Scientists Uncover How Electric Shock Therapy Helps Beat Depression

The Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: 20/03/2012 13:33 Updated: 20/03/2012 13:33

Scottish scientists have discovered how electric shock therapy (ECT) helps beat severe depression, after investigating how the therapy alters the brain's connectivity with other parts of the brain.

The controversial treatment, which has been used clinically for more than 70 years, involves anaesthetising a patient and electronically inducing a seizure. This is the first time researchers have uncovered the mechanics of how the therapy works.

Researchers from the University of Aberdeen claim the electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) could pave the way for more effective treatment of those suffering from severe depression.

Scientists decided to investigate this further by experimenting with ECT by ‘turning down’ an overactive connection between certain parts of the brain that control mood, thought and concentration.

The study, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, involved observing the brain connectivity of six men and three women being treated for depression at the Royal Cornhill Hospital in Aberdeen.

All nine of the participants had failed to respond to prescribed antidepressants and underwent the ECT twice a week for a month until their symptoms eased.

Scientists saw a change in the patients' MRI brain scans and noted a difference in how the brain cells that are linked to depression connected to each other. They claim that the ECT is the reason for the patients’ significant improvement in depression symptoms.

Professor Ian Reid from the study, said as reported by the Press Association: "ECT is a controversial treatment, and one prominent criticism has been that it is not understood how it works and what it does to the brain.

"However, we believe we've solved a 70-year-old therapeutic riddle because our study reveals that ECT affects the way different parts of the brain involved in depression connect with one another.

"For all the debate surrounding ECT, it is one of the most effective treatments not just in psychiatry but in the whole of medicine, because 75% to 85% of patients recover from the symptoms.

"Over the last couple of years there has been an emerging new perspective on how depression affects the brain.

"This theory has suggested a 'hyperconnection' between the areas of the brain involved in emotional processing and mood change and the parts of the brain involved in thinking and concentrating.

"Our key finding is that if you compare the connections in the brain before and after ECT, ECT reduces the connection strength between these same areas - it reduces this hyperconnectivity.

"For the first time we can point to something that ECT does in the brain that makes sense in the context of what we think is wrong in people who are depressed.

"As far as we know no-one has extended that 'connectivity' idea about depression into an arena where you can show a treatment clearly treating depression, changing brain connectivity.

"And the change that we see in the brain connections after ECT reflects the change that we see in the symptom profile of patients who generally see a big improvement."


Mood-Boosting Foods
1  of  9
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE

Scottish scientists have discovered how electric shock therapy (ECT) helps beat severe depression, after investigating how the therapy alters the brain's connectivity with other parts of the brain. ...
Scottish scientists have discovered how electric shock therapy (ECT) helps beat severe depression, after investigating how the therapy alters the brain's connectivity with other parts of the brain. ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:52 AM on 02/04/2013
There is no real evidence that supports electric shock treatments. Its voodoo science. A huge travesty and it is still legal in the United States. In MA special needs children get shocked regularly even for the most minor offenses! Shame.
09:02 AM on 03/23/2012
Dr Ian Reid and his colleagues claim to have discovered how electroshock therapy (ECT) works. They found that electrocuting the brain to cause seizures (of the kind the rest of medicine is trying to cure) reduces the ‘connectivity’ between parts of the brain, and suggest that this is somehow a good idea.

The main problem with their claims (apart from making them on the basis of an astonishing small sample of just nine people) is that ECT does not work. In a review of 60 years of research, which I published with Professor Richard Bentall of Liverpool University in 2010, we could not identify a single follow up study that found ECT to be more effective than placebo (in which the general anaesthetic is administered but the electricity is not). Nor are there any studies which support the oft made claim that ECT reduces suicide risk.

We did find, however, many studies showing that ECT causes brain dysfunction, most often in the form of memory loss – often long-lasting and sometimes permanent. So what Dr Reid has actually found may actually be yet another example of the negative effects of applying the equivalent of about 150 volts to brain cells that are equipped to deal with a tiny fraction of one volt.

Professor John Read
University of Auckland
New Zealand
01:54 AM on 02/04/2013
But professor, what can be the motive behind such unjustified use of this clearly psychopathic treatment? No sane human would do this to another.
12:30 PM on 03/21/2012
They've been using this "therapy" for 70 years yet only NOW have they any idea as to how it works??? So who came up with the idea to begin with & why? You might as well say "I think that hitting people over the head with bricks will cure meningitis" & have the medical profession say "oh yes, if you think so, go ahead & do it...." WTF???
11:46 AM on 03/21/2012
i think its shocking !!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:46 AM on 03/21/2012
creates zombies?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chatnuptime1
The Wolf's Den.
04:37 AM on 03/22/2012
lobotomies make zombies.
12:31 PM on 03/22/2012
IS"nt that what most MPs have before being allowed into parliment !!
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
01:26 AM on 03/21/2012
As a sufferer of depression/anxiety myself, I hold caution to these findings. Anything can trigger such a condition, mental health is a very complex issue which can mean a wide variety ways of managing it. If this is to treat very severe cases, I just hope they know what they're doing, it's horses for courses.
This comment has been removed.
12:17 AM on 03/21/2012
Great work!
08:56 PM on 03/20/2012
Is this good for Grieving a Suicide of a Loved one and that is how you got severe depression ?
07:25 PM on 03/20/2012
Many countries refuse to use this method because it is painful and causes long term and significant memory loss of important facts and information. Strange how they did not mention this. I also know of people who have had it over and over again and are simply becoming forgetful but are still also very depressed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chatnuptime1
The Wolf's Den.
04:43 AM on 03/22/2012
We are using a much safer and saner approach based on the same principle but not needing to put the patient to sleep or volting up to the point of creating a seizure to do it. Very low 1 amplitude temporal stimulation that cannot even be felt for a half hour several times a week while patient reads a book or plays with a math puzzle otherwise mentally engaged in an activity also changed hyperconnectivity in people with chronic depression that doesn't respond to drug therapy. It has been seen even to improve short term memory and learning math problems and retaining information long enough to become a long term memory. It is a lot less draconian too.
01:55 AM on 02/04/2013
Most advanced and humane countries do not allow this barbaric practice.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gumpo
07:20 PM on 03/20/2012
Apparently researchers now believe a "wheel" is probably the best thing to use at each corner of a vehicle to enable it to move along the road efficiently. Apparently a cylindrical wheel is far better than a box shaped one !
Just thought I'd post this finding so you can marvel in the expertise of these professionals !!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gumpo
07:16 PM on 03/20/2012
Glad the researchers have spent all that time to studying this !
I'm pretty sure the surgeons who started using 70 years ago probably had a fair idea of how it worked / what it did then !
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sulk
03:18 PM on 03/20/2012
You become very happy when they tell you they are done with the treatments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gary Lynne
03:13 PM on 03/20/2012
Hilarious, these idiots have been using this technique for 7 decades and had no idea how it worked? Wow, what a definitive science psychiatry must be! Actually it is not a science at all, but rather a pseudo-science using barbaric treatments like this on people who need help. I've read where psychiatrists are once again using psycho-surgical treatments more often because it makes them feel like real doctors! Perhaps both they and society can benefit from the old cliché, "physician heal thyself - using psycho-surgery hopefully!!"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
champagne charlie
Ayn Rand and social Darwinism are just wrong!
03:51 PM on 03/20/2012
Well they knew that people who suffered convulsions had an extremely low rate of depression. ECT induces convulsions and the patients reported less depression. They also used to use insulin shock rather than electrical shock to do the same thing but it was too easy to kill a patient with insulin so electricity became the favored method.
01:58 AM on 02/04/2013
Just one tablet of a drug called Calmpose in a cup of coffee will clear one of depression, along with the help of supportive friends and family. Some one has gotta be making money using these treatments, as usual follow the money trail.
02:52 PM on 03/20/2012
Blimey what will these scientists do now that they have so called solved this problem all sign on at the local job centre
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chatnuptime1
The Wolf's Den.
04:46 AM on 03/22/2012
no worries.. there are a thousand more things wrong with the human body and psyche to conquer.