Tory MP Louise Mensch Sent Threatening Email, Court Hears

Posted: 10/04/2012 19:49 Updated: 11/04/2012 08:32   PA

Louise Mensch
Louise Mensch was in the USA when the email was sent

A Conservative MP was sent a threatening email telling her she would have to choose which one of her children would die, a court has heard.

Mother-of-three Louise Mensch, who is MP for Corby in Northamptonshire, was told she faced a "Sophie's Choice" - a reference to a novel and later film in which heroine Sophie has to choose between the life of her son or daughter at a Nazi concentration camp.

The sinister email was purportedly sent from the online hacking group Anonymous, Gloucester Magistrates' Court heard.

However, police later arrested and charged Frank Zimmerman - a 60-year-old agoraphobic living in a run-down house in Gloucester.

Zimmerman, of Spinney Road, Barnwood, Gloucester, was accused of an offence of sending by public communication network an offensive, indecent, obscene, menacing message or matter on 22 August last year.

The court heard that Zimmerman had failed to attend any court appearance to answer the single charge he faced or give proper instructions to his solicitor - blaming his agoraphobia and depression.

Defence solicitor Charles Cronin told District Judge Martin Brown that he had spoken to Zimmerman by telephone and that he would not be attending court and was instead going back to bed.

In the defendant's absence, Judge Brown decided to proceed without him and held a hearing to determine whether Zimmerman had committed the offence.

Prosecutor Gaon Hart told the court that that Zimmerman had sent the email to Mrs Mensch after she had spoken out publicly during last summer's riots calling for the police to be able to temporarily close down social network sites, such as Twitter and Facebook, if necessary.

Zimmerman originally made contact with the chick lit author-turned-MP on Twitter using the pseudonym Tim Cavendish.

He claimed he had information about Piers Morgan and the telephone hacking scandal engulfing the News of the World.

Mrs Mensch sent him her personal gmail email address. It was to that account that Zimmerman sent the threatening message, the court heard.

The email, which was timed at 10.47pm on 22 August, was sent from an account with the address of lulz.sec@hotmail.com - a reference to the internet hacking group Lulz Security.

The email said:

"Subject: You have been HACKED :D

Louise Mensch, nee Bagshawe, the slut of Twitter.

We are Anonymous and we don't like rude c**** like you and your nouveau riche husband Peter Mensch. You have been hacked!

We are inside your computer and all your phones, everywhere... and inside your homes.

So get off Twitter.

We see you are still on Twitter. We have sent a camera crew to photograph you and your kids and will post it all over the net, including Twitter. C***face.

You now have a Sophie's Choice. Which kid is to go? One will, count on it c***.

Have a nice day

From all of us at MIT 617-253-1000"

Mr Hart said the reference to MIT followed by a US telephone number was to give the impression the email had been sent from hackers linked to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Mrs Mensch was in New York with her husband recovering from an operation while her three children were with their father, her ex-husband, in the UK.

The MP took the threats seriously and immediately contacted the police, the court was told.

In a victim impact statement read to the court, Mrs Mensch spoke of her terror at receiving the threat.

"I was terrified on behalf of my children. I was in New York with my husband recovering from an operation and my children were with their father and to receive a threat like this made me very upset," she said.

"I was 3,000 miles away from my children and I was worried for their safety and the safety of my ex-husband. I felt powerless to do anything."

Mrs Mensch said that after receiving the email she was sent a Twitter message from someone called "Robert Redford".

"He made reference to the contents of the email and that one of my children would die and it made me believe he was responsible," she said.

Zimmerman first became a suspect for threatening Mrs Mensch when Independent newspaper columnist Terence Blacker, who was a former neighbour of the defendant in London, received a similar email.

A forensic examination linked the sender of the email to the IP and router addresses of Zimmerman's Virgin Media account at his home in Gloucester.

Police visited his house and he volunteered the password for his computer, the court was told.

Examination of that computer found Zimmerman had a series of tabs on his internet browser open at the Twitter accounts of Tim Cavendish, Mrs Mensch, Piers Morgan and Lord Prescott.

He also had pages open on BBC News Online of reports of Mrs Mensch receiving threats to her children by email, an article on the News of the World hacking scandal and a story on the hacking group Anonymous.

There was also a page open for a Skype account in the name of Tim Cavendish.

Detective Constable Iqbal Azad told the court: "We were able to trace the internet service provider and it was an internet broadband account held by Mr Frank Zimmerman at his home address."

Judge Brown said he had to rule on whether the email sent to Mrs Mensch was malicious, and if it was, had Zimmerman sent it.

He said he was satisfied the email was malicious and added: "The court needs to be satisfied that this email can be linked to the defendant.

"The very helpful evidence of Det Con Azad has been clear that there is a direct link to the IP address that has been identified as coming from Mr Zimmerman's computer.

"It does not appear in question in my mind that the prosecution have established a direct link by the email received by Louise Mensch and the computer that was found at the defendant's address.

"I can be satisfied that this was a malicious communication sent by Mr Zimmerman from his computer at his home address.

"I can therefore be satisfied that he committed the act in question and the offence has been committed."

The judge said he had decided not to issue an immediate warrant for Zimmerman's arrest without bail and was releasing him on unconditional bail until he is sentenced on 8 May.

He told Mr Hart: "If he does not attend on that date, and unless circumstances change, he must understand I am being left with very little alternative but to issue a warrant."

Following the judge's ruling, Mr Hart said the Crown would be applying at the sentencing hearing for a restraining order against Zimmerman, preventing him contacting "other high-profile individuals".

Details of the proposed order were not revealed in court.

Speaking afterwards, Mr Hart, who is part of the Crown Prosecution Service's special crime and counter-terrorism division, said: "The right to freedom of speech is accompanied by laws that protect individuals from those who seek to abuse that freedom and use the anonymity of email or Twitter accounts to hide from the fear that they cause.

"Zimmerman attempted to use pseudonyms and other methods to wage a campaign of fear against a high-profile person, thinking that he was safe from detection.

"He was wrong. This should be a salutary lesson for anyone who considers that they are above the law because they threaten others through a computer rather than on the streets.

"I would also like to thank officers from the Metropolitan Police Central e-crime unit for their hard work."

FOLLOW UK POLITICS

A Conservative MP was sent a threatening email telling her she would have to choose which one of her children would die, a court has heard. Mother-of-three Louise Mensch, who is MP for Corby in Nor...
A Conservative MP was sent a threatening email telling her she would have to choose which one of her children would die, a court has heard. Mother-of-three Louise Mensch, who is MP for Corby in Nor...
Filed by David Hobbs  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norman Mitchison
05:06 PM on 04/11/2012
With all the criticism of AoL and their reporting that Huff has`nt closed comments. Thats what they do so often.
04:08 PM on 04/11/2012
"Tory MP Louise Mensch Sent Threatening Email, Court Hears " - no she didn't, she RECEIVED a threatening e-mail. Sorry but this kind of rubbish editorial is beginning to make me quite cross. Whatever AOL or Huffington Post is paying their editor I will do the job for half the salary.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wincanton man
02:00 PM on 04/11/2012
Sorry
01:04 PM on 04/11/2012
People don't like liars and the nutters out there will tap in to anything, more care in the community is what we need.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drg40
Representative Democracy is all we have.
12:07 PM on 04/11/2012
It does seem to me that the judge should be spending today offering some pathetic attempt at an excuse why this man, bearing in mind the gravity of the offence, should not be on remand in Broadmoor, and I await to her news of the judge's resignation from his office on the grounds that senility has overtaken him. It seems that if the public feel the quality of their MPs could be improved and that they should act at all times above reproach, then the public have a responsibility on their part of ensuring that their MPs should be protected from nutters like this. I assume that the charges, when laid and if proven, will attract a custodial sentence amounting to many many years. The lady in question has been put through hell by Murdoch and his thugs already and whatever party she supports she should not have to put up with this sort of criminal behaviour.
09:59 AM on 04/11/2012
did you know you can send an email or a text from someone elses phone or computer ? well you can ,and this this kind of information that the government dont want you to know ,they know ,look up reverse phone loop this will give you some idea of whats going on ,it will also make you aware that android /smart phones need their batteries taking out if you dont want to be tracked .
all droids and smarts produce a carrier wave ,if that phone is on that wave is put out .

Im not saying that that man did not send the email ,but i expect that the judge has no clue just what is going on in the real world .
This comment has been removed.
09:36 AM on 04/11/2012
Be interesting to see what kind of sentence he gets compared say to a serial burglar, car thief, or someone who mugs old ladies.
04:16 PM on 04/11/2012
Why? His crime is one of threatening behaviour and to send such a message to a mother is unacceptable. His sentence will not correlate tto muggers/burglars etc as the crimes are totally different.
01:52 AM on 04/11/2012
She can go for her cup of 'Starbucks' in peace now.
01:37 AM on 04/11/2012
The man is mentally ill, He did a terrible thing however, given the man's circumstances and mental state he should be treated humanely. He is an argophobic so locking him up in a cell for 23 hours a day is hardly going to help him. This story has been hyped up, he is a sad, pathetic and ill person who needs medical care..
04:18 PM on 04/11/2012
You'd feel that way if it was your children he'd threatened would you? It makes no difference that his condition did not enable him to carry out the threat, the effect on the receiver of his e-mail was the same as if he could.
11:03 PM on 04/10/2012
What an awful story.
Awful in the sense that this whole thing sounds made up.
The tories aren't very popular...obviously...
Is this just a story spinned for a pity party...?
How convenient that this 'bad man' is an agoraphobic and no one has seen him.
Even if they do/or have produced this 'villain' for the public to see can anyone vouch that actually know him?
Or is he just a Patsy.
Sorry, but don't believe a word of it.
If it is true, how awful.
But this MPs family is safe.
Read any news story, worse things happen to other people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Altern8
11:24 AM on 04/11/2012
Conspiracy theorist rubbish.
If people are free to threaten MPs and their families we will have even MORE difficulty in getting the best people into parliament, so this sort of thing needs to be stamped on hard for all our sakes.
10:45 PM on 04/10/2012
C'mon now Huffy, let my post squeeze through the censor net. Saying I don't like Ms Mensch one little bit is a perfectly legitimate statement. Saying she seems to me a strange hybrid of Michael Portillo, Tonya Harding and a Piranha fish is also a perfectly legitimate statement. We're not yet living in a state where expressing a distaste of certain politicians results in censure, excommunication, banishment or execution- so loosen up on the net Huffy, loosen up.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:27 PM on 04/11/2012
It really makes me feel warm all over that she can affoed to travel to America for an operation. Never mind, when the N.H.S. is fully privatised she will be able to have her operations here without having to sneak off to the States.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ben Wilson
Might as well laugh while you still can.
10:38 PM on 04/10/2012
I can't count the amount of times people have said they will kill me online. This case makes me feel better because with everyone who said it to me I always assumed it was a loser who never went out and had no friends. When it comes down to it, Mensch was duped by a do-nothing nobody. It's not that reasonable to be concerned, not when you know how people behave online for example, you NEVER carry on the conversation, you never trust anything that sounds too good to be true, and you talk to unknown people through mediums which are disposable to you. Eg an email account you're willing to delete.
People that do this stuff crave responses, and they will play you like a piano, if you respond, because everyone thinks they know the best way to kick back, and there is no good way. It's like SPAM, just ignore it or get a new email account.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Altern8
11:26 AM on 04/11/2012
Now THAT'S good advice right there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
adidasmmxx
No likey? Not bovvered !
11:32 AM on 04/11/2012
Yep !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Altern8
09:02 PM on 04/10/2012
You don't threaten people's family, especially not children.
This guy needs to be put away, pour encourager les autres. Good thing for him he is agoraphobic because I can see a lot of inside in his future.

What's with the hatred for this woman anyway? Is it that she's articulate, pretty and has a Jewish sounding surname?
photo
casual agent
Advocate for social justice
12:59 PM on 04/11/2012
But what has race got to do with it'...Labour MP Stephen Timms' was atacked..and he's not Jewish...Well not as far as I know?...But I agree'..No one has the right to threaten anyone.
08:32 PM on 04/10/2012
She does not deserve this level of abuse but the woman is a first class idiot and deserves a lot of the comments she collects..she should not be an MP, but what else could she do for a living
photo
casual agent
Advocate for social justice
01:00 PM on 04/11/2012
I thought she was a novelist..?
04:24 PM on 04/11/2012
She stood for election, enough of the local population voted for her to win her seat in Parliament so why shouldn't she be an MP? Because she wrote simple literature? Because she's a woman? What do you know about her that makes her unfit to be elected to the Commons?