White Rice Increases Risk Of Type 2 Diabetes, Study Claims

PA/The Huffington Post UK  |  By   |  Posted: 16/03/2012 07:09 Updated: 16/03/2012 07:09

Eating white rice may be linked to a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, researchers said today.

A review of four studies involving around 350,000 people found the more white rice people ate, the higher their chance of developing the condition seemed to be.

Experts from Harvard School of Public Health and Harvard Medical School looked at two studies in Asian people (Chinese and Japanese) and two in Western populations (the US and Australia).

Asian people tended to have a much higher white rice intake than those in the West, averaging three to four servings a day compared with one or two servings per week.

The results showed that Asian people have a higher chance of developing type 2 diabetes, with those who ate the most at highest risk.

But even for Western populations with typically low intakes, the researchers said "relatively high white rice consumption may still modestly increase risk of diabetes".

In the total population, the experts said that for every extra serving of white rice (assuming 158g per serving), the risk of type 2 diabetes increased by about 11%.

Writing in the British Medical Journal, the authors concluded: "We found that higher white rice consumption was associated with a significantly elevated risk of type 2 diabetes. This association seems to be stronger for Asians than for Western populations."

The studies took into account a variety of factors such as people's weight, how much exercise they took and dietary issues such as red meat and alcohol intake.

All the people were free from diabetes at the start of the studies.

During follow-up, ranging from four to 22 years, around 13,200 people developed diabetes.

The authors said previous studies suggest that eating brown rice may modestly decrease the risk of type 2 diabetes. But they said larger studies were needed to look at any benefits of substituting brown rice for white rice.

About 2.5m people in the UK are diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes, and another 850,000 have the condition but do not know it.

Dr Iain Frame, director of research at Diabetes UK, said: "This new study is a review of previous research looking at the association between white rice consumption and Type 2 diabetes, but it has not looked at whether eating lots of white rice actually increases risk of Type 2 diabetes.

"Previous research in this area has not provided conclusive results and it is a difficult area to conduct research because no single type of food is directly linked or associated with the development of Type 2 diabetes.

"So this study does not provide any strong evidence that eating lots of white rice will put people at increased risk of Type 2 diabetes."

If you have type 2 diabetes or are worried about getting it, take a look at the best diabetes superfoods you should be eating. These are all rich in flavanoids, which are proven to help reduce type 2 diabetes risks in women.

The flavonoid family is too complex to list out every single food that has flavonoid present, but the general rule of thumb is – the more colourful the food, the richer it is in flavonoid components.

There are six different types of flavonoids:

Flavonols
Find these flavonoids in green fruits and vegetables like onion and leeks, apple and broccoli, as well as teas (black and green) and tomatoes.

Flavanones
Citrus fruits are a great source of flavanones.

Flavones
Look out for these in celery and parsley.

Catechins
A fun flavonoid found in quite a few fruits like peach and apricot, apple, cherries and grapes. Green tea is rich in catechins as well.

Isoflavones
Many soy-based substances contain isoflavones. Get yourself some tofu or soy milk.

Anthocyanins
These are mainly found in pears, cranberries, cherries, currants and blueberries. And you can wash it all down with that glass of red wine... in moderation of course.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Flavonoid Superfoods

    Flavonoid-rich foods that help beat type 2 diabetes in women.

  • Apples

  • Apricots

  • Berries

  • Pears

  • Raspberries

  • Strawberries

  • Black Beans

  • Cabbage

  • Onions

  • Parsley

  • Pinto Beans

  • Tomatoes

  • Asparagus

  • Spinach

  • Carrots

  • Cranberries

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE

Eating white rice may be linked to a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, researchers said today. A review of four studies involving around 350,000 people found the more white rice people ate, the highe...
Eating white rice may be linked to a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, researchers said today. A review of four studies involving around 350,000 people found the more white rice people ate, the highe...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 135
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
16:38 on 01/06/2012
I get the whole white rice thing and rising glucose levels, etc. But the white rice issue has always been questionable to me since cultures in Asia, Africa and elsewhere eat tons of it -- many consuming it several times throughout the day. Really, it has to do with what else you eat, and don't eat.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrP
14:11 on 22/03/2012
Another meaningless epidemiological study. My only critique of this article is that it did not get the headlines of the very similar observational study that has been all over the media, and given special attention by HuffPo that tried to prove that red meat will kill us all.
Sadly, there is some merit to the premise that eating white rice causes an increase in "diabetes" because there is a physiological explanation of why that is the case - high carbohydrate consumption in the presence of insulin-resistance will result in abnormal blood sugar (which is what "type II diabetes is). Real science will show that to be true, while there is no scientific explanation to support the premise that eating red meat will cause any chronic disease process. It's time to stop doing these data-mining "studies" and do some real double-blind, controlled experiments to prove nutritional hypotheses.
09:11 on 19/03/2012
ok so all of Asia has T2 diabetes ? who wrote this one up someone who owns a potato farm !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Volkan Koknar
21:13 on 18/03/2012
This is not meaningfull. How do they read the statistics?
Did they feed them only with white rice? All Asia is eating white rice but type 2 diabet is not often seen as western countries there.

This is all about Glucosamine Index. If a food has high Glucosamine Index that food is a risk for type 2 diabet. Foods with high glucosamine index makes blood sugar increase fast and rapidly. That makes high amount of insuline production and with high amount of insuline body cells start having tolerance to insuline. Insuline stimulates energy pass in to the body cells. But high insuline level makes cells needing more insuline. Because in time cells doesn't get stimulate glucose in to the cells with same amount of insuline.

And need for insuline grows in time untill the body become tired of producing high and enough amount of insuline.

The thing is the people who has insuline tolerance can't be satisfied with low insuline index foods. It's like drug addiction to the insuline. You start needing foods with high glucosamine index always.

So if someone comsumes white rice, it means he also consumes all other type of foods with high glucosamine index. (sweets, sugars, white breat...)
So this research is not meaningfull enough statistically, because you can't isolate the effect of white rice from 350.000 people's diet.
03:03 on 19/03/2012
@Volkan, Do you mean glycemic index?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Volkan Koknar
03:11 on 19/03/2012
Surely yes. I'm sorry english is not my native language. And and i apologize i guess my dictionary referred to the wrong translation. It was glycemic index not glucosamine...
08:19 on 18/03/2012
Since I'm currently doing a tour in the east asia region, I can say that white rice is NOT the only factor. Diabetes is high in places like the Philippines, Malaysia, etc because they love SUGAR. Sugar is added to just about everything. Eating out is sometimes nauseating for us because everything is so super sweet - even savory foods. I hate eating at American chains there like Sbarro's because they add extra sweetener to the sauce, and the soda are catered to the super sweet taste of the population too.

Most locals don't even touch vegetables unless they are deep fried in something and high sugar laded fruits - like pineapple and mangos are everywhere and a staple of the diet.
05:06 on 18/03/2012
This is good research article. But ,studies have not concentrated on other food-intakes along with white-rice.
13:52 on 17/03/2012
The first rule of science is: Correlation doesn't equal causation.

An association only suggests that a hypotheses be formed for clinical study.

These endless epidemiological studies are only good for coming up with a hypothesis. They do not answer any questions.

Go back to school and learn how to conduct basic science.
I-US
Beware the monsters lurking in word swamps.
13:10 on 17/03/2012
My two posts wherein I noted that white rice may be eaten to the exclusion of healthier foods and that may be part of the problem were removed here. Curiously.

Anyway, in both India and Okinawa, brown rice has been the traditional staple until more recently, when polished white rice has come to replace it. As with many dietary trends of the last thirty years--healthier foods are being replaced by less healthy foods.
00:41 on 17/03/2012
Gah! Correlation != causation . This is the fundamental problem with all observational/epidemiological studies. The only thing that can be concluded from them is that there's something that needs studying in an experimental setting, where causation can be precisely determined.

Did the researchers examine whether or not those who consumed more white rice tended to have a greater number of the genetic risk factors that lead to developing Type 2 diabetes? The insulin resistance that's part of the T2 diabetes package leads to a death spiral in eating habits that results in consuming ever higher amounts of carbohydrates.
15:59 on 16/03/2012
say i like eatting good food to keep you health in life
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StephenJK
All your consciousness are belong to us
14:06 on 19/03/2012
I like eatting good food to keep you health in life.

I feel much better now. Thank you. :)
15:29 on 16/03/2012
A lot of posters are making two incorrect assumption in their criticism of this study.

(1) That the enriched processed white rice in the study is the same as locally grown unprocessed rice consumed by billions of rural Asian populations, it's not and the study does not claim it is. Processed rice, stripped of it's natural germ, causes a much stronger insulin response than whole grain (Taubes, Lustig), which in time can lead to insulin resistance which becomes type 2 diabetes.

(2) That urban Asian populations, eating processed rice, are not susceptible to diabetes. India's diabetes population has doubled in the last 10 years ("India, World Diabetes Capita", Hindustan Times). The insulin resistance that inevitably leads to type 2 diabetes can take years to develop, if we fast forward 30 years in these countries we'll likely see the same level of obesity and diabetes we have in the US.
14:11 on 16/03/2012
given what we know about fiberless carb-rich-white-rice, I am kinda surprised of the all or non crowd of posters who are dismissing this study because it is not 100% fool proof. Cmon, no study answers all question in an all or none fool proof manner. Many factors and variable come into play. However the study just adds another reason to be wary of white rice and eat brown rice instead.
14:06 on 16/03/2012
I'd be more concerned about the poisons the food industry uses as "preservatives" in our foods than the damage a bowl of rice will do, the fizzy drinks industry is poisoning people daily but no studies are openly done on their effects, why would that be then, would our authorities be colluding with the food and drug industry.
05:53 on 03/04/2012
"would our authorities be colluding with the food and drug industry" - Perish the thought!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Oregonlib
Honey we're out of micro-bio
14:05 on 16/03/2012
Tater Spud, spokesman for the American potato council, went on to say that, "we have long suspected the insidious and poisonous nature of rice and suggest that everyone switch immeadiatly to the good and wholesome American potato for delicious and healthy starch consumption."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissFrijole
My bite is worse than my bark.
14:05 on 16/03/2012
Ok...so Asian have a higher "risk" of diabetes, but do they actually develop the disease? Do you think that maybe the diet Americans have has something to do with the increased risk? It may be true that rice contributes to the hightened risk, but it is also true that Americans consume WAY more sugar and have a poorer diet overall. You don't see too many fat Asians walking around unless they are from the Pacific Islands or Sumo wrestlers. Those are not part of the study. Regular Asians seem to age much better and live much longer. This is a dumb study. Good job wasting all that grant money on this.