Budget 2012 - Reaction From HuffPost UK's Panel

The Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: 21/03/2012 15:50 Updated: 22/03/2012 13:07

George Osborne has delivered his 2012 Budget to the Commons, and as expected the 50p top rate of tax is being cut to 45p, a measure which will come into effect a year from now.

"We are earning our way out of trouble," the Chancellor said at the conclusion to his speech, insisting that the top rate of tax - introduced by the last government - had only encouraged tax avoidance and raised less than a third of the amount previously expected.

The chancellor also performed a major U-turn on cuts to child benefits for middle-incomes - but has angered pensioners by freezing their personal tax allowances.

FULL BUDGET COVERAGE

  • Liveblog - Updates from the TV shows and the Commons
  • At-a-glance - the key measures

  • Ros Altmann, Director General, SAGA


    The big shock in this Budget was the stealth tax announced for 5million of Britain’s pensioners. Any pensioner with income between around £10,000 and £24,000 a year will pay more tax in future than they would have done before. The Government says this is a measure to ‘simplify’ the tax system – and it is true that the age allowance is very complicated – but the reality is that this is a revenue-raising exercise pure and simple.

    Those paying the price will be middle income groups aged over 65. The very richest and very poorest will not be affected.

    There was nothing in this Budget to help savers, especially older people trying to live on the income from their savings.

    The policy of ultra-low interest rates has hit savers hard and there was no help from the Chancellor. The very least he could have done would have been to relax the restrictions on ISAs that mean older savers cannot put their full annual ISA allowance into cash savings – only half can be in cash, with the rest having to be put into more risky shares or bond investments.

    There was no help for those badly hit by Quantitative Easing, which has damaged annuity and income drawdown rates. And nothing to encourage people to save for later life care needs either.

    There was, however, some great news for the pensions industry which will welcome the Chancellor's announcement that he is making no further changes to pensions tax relief.

    This is a great chance for 50% taxpayers to pile into pensions and contribute as much as they can this year before the 50p rate is cut to 45p next year. 50 per cent relief means anyone contributing £3 to a pension will get another £3 from taxpayers. Those on 40p tax will only get another £2 to their pensions, and basic rate taxpayers get about 80p.

    A long overdue and very welcome announcement was that there will be radical State Pension reform. This is great news and there will be a Consultation later 'this Spring' on a flat rate state pension, above the means-testing level of around £140pw, merging state second pension and Basic State Pension in future. The new pension will be based on contributions and could finally move us towards a system without mass means-testing for pensioners. Of course, we do need to see the details when the consultation comes out, but if introduced correctly, this measure could end the penalty suffered by those lower income pensioners who save for retirement or try to keep working in old age.

    Another welcome announcement is that the Chancellor will be using pension fund assets for major national investments, with the Pension Infrastructure Platform providing investment in long-term projects to modernise our outdated infrastructure. Harnessing the power of pension fund money to help stimulate the economy is a very sensible move.

    Overall, this Budget has hurt middle class pensioners, been great for the top income groups and has done nothing for long-suffering savers.

    Meet the rest of our panel:

    • Fiona Cuthbertson, Keystone Consulting
    • FOLLOW UK POLITICS

George Osborne has delivered his 2012 Budget to the Commons, and as expected the 50p top rate of tax is being cut to 45p, a measure which will come into effect a year from now. "We are earning our ...
George Osborne has delivered his 2012 Budget to the Commons, and as expected the 50p top rate of tax is being cut to 45p, a measure which will come into effect a year from now. "We are earning our ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:12 AM on 03/22/2012
At least Dick Turpin had the decency to wear a mask while robbing people.
09:10 AM on 03/22/2012
This lot have never needed a mask, their bare faced cheek and couldn't care less attitude to the poor with families and the pensioners allows them to hide behind a facade of lies and obfuscation. I cannot wait for 2015 to vote this lot back to years of oblivion. The only credible option for a government now rests with the Lib Dems, alas. UKIP and the smaller parties will romp home into Parliament.
07:18 PM on 03/21/2012
The fact he is the candidate says so much about the Labour Party. They could do so much better but he has the connections in the hierarchy to be the one. Kind of pathetic.
05:55 PM on 03/21/2012
"...I suspect, will approve of the rise in personal allowances but will want to know what effect that will have on tax credits and whether they’ll be drawn into higher rate tax by the new threshold changes."

And of course Huffpost feels no journalistic obligation to tell them
04:53 PM on 03/21/2012
What did people expect who voted for conservatives?

Did they even GLANCE at a history book? or did they have goldfish memories. I am not even 30 and I can remember the by the rich for the rich policies that sunk the UK into desperation under the last Tory government.

Though I heard only 20% voted for conservatives last time. However due to the current voting system (which conservatives did all the sneaky things they could to stop being changed. Unidentified Labour colored flyers through my door that I had to use the internet to trace the 1mm sized MPs name back to a conservative MP? Really conservatives?)

Welcome to tories. I was only a kid last time this happened but as a badly hit family I remember it well. The tories are by the rich for the rich and have always been for selling off and privatising the countries resources. It has always been the case.
07:16 PM on 03/21/2012
It comes down to the great mystery of the working-class Tory.
08:59 AM on 03/22/2012
this is a continuation of my earlier comment....
08:59 AM on 03/22/2012
Osborne again hails the biggest rise of 5.2% state pension increase as being wonderful for pensioners.. it isn't..it should have been based on the RPI rate and not the CPI rate of inflation. Pensioners have had to wait and see their much diminished and deserved purchasing power of their pension lowered and lowered by this uncaring government. If we are lucky enough to have a job at 65/68 years old, then hang on to it. Retiring is no longer an option.
08:58 AM on 03/22/2012
We call the Lib Dems.. but without those few, who would be there to hold this evil government to account? We have seen everyone adversely affected by this budget except the idle rich. He has helped his rich chums to hang onto their ill gotten gains through tax avoidance. Increasing stamp duty on properties over £2mill won't mean a thing or earn any more as those few will just not sell. If you are rich enough to be taxed at 45p in the pound, which won't come into effect for twelve months, then are you really going to be worried about the stamp duty? You will have enough in the kitty to find ways around paying that stamp duty ie by selling their homes for £1.99 mill but sell fixtures and fittings for say £200k which would be negotiated in a deal that would not attract the full stamp duty. What sickens me is that Osborne is passing off the increase in tax allowance as happening now when it clearly isn't. Osborne, Cameron and the rest of this clique have got it wrong. I'm not saying the socialists would have done any better.
04:21 PM on 03/21/2012
A budget by the rich for the rich ; it's obscene
A lot of part time workers will have their familly tax credits stopped completely
causing them to lose up to £ 5.000 a year ! How can that be fair
these are people already struggling to make ends meet
Most will have to stop working ; where's the economical sense in that
That's punishing them for working ; defying any kind of common decency !
09:11 AM on 03/22/2012
100% correct.