Richard Dawkins And Archbishop Rowan Williams To Go Head-To-Head Over Origins Of Man

Richarddawkinsarchbishopsplit

First Posted: 10/02/2012 15:36 Updated: 10/02/2012 15:39   PA

The Archbishop of Canterbury and atheist Professor Richard Dawkins are set to go head to head to discuss man's greatest question.

The leader of the Church of England will meet Britain's most famous non-believer to take on the complex subject of "The nature of human beings and the question of their ultimate origin".

The pair - who may be unlikely to find much common ground - will be joined by philosopher Sir Anthony Kenny at the event at Oxford University.

The discussion, which organisers expect to be "invigorating and enlivening", is fully booked but will be streamed live online on February 23.

The two men have exchanged views on evolution and the existence of God before.

In a programme broadcast on Channel 4 in 2010, Prof Dawkins asked Dr Rowan Williams if he would see God as having any role in the evolutionary process.

Dr Williams said: "For me, God is the power or the intelligence that shapes the whole of that process.

"As creator, God's act is the beginning of all creation."

At which point Prof Dawkins intervened and asked: "So by setting up the laws of physics in the first place in which context evolution takes place?"

Dr Williams replied: "Things unfold within that."

In the programme Prof Dawkins said that Dr Williams uses "poetic language", adding: "There does come a time when you worry that people are going to misunderstand it."

In an article on his website, published earlier this month, Prof Dawkins said of Dr Williams: "My suggestion is that the best way to understand Rowan Williams is to remember that he is a poet.

"And maybe this is the best way to understand other theologians.

"When Williams speaks of 'silent waiting on the truth, pure sitting and breathing in the presence of the question mark', we laugh because we read it through rational spectacles."

In the article, Prof Dawkins suggests that theologians, such as the Archbishop of Canterbury, don't really "understand the difference between literal truth and poetry; or literal truth and metaphor".

He goes on: "And this is where I would take issue with them, because for me a question like "Does God exist?" is not just a matter of poetry or metaphor.

"It has an answer, true or false (which is not to say the answer is easy to discover: it may even be impossible)."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

The Archbishop of Canterbury and atheist Professor Richard Dawkins are set to go head to head to discuss man's greatest question. The leader of the Church of England will meet Britain's most famous...
The Archbishop of Canterbury and atheist Professor Richard Dawkins are set to go head to head to discuss man's greatest question. The leader of the Church of England will meet Britain's most famous...
Filed by Ned Simons  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:01 AM on 02/20/2012
The answer to whether God exists is emphatically *not* 'true or false'. The nature of the existence of a 'supreme being' is obviously of a completely different order to the existence of any other type of thing or being. What does 'exist' even mean, in relation to such a concept? Again, Dawkins ignorance of the fundamentals of metaphysics - a subject that I presume he thinks meaningless - hobbles any attempt at intelligent comment by him. And to cap it off, he doesn't understand what it is that he doesn't understand.
11:30 PM on 02/13/2012
Extremely exciting!

However, I'd encourage everyone to consider the following, in light of recent events:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6ZD8KpPv3k

Thank you!
10:05 AM on 02/11/2012
This debate is going to be good! Rowan Williams is a formidable intellectual who can take on Dawkins. I disagree with what he said about the distinction between literal truth and poetry, things are never really that black and white, Dawkins should stop being so absolutist.
08:58 PM on 02/10/2012
So....where's the supporting links? Where can we watch this streaming debate online?
photo
hearthammer
If left is right and right is wrong, decide!
04:55 PM on 02/10/2012
It's hard to promote commonsense on this one as the religious tend to adhere to dogma rather than science. The best one I heard recently from a religious person was "God exists because you can't prove he doesn't!"