Chris McManus Killing: Italian Politician Criticises David Cameron

PA/Huffington Post UK  |  By   |  Posted: 9/03/2012 09:43 Updated: 9/03/2012 11:41

Mcmanus
Chris McManus was killed with Franco Lamolinara in Sokoto during an attempted rescue operation

UPDATE: According to Reuters, the Italian President has described British action in the Nigerian hostage operation as "inexplicable behaviour". Rome has demanded a political and diplomatic explanation.


An Italian politician has complained that David Cameron and the British Government took unilateral action in the failed attempt to free a British and Italian hostage in Nigeria.

Chris McManus and Franco Lamolinara were killed in Sokoto during an attempted rescue operation after being taken hostage in the country last May.

In a statement, Cameron said that he had authorised a rescue mission to go ahead today, saying there was "reason to believe that their lives were under imminent and growing danger."

"Preparations were made to mount an operation to attempt to rescue Chris and Franco. Together with the Nigerian Government, today I authorised it to go ahead, with UK support,” he said.

According to Downing Street, the British government was in contact with Italian authorities “throughout the case".

However, Lucio Malan, of the Italian People of Freedom party, questioned why the British government did not inform Italian counterparts of its intentions before launching the operation.

He told BBC2's Newsnight: "It is still to be explained why the Italian authorities were not informed although they are quite present on the territory of Nigeria."

Labour MP Meg Hillier, who chairs the all-party parliamentary group on Nigeria, said: "I don't know how fast moving this was but it does seem odd that an ally like Italy was not actually kept informed and it is important that we find out what happened and that the Prime Minister explains to the Italians."

Mr McManus, a contract worker for the construction company B.Stabilini, had been held by terrorists associated with Islamist extremist group Boko Haram since May last year after being kidnapped from his apartment by gunmen in Nigeria where he was helping to build a bank.

Mr Cameron said: "The terrorists holding the two hostages made very clear threats to take their lives, including in a video that was posted on the internet. Preparations were made to mount an operation to attempt to rescue Chris and Franco. Together with the Nigerian government, I authorised it to go ahead, with UK support."

Exact details of how Mr McManus died in Sokoto, a city in the north-west of Nigeria, remain unclear, but Mr Cameron said initial indications were that the contractor and Mr Lamolinara were "murdered by their captors, before they could be rescued". A Nigerian official claimed the two died in a crossfire during the rescue attempt, but the UK said it was awaiting further details.

Mr Cameron offered his "sincerest condolences" to the families of the hostages, saying they had "endured a terrible ordeal" after details of the failed mission emerged. In a statement, the family of Mr McManus, from Oldham, said they were "devastated by the news of Chris' death" but confident "everything that could be done was being done" during their 10-month ordeal.

FOLLOW UK

UPDATE: According to Reuters, the Italian President has described British action in the Nigerian hostage operation as "inexplicable behaviour". Rome has demanded a political and diplomatic explanation...
UPDATE: According to Reuters, the Italian President has described British action in the Nigerian hostage operation as "inexplicable behaviour". Rome has demanded a political and diplomatic explanation...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 90
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
22:18 on 09/03/2012
Back in the days of the Cold War, it was generally accepted in Nato that you only told the Italians something if you wanted the Eastern Bloc to hear about it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
17:57 on 09/03/2012
If this had been successful, there would be no criticisms of the British prime minister. The British were right to keep the plans to themselves.
13:58 on 09/03/2012
Interesting interview with Philip Hammond on the news.Seems intelligence was comprimised and the two men were killed in the crossfire in a battle that raged for 'a couple of hours'.Hammond made no comment when the interviewer made those statements but didnt refute them
13:24 on 09/03/2012
This is the ONE thing that David Cameron has done right ! The hosteges needed to be rescued, it was unfortunate,that they were killed but there are no certainties in situations that involve terrorists ( or weapons in genral for that matter ),if no action was taken ,he would be criticised for that too !
13:24 on 09/03/2012
with the italians experience of war and their far better trained special forces(famous throughout the world) and their second to none bravery in the field of battle, surely it should have been left in the hands of these experts than to entrust it to the british military. what do they know?
13:32 on 09/03/2012
Ha! Ha! Ha! Nice bit of humour!
13:20 on 09/03/2012
It's so sad that two people have lost their lives and instead of offering our condolences, some people prefer to be maliciously vocal about the prime minister, the Italian government and the local Nigerians involved in the rescue mission. Terrorism is just that and all countries have to unite to beat the terrorists. Of course the italian government should have been kept in the loop of any rescue mission, but as most logical people have commented, the outcome would have probably been the same. Let's show solidarity with all parties involved in the rescue of hostages and show the terrorists that there's no place for them to hide. We MUST remember that the majority of people in those countries are decent people and not all TERRORISTS!!
13:12 on 09/03/2012
NOT WORTH WRITNG A COMMENT IF HUFF POST DOESENT PRINT IT ITS USELESS GET RID OF HUFF
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
13:11 on 09/03/2012
Lets hope that these terrorists that have been caught don't make it to the the UK.
Or they may claim persecution if returned to their country.And we will be stupid enough to accept them.
22:21 on 09/03/2012
My understanding is that Nigeria retains the death penalty. The surviving terrorists will be facing a firing squad.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lord Justice Wolf
13:08 on 09/03/2012
I would bet you any money whatsoever that pillick William Hague had his hand in this botched attempt in some way. Time will tell but its got his name all over it in someway. Anyway they died in a cross fire? So were the Yanks involved at all? Usually there name is somewhere when its friendly fire. As for the Italian government? Well they should have been kept in the picture because one of the hostages was Italian? Makes sense to keep them up to speed with rescue missions.
13:08 on 09/03/2012
unfortunately this is REAL life NOT the movies!! no matter how well trained you are there is bound to be something to go wrong,thats life! had this op gone according to plan there would be rejoicing but as it turned out there is now nothing but recriminations,an operation of this type is always going to carry risks,& it takes but a split second to squeeze of multiple rounds into a hostage & only slightly longer to slit a throat,the Italians are saying they were cut down during an exchange of fire,HOW the hell do they know "were they present??"at the time I VERY MUCH DOUBT IT !!,as far as their comment about NOT being informed this i very much doubt as it involved one of their citizens so a representaive of some form would have had to be,this is a very sad day not only for the familys but also the specials as any failure is a downer,remember if it had gone right everyone would be praiseing them but as its now they are criticising,my condolances go not only to the families but also the guys that did their best,& we do not know if they took casualties ? which is a very good possibility !!
13:04 on 09/03/2012
That is point is Italy is our ally and if it were the other way round, would the British people want to know if their government was contacted, kept informed?
The thing is terrorism is unacceptable, but that no one is arguing about. So the issue must be, should the Italians or their government entrust without question the welfare of their nationals to another government.

Was due courtesy disregarded as some Italian politicians allege here?

So who should inform the Italian parents of their son's death?
PM Cameron did that in the UK informing by phone the parents of Chris Mcmanus, should he also do the same for the Italian victim?

Whatever the speculation, there is supposedly an explanation but, like the Labour MP said, there must be an official explanation to Parliament. We all await.

As for Boko Haram they really need to get upto speed with events around the world. Obviously these act just made their 'little' war much bigger, now they have Major powers to contend with.

Hope the UK steps in further to aid the Nigerian 'forces' stop the massacre of christian or otherwise. Some allege arms from the Libyan conflict have leaked through the porous Niger-Nigerian border.

Nigeria and the UK have large stakes in mutual trade and investment.

Many of us are truly alarmed, perhaps if the attack on the UN offices in Abuja had seen a decisive response from the UN Security Council, Boko Haram might have thought twice.
12:57 on 09/03/2012
where are the brave italian soldiers ??? somtimes there is only minuets to act imagine the time from arranging the op then informing our pm then italian pm getting the ok ect , these poor men where probably already dead, now just get the basxxxds who did it
12:56 on 09/03/2012
Who are the Italians to criticise anyone when they are always the first to turn and run in any crisis. A good example is when the Germans came over the hill into Italy during WW2.
Did they stand and fight? No, the white flag went straight up, then they made a pact with the Bosch and turned against the rest of Europe.
13:17 on 09/03/2012
Your history lacks an awful lot of knowledge. I'll admit that some Italians were of the type you describe. But reading history and talking to many of my relatives who faught them, the majority of Italians were as good as many of the Germans and fought hard and well. You are typical of a 'snippet' person... take 2 or 3 so called facts and making a truth out of them.
14:03 on 09/03/2012
I wish to inform you that my knowledge of this particular history is far greater than yours.
I agree that the artesans were indeed good soldiers but the Italian army were mainly cowards. Believe me I know this to be fact because I was there. I`m 97 years old, and fought in WW2 and because I am old does not mean my memory has faded one little bit!
Perhaps you would be wiser not to beleive all you read, because most of it was written by historians that never saw the front lines or based on stories passed down and exagerated through ignorance or bravado. Even today I have frequent nighmares and hear the explosion of bombs and shells being dropped all around and hear my comrades calling for help or calling out in agony, thats how clear my memory is, just like it was yesterday
Its something that I have never been able to forget..
14:28 on 09/03/2012
I can assure you that my history is far greater than yours. Yes the Artesans were execellent fighters, but the vast majority of the Italian army turned tail and run.
I know because I was there, I may be 97 yrs old now but the horror of what I witnessed during the liberation of Italy will be forever in my mind. You make the mistake of telling me about the history you have read, all written by historians that never saw a riffle or uniform and written by hand me down accounts from people like yourself who got the information through stories handed down, which in turn, tend to be exagerated as the stories are passed around. Even now, I still hear guns exploding and my comrades crying out for help or crying out in pain as they lay injured or dying. Therefore please dont try to lecture me about the Italian army, because I know all about them.
12:53 on 09/03/2012
Listening to the news that two hostages one British the other Italian, have been executed in Africa. Very sad indeed. The Italian's are now asking why they were not informed of the rescue attempt by British special forces. Hmmm things happen fast and indeed it has now been said the hostages were not killed in cross fire but executed before our lads went in. Then again if the shoe was on the other foot I suspect the Italians would prefer to be making phone calls than risking there own lives in combat!
12:45 on 09/03/2012
It's sad that with any failed rescue attempt like this, we always resort to recriminations and back biting. I feel it is wrong that the present Italian representatives were not at least told of the operation, given that one of thier nationals was a victim - how would the British have responded, if the Italians had launched this rescue without informing them? However, we need to remain focussed on the kidnappers - not the attempted rescuers. Albeit sad that the rescue attempt (for whatever reason) was not a global effort, the war against these extremist groups should be. No one nation is being isolated here - there have been German, French, Dutch, Russian, American - no one is safe. We should also recognise the support of those locals who have sometimes lost thier lives in trying to aid these rescue attempts. Put our efforts into supporting these people so that the kidnappers find they simply have nowhere to hide.