NHS Bill: Nick Clegg Should Tell Lib Dem Peers To Kill Health Reforms, Says Harriet Harman

Posted: Updated:
PMQSPLASHCLEGGHARMAN
PA/Getty

Nick Clegg has defended the coalition's controversial NHS Bill during fiery exchanges with Labour deputy leader Harriet Harman in the Commons.

Standing in for David Cameron at Prime Minister's Questions on Wednesday, the Lib Dem deputy prime minister said Andrew Lansley's Health and Social Care Bill would deliver a "more equal" NHS.

But Harman said Clegg should tell Lib Dem peers in the House of Lords to vote against the legislation on Monday in order to make sure it did not become law.

"People are still against this bill because it hasn't changed one bit," she said. "It's still a top down reorganisation."

She told MPs: "He could stop the bill but he wont. He says the Lib Dems make a difference but they don't. What has happend to that fine liberal tradition? They must be turning in their graves."

The Labour Party has been strongly lobbying to get the government to scrap its controversial health reforms which they say are too expensive and introduce too much private competition.

Harman said that Clegg was refusing to "stand up for the NHS" as "the only thing he stands up for is when the prime minister walks in the room".

Clegg hit back by accusing Labour of creating "sweetheart deals" for private sector providers in the NHS while in power, which the coalition was now scrapping.

"The shadow health secretary says it is irresponsible to increase NHS spending. They don't believe in more money for the NHS, we do," he said.

"They presided over inequality in the NHS which again we are making a statutory obligation in this bill to deliver a more equal outcome."

He added: "The Labour Party used to believe in reform, now they believe in starving the NHS of cash and failing to provide reform."

Clegg also dismissed accusations that his party had failed to influence the direction of the Bill.

"Some of her colleagues must think the Lib Dems make a difference because they were handing out leaflets in the conference in Gateshead while her leader was throwing a sickie and going to watch Hull City instead," he said.

Ed Miliband was recently criticised for saying he could not attend a rally on health care because he was ill but then deciding to go to a football match.

live blog

Oldest Newest
@ TimMontgomerie : Hostile #PMQs to Clegg from Tory backbenchers: Redwood on regulations, Lilley on Lords reform, @DouglasCarswell on child benefit

Share this:
@ JananGanesh : Clegg won that

Share this:
@ JoeMurphyLondon : Also interesting how many Tories are tweeting praise of Clegg #pmqt

Share this:
@ trsmith87 : Best PMQs for a while. Proper knock about. #pmqs

Share this:
@ dylsharpe : Unmemorable #PMQs. Clegg did well to repel the qus, when not angry. Harman good at condemning, but may regret tactic of slaughtering the LDs

Share this:
@ Lobbydog : Clegg doesn't even pretend to sidestep the NI question from Skinner. Just completely ignores it. #pmqs

Share this:
@ jamesrbuk : An unusually even-tempered intervention from Dennis Skinner there. Or not. #pmqs

Share this:
@ timfarron : 6-0 to Nick Clegg at #pmqs

Share this:
@ georgeeaton : Clegg says boundary changes are a cause close to the Tories' heart. Hint that it's not close to his? #PMQs

Share this:
@ AnushkaAsthana : Harriet Harman says only thing Clegg stands up for is when the PM walks into the room. BOOM BOOM! #PMQs (Clegg getting angry - love it!)

Share this:
@ GraemeDemianyk : Tory Cabinet ministers Gove, Spelman and Lansley standing in shadows at #pmqs not looking entirely convinced by the Clegg show

Share this:
@ JohnHigginson : Clegg's fourth outing at PMQs is his best yet. Harman's got lots to throw at him but nothing sticking. #pmqs

Share this:
@ EmmaFrancesCarr : Clegg is doing really well. Surprisingly well. #pmqs

Share this:
@ amyelizjackson : Hattie H sounds less shrill than usual. Maybe she learned something from The Iron Lady. #dpmqs

Share this:
@ James_Macintyre : Bizarre: Clegg attacking Labour from the left on NHS privatisation while sitting with Tories.

Share this:
@ toadmeister : @EdBallsMP seems remarkably subdued. No flatlining hand gestures. Has Harriet Harman told him to rein it in? #pmqs

Share this:
@ TimMontgomerie : I always get the feeling that Labour's attacks on Cameron are business but when they go for Clegg it's personal #PMQs

Share this:
@ openurmindnsee : balls has written harman questions, yes? #pmqs

Share this:
@ JohnHigginson : Harman kicks off with unemployment saying women are hardest hit. Clegg (doing very well so far) says went up under Labour by 20% #pmqs

Share this:
@ alexforrestitv : Liz Kendall asks Clegg what went wrong with our economy. He says Labour Govt. #pmqs

Share this:

Labour MP Liz Kendall kicks off the questions by asking "what's gone wrong" with the economy.

Clegg says what went wrong "was the Labour governments for thirteen years creating the most unholy mess in 2008".

Share this:
@ joncraig : Full house for Clegg PMQs on LibDem benches below gangway too. Whole House pretty packed despite PM away in US. Lots of LibDem MPs rising!

Share this:
@ HumeBrophy : Cameron’s spokeswoman tells The Sun’s Whitehall Correspondent "I'm sure the Deputy PM is more than qualified to fill [his] shoes at #PMQs”

Share this:
@ joncraig : LibDems out in force for Clegg PMQs. Danny Alexander & Michael Moore in plum seats on front bench, edging out Ken Clarke & Philip Hammond.

Share this:
@ PoliticalYeti : Cringing already and #PMQs hasn't even started. Fear the DPM will take a hammering from all sides.

Share this:
@ pamela_nash : Flashing my ankles in #PMQs today. Hope @Toadmeister can cope.

Share this:
@ worgztheowl : Lucky for @Ed_Miliband that Dave's away, he'd have so much to go on he wouldn't know what to ask first. #pmqs

Share this:
@ petermbarrett : Willing to bet #Harman tries a 'gag' around #Cameron having been at a baseball game. Something about Coaltion 'swinging and missing' #pmqs

Share this:
@ JonNarcross : Always worth tuning in for... RT @cptjamesmartin The legendary Dennis Skinner MP due to speak on #PMQs at 12:00

Share this: