Huffpost UK Politics uk

NHS Reforms: Tim Farron Says The Bill Should Have Been Dropped

Posted: Updated:
Tim Farron Made The Comments On ITV Granada's Party People Programme
Tim Farron Made The Comments On ITV Granada's Party People Programme

Further coalition tensions have emerged over the Government's troubled health reforms after Liberal Democrat president Tim Farron said the legislation should have been dropped.

Farron said the legislation to implement Health Secretary Andrew Lansley's reforms should have been scrapped or "massively changed" at an earlier stage before it progressed this far and it would be "stupid" to ignore medics' concerns over the proposals.

He demanded that all elements of new competition in the NHS should be stripped from the bill in order for Lib Dems to support it.

Lib Dem peers have tabled a number of amendments to the Health and Social Care Bill, which resumes its difficult passage through Parliament next week in the Lords.

This week has seen an NHS summit at Number 10, criticised by Labour and health professionals for Downing Street's decision not to invite Royal Colleges opposed to the Bill.

Andrew Lansley was heckled in Whitehall by protesters, including a woman who described the health secretary's reforms as "Codswallop".

Speaking on ITV Granada's Party People programme, Mr Farron, said: "Lots of us are guilty for allowing it to get as far as it has done now.

"Basically this should have been dealt with far earlier in the cycle."

Asked whether that meant it should have been dropped, he said: "Dropped, massively changed."

Pressed on what should happen now, Farron focused on part three of the legislation and said: "Take out all the new competition in the bill. If that was to happen then the bill may as well proceed because then it becomes about democratising and tidying up the mess that was left behind by Labour."

Farron added: "What I want is for the Lords to introduce changes that will remove the new competition elements from the bill and I would like the Government to give way on those things. It's all to play for."

His comments came after the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPH) called for the Health Bill to be withdrawn just days after attending a Downing Street summit with David Cameron.

Its president, Professor Terence Stephenson, said the RCPH never supported the bill but it was now clear a substantial majority of voting members believe it "carries risk for children and young people".

He said there was also "deep concern" among the wider health profession and public over the impact of the bill on patient care.

Farron said it would be "absolutely stupid for anybody to ignore what is being said" by health professionals.

The Prime Minister's official spokesman said: "We have said we will continue to listen as this bill proceeds through the Lords, but we had a listening exercise last year and as a result many significant changes were made to that bill.

"We think the reforms are the right ones. It is going to be an ongoing process explaining to people these reforms and, in particular as we implement these reforms, showing how they are working to the benefit of patients."

Around the Web

LDVideo at Conference | Farron on 'Tory bashing', Lamb on NHS ...

In conversation with - Tim Farron - Channel 4 News

Morecambe Bay Hospitals Trust under fire: MP Tim Farron ...

Tim Farron | Facebook

Tim Farron - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Tim Farron

Tim Farron: 'I need counselling to cope with coalition...' - Profiles ...

Tim Farron: Labour 'utterly dishonest' about state of economy ...

Tim Farron (@timfarron) on Twitter

Tim Farron for Lib Dem president | Facebook

Farron urges greater protections for rural cyclists

Liberal Democrat News 24th February 2012

Liberal Democrats sweep the board in Windermere