HMRC Writes Off Nearly £11bn In One Year Of Unpaid Tax, Finds Public Accounts Commitee

Hmrc Unpaid Tax

The Huffington Post UK   Dina Rickman First Posted: 7/02/2012 06:31 Updated: 7/02/2012 07:31

The Treasury was "shocked" to find that HMRC had written off up to £10.9bn in tax in a year, according to the head of the influential Commons committee.

Margaret Hodge told HuffPost UK that the Treasury was "taken aback by the figure".

The figures were revealed in the government accounts for 2009-10, scrutinised by the public accounts committee (PAC). It is the first time the government has released such figures, which took 20 months to prepare.

Giving evidence to the PAC, top treasury official Sir Nick Macpherson told MPs: "That is a lot of money, you are right to draw attention to that. I know that this committee regularly holds Her Majesty's Revenue And Customs (HMRC) to account."

Hodge, whose committee has previously criticised HMRC for "sweetheart deals" with big companies said tax had become a "key issue."

"It's the first time they've ever done this [released accounts] so we should welcome that. They've never put together everything the government spends over time.

"All the criticisms are in the context of this welcome advance. I think we were pretty taken aback by what it shows you. What one hopes is that government, the executive will now look at some of these figures and think about them before they take policy decisions for generations to come."

Hodge also called for government to include banks and Network Rail in their accounts, saying: "They should put Network Rail into the accounts. It's entirely funded by the taxpayer and they should be accountable to our scrutiny."

The figures also reveal that the government was liable for up to £15.7bn in outstanding clinical negligence claims, would need to pay up to £131.5bn in the future under PFI schemes, and had a public sector pensions liability of over £1,132bn.

MPs on the committee said they were "surprised" the Treasury didn't have a "grip" on trends such as clinical negligence.

"The Treasury now has the potential to strengthen the management of public finances if it uses the WGA to identify influences on the government’s financial position, including where it is most exposed, and uses these to better anticipate the risks that it must address. The Treasury must use this opportunity better to manage these risks," they recommended.

Emma Boon, campaigns director of the Taxpayers' Alliance said: “It’s fantastic to see even more information published showing how the Government spends taxpayers’ money. Greater transparency will make it easier for members of the public to hold the Government to account. Taxpayers have a right to know what big financial decisions mean and it should be clear what our liabilities are for things like public service pensions and PFI.”

A Treasury spokesperson said: "No other country has sought to fully consolidate all public sector bodies, including the local government sector, in one statement of accounts. We will build on this first publication and are working hard to remove any qualifications," a spokesman said.
"HMRC collects almost all tax debt and write-offs are relatively low. What's more, around 90% of those write-offs are due to insolvency where further debt pursuit is actually barred by law."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

The Treasury was "shocked" to find that HMRC had written off up to £10.9bn in tax in a year, according to the head of the influential Commons committee. Margaret Hodge told HuffPost UK that the Tr...
The Treasury was "shocked" to find that HMRC had written off up to £10.9bn in tax in a year, according to the head of the influential Commons committee. Margaret Hodge told HuffPost UK that the Tr...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 41
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:54 AM on 02/08/2012
When you owe the tax man a little its your problem, when you owe them a huge amount its their problem.
11:51 AM on 02/08/2012
Why is the country not surprised at HMRC writing off £11b in one tax year? Why does the country accept that we have one of the most costl;y, inefficient and customer-unfriendly rail transport systems? Or, that our transport system grinds to a paralysing halt after a cold snap? Or, that our defence strategy has built two aircraft carriers without any planes to use them? Or, that our education system fails to educate effectively, across all streams of children? Or, that in this time of austerity, it is the front-line services that are being cut - nurses, doctors, policemen, bin collections, libraries, social care provisions, welfare for the needy, etc etc
Simply, it is the way we are governed, with layers of civil servants and committees, a culture of risk aversion that costs £billions to implement and police, AND that we have leaders who are incompetent or unable to manage 'BIG' organisations like major offices of State, the NHS, HMRC, etc etc Until this is recognised and addressed, we will continue to have poor service, with costly mistakes, and a country with the biggest overdraft it has ever had! Change it!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Vapula
Failure is not an option
03:10 AM on 02/08/2012
Tax avoidance in the UK is big business and there is nothing to suggest that it will not continue unabated. Sweetheart deals are just the tip of the iceberg.
11:26 PM on 02/07/2012
All for transparency...thank you! But do not like what I see......
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barbara Longstaff
11:56 AM on 02/07/2012
Everyone should pay taxes and no one should get away with it. Confiscate their businesses and run them and when the tax has been paid then give the business back to them but make sure they have to work in the firm until they do. Maybe then they will appreciate that they have to pay tax. Mine are PAYE so they are taken out before I get my money, maybe a certain amount could be done with firms so at least the Tax Office gets an amount of what the firms owe. Until this debt has been cleared no bonus should be paid to anyone in the firm.
11:47 AM on 02/07/2012
HMRC NEEDS REORGANISING FROM TOP TO BOTTOM & BOUGHT UNDER CONTROL.
aT PRESENT THEY JUST DO WHAT THEY LIKE,ALLOWING CERTAIN COMPANIES TO PAY LOWER AMOUNTS THAN THEY ACTUALLY OWE BY NEGOTIATING SPECIAL ARRANGEMENTS WITH HEAD OF HMRC.
Tthese companies have accountants who work out how much tax is due & they should pay what is due & HMRC should in no way allow a discount
Us mere mortals have to pay our taxes without being able to arrange a discount so why should they
11:47 AM on 02/07/2012
The Tax officers and the Government should ensure that Companies pay their taxes when due, any failing to do so will remove their right to pay bonuses until debt cleared. This rule should apply to all companies including all banks as if it was not for the Country baling out the banks / building societies with financial problems the remainder would have been under significant pressure as well. The banking system was totally supported in its hour of need by tax payers money and as such they should be paying off the debts they owe, as well as the taxes they seem to be able to avoid very easily.
I am of the mind to not pay my taxes as I am in need of financial support otherwise I will not be able to buy a new car (never owned a new one), a new coat (mine has a worn inner lining), or even take a holiday(last actual holiday was 1998) or even subsidise my dependant daughter (no help from the government whatsoever), or subsidise my son through college...
11:39 AM on 02/07/2012
Like many others I have just paid my income tax a few days ago. Had I ignored it would it have been written off or would I have faced a hefty fine and possible jail term?
Issues here need to be resolved when Britain is in such a poor state
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mickbono
huff is crap
11:04 AM on 02/07/2012
yet they still persecute the unemployed the disabled & oap`s putting them further in poverty , yet there pals dont pay billions in tax & they do nothing about it . i think were all in this together , what a load of bull manure
11:44 AM on 02/07/2012
I still had to pay £400 on my pension or be prosecuted
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mickbono
huff is crap
01:55 PM on 02/07/2012
i pay around £300 on mine yet there is £11 billion not collected
10:44 AM on 02/07/2012
And that`s just from the MPs, all you ordinary people out there will still have to pay !!
10:42 AM on 02/07/2012
So why did I have to pay my Corporation tax to be in the HMRC account by the 1st Jan 2012 when it was a public holiday and by the looks of things many other HUGE companies are just not paying anything at all. ?????????????????????????
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:31 AM on 02/07/2012
I wonder how much was written of in Sweet heart deals with the big companies....
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-16253205

Another £8 BILLION so that is £18 BILLION lost to the HMRC. Imagine a company making £18 BILLION write off.
£300 for every man woman and child.
Pursue the sweetheart deals and at least claim some money bac
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:30 AM on 02/07/2012
So when the big business declares a certain amount as a Tax payment, then the HMRC write it off in a sweetheart deal. So where is this "sweetheart deal tax money" added? As a Profit ? Bonus? or what. This money cannot not be "unaccount" for.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
10:14 AM on 02/07/2012
"90% of those write-offs are due to insolvency where further debt pursuit is actually barred by law."

Shouldn't that be at the top of the article? Granted the treasury are high on the list when receivers break up bankrupt companies to repay creditors, but it still accounts for a lot of the write-off.
11:17 AM on 02/07/2012
The problem is how many of those "insolvencies" are artificial and specifically created in order to write off debts, before the business assets are bought back by the same directors with a nice clean slate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
11:52 AM on 02/07/2012
That actually just happened to me last week! A client tried to screw me for £1,300 by declaring her company bankrupt. Very underhand. Foolishly she had let slip details of her 'new' company, so I can still chase payment.
10:06 AM on 02/07/2012
Add this to the £70 billion of Tax that is "avioded" each year and we could soon pay off our debts.
10:05 AM on 02/07/2012
Just goes to show how much of a mess labour put us into. 2 yrs after they lost power, and they're ballsups are still coming out
03:51 PM on 02/07/2012
It's got nothing to do with Labour, it's been going on for many years and is just now coming to light with more clarity in the accounting procedures. The Inland Revenue had been shambolic for years but somehow they've got away with it and this is all coming to light in the merged Department HMRC which is an even bigger joke.