Strictly Come Dancing: Who Will Replace Alesha Dixon?

Kara Tointon And Karen Hardy

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 04/01/12 10:55 GMT Updated: 04/01/12 13:07 GMT

Now Alesha Dixon has jumped reality show ships to join Simon Cowell on the Britain's Got Talent panel, the bets are on for who will replace her as the only female judge on the Strictly Come Dancing panel.

Some fans are calling for the reinstatement of Strictly's original female judge Arlene Phillips, who was controversially axed in 2009 in favour of Dixon.

At the time, BBC One controller Jay Hunt said in defence of Arlene's replacement: "As a former Strictly champion, Alesha knows exactly what it takes to win.

"Her eye for great performance and her charisma and charm make Alesha a great addition to the judging panel."

But fans were outraged that Phillips' experience as a dancer, choreographer, theatre director and talent scout was cast aside for a younger model.

Yesterday Phillips reacted to fans' calls for her to return, writing on her Twitter page: "Gosh twitter followers and friends.

"I am overwhelmed by your incredible tweets campaigns and Facebook messages. So much love and thanks."

However, ex-Strictly professional dancer Karen Hardy is currently the bookmakers' favourite to fill the vacancy.

William Hill is offering odds of 4/6 that Hardy will join Len Goodman, Craig Revel Horwood and Bruno Tonioli on the panel for the next series. The ballroom pro competed on Strictly from 2005 to 2008, winning the 2006 competition with Mark Ramprakash.

However, The Sun reports that Kara Tointon, who won the show in 2010 and is engaged to Strictly dancer Artem Chigvintsev, is the BBC's favourite to replace Dixon.

Other stars in the line-up are Dirty Dancing actress Jennifer Grey, who put in a guest stint as a judge on the most recent series, and Russell Grant who stole the show with his cannon-exiting antics. Jill Halfpenny and Darcey Bussell are also in the running.

All of these prospective judges have shorter odds than Phillips, so she may have to accept her time on Strictly is over for good.

Quick Poll

Who do you want to replace Alesha Dixon?

VOTE

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK ENTERTAINMENT

Now Alesha Dixon has jumped reality show ships to join Simon Cowell on the Britain's Got Talent panel, the bets are on for who will replace her as the only female judge on the Strictly Come Dancing pa...
Now Alesha Dixon has jumped reality show ships to join Simon Cowell on the Britain's Got Talent panel, the bets are on for who will replace her as the only female judge on the Strictly Come Dancing pa...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 32
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
10:32 PM on 01/04/2012
I'm told that Davina McCall, Cheryl Cole and Carol Vorderman are among those who've applied so far and have been rejected. And I am told that ITV executives are looking to negotiate with two younger ladies, but will give no clue as to their identities, however a final decision is expected shortly.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:59 PM on 01/04/2012
i think karen hardy coz she's a professional dancer so she will know what she's talkin about- jill halfpenny, kara tointon, jennifer grey, and russell grant may have danced but don't have the full knowledge of what it takes to be a top knotch dancer and darcy bussell is good but i don't think she can get away from ballet :D also i think arlene, as much as she wants to return won't coz she's left it behind now :(
04:17 PM on 01/04/2012
Why is the BBC obsessed with age and beauty, yes Kara Toynton is a very beautiful woman, but she is an actress not a dance expert, she very deservably won in 2010 and was a delight to watch, but,think of all the unsavory comments Alesha Dixon got when she joined the panel it wouldn't be fair to subject Kara to that, the public are very fickle and although they loved her as a contestant, think they could put her down as a judge, and lets face the BBC only want her as eye candy, please bring in someone who knows what they are talking about but please please not Jennifer Gray who was rubbish
03:41 PM on 01/04/2012
Arlene Philips at the age of 38.6 should be bruoght back.
Her experience in the entainment industry is phenonmenal.
04:02 PM on 01/04/2012
Your guestimate of our dear Arlene's age is in jest right? She was in her 30s when choreographing Legs an Co on TotP in the 80s! The Beeb should not replace Alesha, keep the panel at 3 until the quarter finals than have an extra, guest, judge. Three works just fine on the US version and other countries' versions.
04:35 PM on 01/04/2012
I have nothing against Alesha, I thought she has already made a career move.

I don't know the history of Arlene , I am just going by her looks but then you can 't tell with people nowadays. I added 0.5 for magin of errors.

I think your suggestion is reasonable about a guest judge.
03:38 PM on 01/04/2012
I think Kelly Brook should replace Alesha. Kelly was about to give her a run for her money in the show Alesha won, until she had to pull out because sadly her dad passed away. It would be a good turn of events for her and make things even.
03:26 PM on 01/04/2012
Arlene should come back! End of.
03:17 PM on 01/04/2012
Perhaps Bruce could do it, he always seems to have a lot to say, he could also do his presenting, along with jokes, singing and a bit of dancing. While he is at could take over as PM and there must be a place at a bank for him at the weekends he could practice to qualify for the Great Britian 100m Olympic team.
03:16 PM on 01/04/2012
Please not Kara Tointon she'd be even worse than Alesha, and she'd be just a little bit biased judging her fiancee
04:03 PM on 01/04/2012
Even if unintentional her judgements on Artem would be deemed biased by teh audience. She really couldn't take overunless Artem left and personally I'd much rather he stayed - yum!
03:09 PM on 01/04/2012
can the BBC also get rid of Bruce Forsyth as well
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:01 PM on 01/04/2012
he might be goin coz i heard rumours of vernon kay replacin him :(
03:07 PM on 01/04/2012
do not care who it is as we will not be viewing it again. It is all a fix. Anyone noticed craig 99% of the time votes one less than the others who all vote the same.
04:04 PM on 01/04/2012
Rubbish
02:55 PM on 01/04/2012
Ok so Alesha is pretty, and that was what she was picked for, she knew nothing about the finer points of dancing and was a failed pop sta,r she really just parotted the other judges..... Karen Hardy was a mutli champion and must be the choice.... While their at it, get rid of that old dinosaur Len and his stupid lens
04:08 PM on 01/04/2012
Len is the only panel member able to properly judge ballroom and latin dance - it's his living. Bruno and Craig are ex showdancers and currently choreographers so their expertise is on elements of performance. Alesha's role was the voice of the lay person, i.e. viewers, and as a previous (winner) competitor she knows the stresses and understands the experiences of the celebs. So each judge has a defined role. Although it's nice for the viewers' point of view to be covered I don't think it's essential and the show could easily go forward with a 3 judge panel - that's be several 10s of thousands of pounds freed to put into other aspects of the show - decent guest performers for example.
02:40 PM on 01/04/2012
Let's think of Alesha Dixon as a blip. Arlene Phillips or Karen Hardy would give the show some prestige.
cantabria
my default position is wrong
03:20 PM on 01/04/2012
That's not a bad idea, get rid of Len and have 2 gays and 2 girls
02:37 PM on 01/04/2012
Just not Kara. She seems like a nice enough girl, but a professional would be good! Also, wouldn't it be difficult if she was marking her fiance / husband? We don't want Artem to leave...
02:03 PM on 01/04/2012
Karen Hardy. She is the most professional with the charisma to match.
04:10 PM on 01/04/2012
Would have no objection to Karen being a judge - that would give 2 experts in ballroom/Latin and 2 theatre/dance choreographers - so a balance of opinion would be achieved.
01:58 PM on 01/04/2012
It's great that Alisha is finally going. Anybody will be an improvement.