Tom Harris, Labour MP, Resigns New Media Adviser Role After Downfall Gaffe

The Huffington Post UK   Dina Rickman First Posted: 16/01/12 11:29 GMT Updated: 16/01/12 15:00 GMT

Labour MP Tom Harris has quit his post as the party's new media adviser after posting video comparing the comments of an SNP MSP to the last days of Hitler.

The three minute youtube video, which spoofs the 2004 film Downfall about Hitler's last days, was titled 'Joan's Downfall' and parodys comments made by MSP Joan McAlpine who claimed those who did not vote SNP were "anti-Scottish".

But after talks with new Scottish Labour leader Johann Lamont the MP for Glasgow South quit, saying his actions had been an "unhelpful distraction."

"Having spoken to Johann, I have decided to step down from leading the party's social media review," he said.

"The video I posted has been a well worn joke used to parody a range of public figures.

"However, context is everything and in the context of Johann's and my desire to improve the level of political debate on social media and the context of Joan McAlpine's much more serious statements about all political opponents of the SNP being anti-Scottish, my actions have been an unhelpful distraction for which I apologise."

The SNP called the video tasteless and embarrassing.

"It is hugely embarrassing for Labour that one of their MPs and a leadership contender - who should have better things to do with his time - is promoting tasteless stuff like this through his official MP website," a spokesperson said.

A Scottish Labour spokesperson added: “Tom Harris did the decent thing after a lapse of judgement. It is about time that Joan McAlpine does the right thing and apologises for her much more serious error of judgement in saying that anyone who opposes the SNP is anti-Scottish. By her own logic, she must see that she regards the majority of Scots as anti-Scottish. If she doesn’t do the decent thing then Alex Salmond should sack her as his ministerial aide.”

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

Labour MP Tom Harris has quit his post as the party's new media adviser after posting video comparing the comments of an SNP MSP to the last days of Hitler. The three minute youtube video, which sp...
Labour MP Tom Harris has quit his post as the party's new media adviser after posting video comparing the comments of an SNP MSP to the last days of Hitler. The three minute youtube video, which sp...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 43
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:22 AM on 01/17/2012
Seems to me they're sacking MPs for all the wrong reasons.
02:04 AM on 01/17/2012
But Dianne Abbott survives even though her twitter comments were no the first time she has made r@cist views known.
10:43 PM on 01/16/2012
I live in the States. If every person over here resigned after calling President Obama "fascist," "Nazi," "Marxist," or "Communist," half of the Republican Party would be gone. It is good to hear that politicians in the U.K. can be shamed into resigning. The words we use should matter!
This comment has been removed.
photo
ScottishScript
"I am not a number, I am a person!"
06:05 PM on 01/16/2012
I personally love the reworked Downfall vids, some of them are hilarious. This one is kind of lame though, too much crammed in and not particularly funny or well synched to the on screen action.

The problem here was Tom Harris’ occupation as the Labour Party’s Media Advisor. Using this Downfall rework to attack another party leader during a particularly testy time in Scottish politics was totally ill advised. His mistake wasn’t that he made some vile remarks, but that he left Labour open to the charge that he did.

He demonstrated quite clearly how oblivious he was to how such a prank could get out of hand in today’s multimedia world. The guy was clearly in the wrong job to begin with.

I’m no Labour supporter, but this is a non story. However the ‘Scottish’ Sun clearly thought otherwise.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:42 PM on 01/16/2012
The problem is explaining an internet to meme to the multitudes who do not know of its history, I agree this is a non-story, and I too am not a labour supporter.

I must say I have seen worse downfall vids, I did like the inclusion of the two women outside the room, you don't get their input on many of them.
06:59 PM on 01/16/2012
I have to turn the sound track off as I understand German it is hard to read an listen in 2 different languages. I enjoyed the Susan Boyle parody of downfall.
05:01 PM on 01/16/2012
Twitter 3 (Abbott, Miliband, Harris) Labour 0
06:37 PM on 01/16/2012
surely that should be 4 (McAlpine).
07:38 PM on 01/16/2012
Would it not be easier to count twitters in reverse order, as you could count them on one hand, and with the corrupt dodgy sods in the previous corrupt government, that would be red handed. Thank God joe public are waking up and won`t be palmed off. mps could be green with pink spots 4 all I care as colour doesn`t matter, so long as they don`t take us 4 fools, and stop ripping us off with ludicrous bullshit. Less passing the buck, and playing lord and lady muck, and more of dealing with matters of real concern!
06:53 PM on 01/16/2012
Update result from Alex Gallagher
Twitter 4 (Abbott o.g., Miliband o.g., Harris o.g., McApline o.g) Labour 0
This comment has been removed.
04:10 PM on 01/16/2012
lifes all got a bit to serious. if you don"t support the SNP you anti scottish ? whats that all about, a bit like germany dictatorship in the years leading up to WW2 and the six years in went on. its was a joke a bit like the SNP, they released a libyian bomber on compassion ? they are trying to get a ref vote around the dates of the battle of the boyne, but 700 years further on, that would be another battle they would lose. Its time all polticians took a look at themselves and have a good laugh because thats what the public do when they think of you. I oppose the last goverment and a lot of what this ones doing does that make me anti english ?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:41 PM on 01/16/2012
"if you don"t support the SNP you anti scottish ?"
That is not what Joan McA. said. Not by a long chalk. Find her actual words then think of the context.
I read the rest of your post and some of it is laughable. The battle thing.. oh dear... try again on that. The SNP didn't release Mr. al-Megrahi on a political whim. His release was a matter of following the law of the land.
I'm not sure how not liking the Westminster government could ever be seen as anti-english. It (westminster) governs England but it isn't England's government as such. It's the UK government which managed to neglect England completely when setting up devolved governments in Wales, N. Ireland and Scotland.
05:00 PM on 01/16/2012
west lothian questioner - as a matter of historic constitutional fact devolved Government in Northern Ireland that was not the choice of Northern Ireland - it was imposed by Westminster under the Government of Ireland Act 1920 - Edward Carson the Unionist Leader wanted all of Ireland to remain under UK rule governed from London - as a consequence he refused on principle the Premiership of Northen Ireland when it was offered to him
photo
ScottishScript
"I am not a number, I am a person!"
04:42 PM on 01/16/2012
Thanks, I read your post and it made me laugh out loud at your historical illiteracy. Are you aware of ‘Godwin’s Law?’ If not Google it to learn something about why bringing WWII and all the rest into this debate.

And what in heaven's name has the Battle of the Boyne of 1680 got to do with the SNP and their referendum dates? Is it possible you were referring instead to the Battle of Bannockburn in 1314?

Everyone makes mistakes, but that one’s a beauty.

You said:” Its time all polticians took a look at themselves and have a good laugh...”

No, I suggest everyone read your post and have a good laugh.
05:09 PM on 01/16/2012
thanks for the history lesson, it never hurts to learn something. or update what was taught and forgotten in long ago school years. i can laugh at myself its a great way to live
if more could do the same it may just be a nicer place to live. Scotish regiments have always served the queen with great bravery. I read with interest ronnience comments about the orgins of the SNP Is this correct ? as two generations ago part of my family left stornaway for london, i should know more about the history of scotland, but the rest of my family were cockneys so i haven"t really shown to much interest apart from celtic which i suppose could make me a irish supporter
03:49 PM on 01/16/2012
It's interesting that Joan McAlpine says if you don't support the SNP you're anti-Scottish, but she keeps her job. While Tom Harris, who spoofs the whole thing, has to walk the plank.

Funny old world, as Eck's hero Maggie said...
04:07 PM on 01/16/2012
And that spoof he chose did the rounds a year ago - everybody was at it. There were dozens on the internet many about H not getting the new i-phone.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:34 PM on 01/16/2012
That isn't quite what Joan McA. said. Find the actual words she used and think about them in their context. Perhaps a bit intemperate, but essentially accurate.
04:53 PM on 01/16/2012
She said on twitter “Interfering in referendum is anti-Scottish as is refusal to compromise on popular desire 4 powers to Scotland.”

and then "The issue here is the behaviour of the anti-independence parties coming together to seek to stop Scotland having a referendum at a time of our choosing."

Of course interfeering in the referendum is not anti-Scottish. How can it be? And how can "Scotland" be stopped from having a refgeendum? Who chooses..? Not "Scotland"?

When she says "...parties coming together to seek to stop Scotland having a referendum at a time of our choosing.", just who exactly is "our", if not the Nationalists.So Scottish="our"=SNP

And how can you accuse people of "anti-Scottish behaviour" but not being "anti-Scottish"?

I think Ms McAlpine suffers from the common Nat failing of thinking that anyone who opposes them is "unpatriotic".

All that said, always steer clear of Hitler.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
uksnapper
01:48 PM on 01/16/2012
Clearly he knows nothing about copyright laws so it is right that after demonstrating the sum total of his knowledge he should be dismissed
05:52 PM on 01/16/2012
meanwhile the british judiciary are trying to extradite a young man to the states for not committing this offense, but I suppose its more to do with whose pockets you're in rather than whether an offense was committed or not.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
uksnapper
06:05 PM on 01/16/2012
The extradition treaty is a joke and I can not understand why its such a one way treaty. The USA can demand extradition without trial or proof of guilt in the UK but the UK is powerless to extradite from the USA.
Spineless gutless politicians out to feather their own pockets and damn the voters., or am I missing something ?
06:47 PM on 01/16/2012
Its not like it is original. This clip has been used to lambast sevaral football teams, politicians etc.
In fact it was used against Gordon Brown several years ago.
Typical Labour politician they have to steal other peoples material, just like they are doing with the Tory party's policies at the moment.