The higher price may be having an effect in some parts of the UK as it is becoming selective and the numbers who can afford it will reduce. Where does Big Dave - call me Dave get his ideas from - Marie Antoinette? [who didn't make any reference to cake apparently]
19:02 on 31/12/2011
50p a unit isn't going to make my particular brand of beer any more expensive, it contains 1.2 units and cost 70-80p a bottle from a supermarket when it's on offer so I look at this quite strangely.

Firstly I haven't seen the evidence upon which they're proposing this but I doubt it will work, the problem with people getting blind drunk in our streets happens as much in pubs and more often clubs than in the streets themselves, minimum price isn't going to change this.
Secondly 'binge drinking' is a stupid term because people can binge drink and still be sober enough to walk straight.
Thirdly it's the way people use their drink which needs addressing, people drink to get blind drunk, rather than drinking because they enjoy the drink or the social setting into which it's drunk, tackle these issue rather than keep taking our money.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
ideaville
I have sexdaily, I mean dyslexia, Danm!
21:22 on 29/12/2011
They reckon that a minimum of 50p per unit will save 2000 premature deaths per year.
Well, how about all in extra benefits an extra 2000 people per year will cost?
Why not leave things as they are and not penalise the many for the behaviour of the few.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
21:35 on 29/12/2011
Let 2,000 people die so that you can buy cheap booze? Are you being serious? Please say you're not.
This comment has been removed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
ideaville
I have sexdaily, I mean dyslexia, Danm!
22:33 on 29/12/2011
When you put it like that, it makes it sound selfish :)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
forestnfama
Woodstock Veteran
09:51 on 29/12/2011
Solution......legalise pot.....
photo
My Mate Pat
Nobody's Nationalist
09:37 on 29/12/2011
I can afford to drink at the proposed prices, but what gives me any more right to get sloshed than anyone else. Is it fair that the government can legislate to limit access to oblivion based solely on the ability to pay an artificially inflated price. Of course not.

This is just bad legislation that will not have the effect claimed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
13:40 on 29/12/2011
In the places it has been tried, it has had an effect for the better. I would expect that to be the case here too.
14:19 on 31/12/2011
Worth pointing out that measures like this are quite reversible - or revisable - if they don't turn out as planned. There is always a "law of unintended consequences". I recall back in the 1970s we all told ourselves that keeping the pubs open longer would result in more civilised drinking habits, and it seemed a fair argument at the time......

The case for this policy has been well made and it deserves a try. If problems arise, let's discuss that to do about them.

And if in the end it has got us all thinking about how we use alcohol, is that a bad thing? I speak as one who is very fond of the stuff, BTW.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
08:16 on 29/12/2011
Minimum ministerial competence hasn't gone so well, but why not try the same plan somewhere else.
07:27 on 29/12/2011
welll we are getting closer and closer to being a MUSLIM state THAY dont want us to smoke / drink / own and drive a car . with the spred of MASS IMMIGRATION great areas of towns and citys are now transformed in to no go areas . thay dont want us to use energy. i think we are going back to the days of the 18th century . it will be cheeper to use candles for lighting and a horse and cart to get about. WE MUST STOP THIS. PPL WE MUST HAVE A NEW PARTY IN POWER . the old way of voting for the BIG THREE PARTYS MUST COME TO A END . WE ARE IN NEED OF A STRONG AND JUST GOVERNMENT ONE THAT WILL NOT COMPROMISE . AND PUT RIGHT THE WRONGS THAT GOVERNMENTS PAST AND PRESENT HAVE DONE TO US amen
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:34 on 29/12/2011
What does minimum pricing of alcohol have to do with anything in your post?
07:45 on 29/12/2011
my post is just a take on how the powers that be MAKING us change the way we live .WERE IS THE RIGHT OF FREEDON TO CHOOSE what we want to do . and dont you see what MASS IMMIGRATION is doing to this country .
20:45 on 29/12/2011
bet your an snp supporter
20:44 on 29/12/2011
spot on could not have put better myself
00:17 on 29/12/2011
I think the reason most people like to have a cheap drink is because they can't afford to go to the pub or a restaurant or even maybe the theatre or cinema no more. The Government has drained us all dry with tax, vat inflation in general. i took 2 pay cuts & then was made redundant all the time the prices of everything goes up in price. SO MR. CAMERON, YOU WANT TO TAKE AWAY THE LAST CHEAP ENJOYMENT WE CAN ALL HAVE & MAKE OUR LIVES A COMPLETE MISERY BY INCREASING THE PRICES ON CHEAP BOOZE???? YOU MAY ASWELL TAKE EVERYONES WAGES & GIVE US OUR POCKET MONEY!!!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
23:53 on 28/12/2011
The Tory Taliban are never happy unless thety are taking away the rights and few enjoyments left to working people in the UK and turning our lives into one big Myseryfest.
Lord Elpus
If you're going through hell, keep going
00:20 on 29/12/2011
Exactly how many rights and enjoyments were we left with after the last lot had finished trying to control every aspect of our lives then? The seeds of the Miseryfest to which I think you refer were sown a long time ago.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:35 on 29/12/2011
It's a Myseryfest Accumulator !!!
21:16 on 28/12/2011
Would it not be a better idea to limit the amount of alcohol someone can buy?
Anyone who goes to a pub or club, usually buys 1 pint or 1 of whatever they their favorite tipple is.
At a supermarket you can buy as many gallons of whatever you want.
I was talking to our local Councillor the other week, and within a half a mile radius there are 17 establishments with alcohol licences, all off licences.
There is absolutely no control over these premises, who sell alcohol to anyone, including under 18's at times.
If a pub or club were to do this they would be closed down, and rightly so too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ppenguinator
Life's too imprtant to be taken seriously.
21:52 on 28/12/2011
After buying their maximum amount from one shop, what would stop them from going to the another?
20:11 on 28/12/2011
The France run will be back on again.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
19:47 on 28/12/2011
I couldn't agree with this more - so long as it becomes reality rather than PR posturing.

Some time ago I bought a bottle of cider - it was 3 litres, at 7.5%, which isn't far from being as much alcohol as a litre of spirits. It cost me £2.99 to buy enough alcohol to knock most people out. It was only a week or so later I started noticing plastic bottles in bushes, and abandoned at bus stops.

Anybody who can afford to drink, can afford to pay, say 50p per unit.
19:17 on 28/12/2011
what are this government after taking the country in to bankruptcy why pay those prices when you can buy a lot cheaper abroad no uk tax or duty its about time they all went mind you they dont care cameron on his 1million a year and half of his purchases paid for by us cause he is working well getting pissed in parliament how many of us get paid to drink and go on holiday
17:43 on 28/12/2011
The lads where I come from are laughing all the way to the bank.They deal in the black market be it alcohol or ciggs,and if he keeps putting the prices up then they will branch out into that category.I have said it before and I will say it again,if the toffs in government keep hitting the poor then they will always find a way around it.
I know that they have been talking about the fuel if the government keeps putting it up.As for the shopkeepers before someone jumps in and states they are losing business,wrong,There are certain shops where you can buy under the counter and I for one do not blame them.
17:26 on 28/12/2011
THE ANSWER IS TO STOP BUYING IT FOR 6MONTHS AND TEACH THE PLONKERS THAT PRETEND TO BE ON OUR SIDE A FEW TRICKS OF OUR OWN.