Red Issue: Did Manchester United Fanzine's Fabrice Muamba Cover Cross The Line?

Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: 26/03/2012 14:39 Updated: 26/03/2012 17:20

The latest issue of the Manchester United fanzine Red Issue is under fire for apparently mocking the outpouring of support for Fabrice Muamba following his near-fatal collapse last week.

Scroll down for the cover in full

Under the headline Grief Junkies Run Riot, it features the harrowing scene after he slumped to the ground as concerned teammates gathered around him.

Private Eye-style speech bubbles asking, "Is he dead?", "I've tweeted my condolences just in case" and "Good mourning!" hover above.

Twitter commentators are already up in arms about the Red Issue cover, branding it "poor taste" and "sickening".

Red Issue has responded via the same medium with: "It's not mocking Muamba you simpleton" and labelling the complainers as "gobsh*tes".


Red Issue
It's not mocking Muamba you simpleton.


Red Issue
FAO all Twitter gobshites: it's not like you don't know where to find us. Come and say hello after 5pm.

Thousands of football fans clapped and cheered in a show of support for Muamba as his Bolton Wanderers side returned to the pitch on Saturday.

The 23-year-old player remains in a "serious but stable" condition at the London Chest Hospital, where he was admitted last Saturday after suffering a cardiac arrest during his club's FA Cup quarter-final with Tottenham at White Hart Lane.

At the Reebok Stadium, his team-mates took on Blackburn Rovers in a local derby as Wanderers resumed their Premier League campaign.

Players from both sides completed their warm-up with T-shirts emblazoned with "Muamba 6" in tribute to the midfielder as fans chanted his name.


Blackburn Rovers' players wear Muamba on the backs of their shirts

Shortly before kick-off a video was shown on the big screen featuring images of support that have been received during the week.

Today doctors said Muamba was making "encouraging progress" in his recovery and had been able to "sit out of bed" and watch television.

Bolton manager Owen Coyle revealed that Muamba watched his team-mates' 2-1 victory over Blackburn on Match Of The Day yesterday morning - but fell asleep when the score was 2-0.

Coyle also confirmed that a small delegation of Bolton players will visit Muamba in hospital ahead of tomorrow's rearranged FA Cup quarter-final at Tottenham.

Is it all a bit of harmless banter or has Red Issue crossed line?


Richard Buxton
fanzine Red Issue sinking to new depths with sickening cover on latest edition. Even United fans are outraged:


Mike Rawlins
fanzine red issue gets it wrong, horribly horribly wrong.


Ramy 'mufc'
Just seen the front cover of today's Red Issue, no-one buy it, that is a disgrace.


Adam Arsenal
Just seen the front cover of that new Red Issue edition.... Disgusting... I'm so proud we have a decent Fanzine!!!!


Red Issue
No wonder the Twitterati aren't happy with the cover - it's them who are being lampooned

Loading Slideshow...
  • Tottenham Hotspur's William Gallas reacts on the pitch after Bolton Wanderers' Fabrice Muamba collapses

  • (left-right) Tottenham Hotspur's Carlo Cudicini, Luka Modric and Louis Saha look concerned after Bolton Wanderers' Fabrice Muamba collapses on the pitch and is resusitated by medical staff

  • Tottenham Hotspur's Luka Modric (2nd left), Bolton Wanderers' Ivan Klasnic, referee Howard Webb and manager Bolton Wanderers' manager Owen Coyle look on after Fabrice Muamba collapses on the pitch

  • Tottenham Hotspur's Benoit Assou-Ekotto (left), William Gallas, Carlo Cudicini and manager Bolton Wanderers' manager Owen Coyle look on after Fabrice Muamba collapses on the pitch

  • Tottenham Hotspur's Jermain Defoe, Ryan Nelsen and Luka Modric react after Bolton Wanderers' Fabrice Muamba is carried off on a stretcher

  • Tottenham Hotspur's Jermain Defoe reacts on the pitch after Bolton Wanderers Fabrice Muamba collapses on the pitch

  • Players walk back into the tunnel after the game is abandoned after Bolton Wanderers Fabrice Muamba collapses on the pitch

  • The medical team tend to Bolton Wanderers' Fabrice Muamba as Ryo Miyaichi, Darren Pratley and Dedryck Boyata look on

Video of Bolton fans staging a mosaic tribute to Muamba
FOLLOW UK SPORT

The latest issue of the Manchester United fanzine Red Issue is under fire for apparently mocking the outpouring of support for Fabrice Muamba following his near-fatal collapse last week. Scroll do...
The latest issue of the Manchester United fanzine Red Issue is under fire for apparently mocking the outpouring of support for Fabrice Muamba following his near-fatal collapse last week. Scroll do...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:09 PM on 03/27/2012
Just who is Red issue to judge that the so called 'grief junkies' don't genuinely mean it? What do they do someone close to them gets ill or passes away and they receive a get well or a condolence card? Throw it in the bin and label them grief junkies?

And the chest pouting of 'you know where to find us'........grow up lads the heydays of Tony O'Neill are behind you.
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
10:53 AM on 03/27/2012
They crossed the line. Think of the players around whose hearts are in their mouths thinking they gonna lose their friend & colleague. Think of Bolton FC & in particular Owen Coyle whose been absolutely fantastic this past week. The fanzine wouldn't be the same if it wasn't one of their players, they had the chance to show respect as have done the majority, but instead be petulant & cynical. I'm tempted to say Manchester United fans have gone down in my book, but I won't coz I know this fanzine isn't represented by all their fans.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
07:34 PM on 03/26/2012
I think that maybe they crossed the line, but do they not also have apoint? All this outpouring of grief from rival fans for a player who any other given day they would be shouting all sorts of terrible things at him. At the moment, the football world is giving itself a right pat on the back over the way they have all come together to wish the player well...but every other week we sing, chant, scream and threaten one another
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
10:44 AM on 03/27/2012
You're right, every week they scream, chant t'his & that', but it takes incidents like these to show respect and put those rivalries aside, and I for one have found it all quite moving.
06:53 PM on 03/26/2012
I wonder what the fanzine's reaction would have been if it was a Man U player who had collapsed.

Some of this club's so called fans are disgusting (Not the majority by the way). A friend of mine was stewarding at the Man U end when Southampton entertained them in the FA cup a couple of years ago. He had to wash his face after all the spittle was spat at him and he is a Man U fan.
05:17 PM on 03/26/2012
DISGUSTING!!!!
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Philip J Sparrow
When your work speaks for itself, keep quiet
04:00 PM on 03/26/2012
A valid point poorly made (United fan speaking)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nathan0316
TrueBlueTory Age quod agis
03:25 PM on 03/26/2012
The difficult question here is not whether people should feel bad when they hear bad news, but how far do they go? When does public grief go over the top, stop being about genuine emotion and start being a contest as to who is expressing feelings in the best way?

In short, how bad can we feel when someone we've never met suffers?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gunderan
Who let the Libertarians out without supervision?
05:30 PM on 03/26/2012
YES.Thats is a brilliant point.
Just to add to it why do some people feel worse for total strangers than they do thier own family and friends.
03:05 PM on 03/26/2012
Fanzines are known for having a slightly "off-beat" take on events and humour, but there is a line and this rag has trampled right through it.