Student Lender Smart-Pig Says NUS 'Out To Get Us' After 'Misleading' Accusations

Smart Pig Nus

Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 16/02/2012 17:16 Updated: 16/02/2012 17:18

A lending service aimed at students has said it is "upset" at the accusation that it misleads customers, arguing student unions are "out to get us".

The National Union of Students (NUS) released a statement on Sunday saying student lenders Smart-Pig should "immediately stop" aiming its services at students.

"They style themselves as a friend of students but in reality they are anything but," NUS vice president Pete Mercer said.

"Some of their tweets are very misleading, even implying the NUS would be supportive of their loans when we have grave reservations about such credit."

The students' union is up in arms about the company charging 855% APR "despite presenting themselves as an 'ethical' leader" as well as incentivising students to borrow.

Lynne Condell, chair of the National Association of Student Money Advisers, also piped in, saying the company was "preying on students who really do not have a lot of credit options available to them".

But Tom Parks, director of Smart-Pig, told The Huffington Post "someone from the NUS is out to get us and I want to know who it is".

He said the company had been "very upset" by the accusations as the NUS had not attempted to get in contact before releasing the statement.

"They have been reluctant to talk to us," he continued.

He added there were a "number of" misrepresentations in the release and the union had "jumped the gun".

"The NUS's claims are contradictory. No payments have been made through our refer-a-friend scheme and new customers are not at any point offered a cash discount or introductory offer."

Smart-Pig was founded by Parks, only recently graduated from Warwickshire, and another individual who is still at university in Hertfordshire, in December.

"Current payday lenders do not service students adequately. If we weren't here they would be forced to go somewhere else. We have had considerable positive feedback."

Parks said there were policies in place to ensure students did not repay above a certain fraction. Although he would not disclose the percentage, he insisted it was an "ethical" amount.

But the NUS argues that students could be put at risk by the service:

"The idea that a payday loan should be the first port of call for a student struggling to make ends meet between loan payments is potentially very dangerous for students," Mercer continued.

He added students should talk to their union or financial advisers at their university about alternative options before considering taking out a loan.

Labour and Co-operative MP Stella Creasy said the incident was "another example of how these legal loan sharks cannot be trusted to act responsibly".

"I urge students not to be taken in by this company," the Walthamstow MP said.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:11 PM on 02/17/2012
Ive had a look at the website too, if you look under how it works I think it displays the risks and what happens quite clearly.
03:31 PM on 02/17/2012
These risks should be displayed right at the start before anyone does anything.

In fact the site probably shouldn't exist.
01:57 PM on 02/17/2012
I saw that the student money site Savethestudent bought up the whole Smart-Pig thing about a month ago and it has gained in popularity.

They quite rightfully said that no students should take out a payday loan without knowing what else is on offer first. I took a look at the Smart-Pig website after this and they don't have anything on there that states the risks!
12:39 AM on 02/17/2012
Nobody should take out any type of loan without knowing what it's going to cost. Don't just blame the lender!
This comment has been removed.
10:16 PM on 02/16/2012
They're all dishonest thieves...and the government stand by and let this happen! Remember we are all in this together...Except the poor and needy, except the vulnerable, except the billionaires. Some of us shoulder all the burden and some of us get off scott free. The masses are completely at the mercy of the 10% or less that have everything. I don't begrudge them anything they have, but why rape the poor over and over again!
11:19 PM on 02/16/2012
Bring back student grants, like they had in my student days in the 60's., However, in order to make the scheme viable, tuition fees should be lowered to zero (as they were when I was a student) and the Mickey Mouse universities which were set up from Polytechnics (by that great friend of Margaret Thatcher, Sir Keith Joseph) downgraded back to polytechnics and all Mickey Mouse courses abolished, unless they can be shown to offer a means of economic growth. Reinstate 'O' and proper 'A' Levels and reintroduce the CSE for the less academic, and, abolish mixed ability teaching which disadvantages the most able. Harsh measures, but necessary to bring British education back to the high standard it once occupied.
03:06 AM on 02/17/2012
100% agree. I know students who now travel each day to UNI and have lectures cancelled, have two minute meetings with lecturers, who don't care and say read the blackboard and do your course work. All for a mere £3,000 plus a year,soon £9,000. Is this value for money? No it's a money making machine for Universities and they should be done under the trades description act. For £9,000 I would want to sit one to one with a tutor and have 24/7 access and free books. As for education to go back in time, sorry we haven't got the teachers with a good enough education to even contemplate this..Because of the destruction of education over the last fifty years.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:21 AM on 02/17/2012
100% agree. Also allow children from 12 years to work paper rounds and from 14 to work up to 16 hours a week any where they wish.
10:11 PM on 02/16/2012
Rip off Britain..it should be illegal and banned. How do these people sleep at night? Just one more warning. If you are offered a credit card, at 13% say...you use it and then max it due to circumstances, the bank offers you another £300, you use this. As soon as you do this the interest rate increases to 21%. Happened to me, so beware, they hook you in and then increase the rates. Lending rate at the mo is 0%..Justify this?
06:25 PM on 02/16/2012
Maybe just maybe, instead of trying to argue their case by making potential false statements such as NUS endorse, etc. they should follow the lead of Wonga, and STOP this practice.

Maybe they would also like to tell everyone what happens when s student defaults, and what debt that alone will create.

It is a good job that OFT is looking at this type of organisations
This comment has been removed.