'Left-To-Die' Boat: Goldsmiths Report Suggests UK Military May Have Known About Migrants Stranded Off Libya

The Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: 11/04/2012 16:48 Updated: 11/04/2012 16:56

Migrants Die

An extensive report into the deaths of scores of African migrants who were left adrift at sea while trying to flee the war in Libya has suggested that the British military may have known about their plight.

Some 63 of the 72 migrants on board died on the “left-to-die” boat in 2011, most of thirst and starvation. The 90-page report, published by Goldsmiths University in London, used “forensic oceanography” technology to chart the movements of the boat, which drifted for two weeks unaided, despite claims it was known to both Nato and participating forces.

According to the few survivors, a “military helicopter” twice had visual sightings of the boat and communicated with those on board, but left the area without providing assistance.

The description of the helicopter is alleged to be that of a British Westland Lynx, believed to have served in the operation against the crumbling Libyan regime at the time.

The British military has so far refused to co-operate with any investigation into the incident, and the MoD has denied its helicopters were in the area at the time of the boat crisis.

However, one of the survivors was shown pictures of helicopters serving in the area at the time and identified the Lynx.

According to the report, survivor Dan Haile Gebre, was “presented him with several photographs of different helicopters in operation at the time of events”. When he was showed the image of the Westland Lynx helicopter of the British Army, he immediately said it was “exactly like this”.

According to survivors’ accounts, a ship also came into contact with the migrant boat, but again abandoned those on board. The ship may have been French, according to one survivor, who alleges that it was flying the French flag.

The report states: "At first, after the ‘left-to-die boat’ case was reported in the international press Nato denied being involved in any way in the incident”.

In May 2011, Carmen Romero, Nato deputy spokesperson, stated that: “We [Nato] can find no evidence whatsoever of any Nato ships being involved in this tragic incident.

Nato subsequently admitted that the Italian coastguard had informed the organisation of the vessel’s plight.

The newly-published report goes further, highlighting a “number of elements” that suggests that Nato was informed of the “the migrants’ distress”.

Dan Haile Gebre described the first encounter with the helicopter as follows: “It circled around us 4-5 times and came closer. It was making a lot of wind, and we almost lost our balance”.

A second survivor, Abu Kurke Kebato added: “The helicopter came very close to us down, we showed him our babies, we showed them we finished oil, we tell them ‘Please help us.’”

Further damning testimony alleges that that the helicopter bore the English writing “ARMY”.

According to the report, “a Westland Lynx 140, a battlefield utility helicopter of the British Army which does bear the writing “ARMY” on its side and can be used for SAR operations, was spotted in June 2011 in Malta on-board the HMS Ocean, a landing platform dock ship that took part to the military operation in Libya”.

Britain and the US refused to co-operate with a recent Council of Europe investigation into the tragedy, which concluded that the deaths were avoidable, blaming institutional failures within Nato and its constituent countries’ military forces for the tragic outcome.

Subsequent to that investigation, Nato has come under increasing pressure to identify the helicopter and the boat that are believed to have contacted the migrant vessel, but have so far refused to release classified imagery.

The Goldsmiths report, which used advanced technology to map the drift of the migrant boat, highlights the ease with which a rescue operation could have been initiated by Nato.

The research concludes by stating "participating states/Nato forces had the information and the ability to assist the migrants but failed to do so in a way that would have prevented the deaths of 63 people," adding that "only through further inquiry and disclosure by all parties involved will they receive the definite answers they deserve."

When contacted for comment, a spokesperson for the Ministry of Defence told the Huffington Post UK that British forces operating at sea are “fully aware of their obligations under maritime law to render assistance to those in distress”.

According to the MoD, there is no record of any Nato aircraft – British or otherwise – having seen or made contact with this particular vessel.

“Furthermore, the witness states that the helicopter in question bore the word “ARMY” on its side. We can categorically state that there were no British Army Lynx in the Mediterranean during this period.”

FOLLOW UK

An extensive report into the deaths of scores of African migrants who were left adrift at sea while trying to flee the war in Libya has suggested that the British military may have known about their p...
An extensive report into the deaths of scores of African migrants who were left adrift at sea while trying to flee the war in Libya has suggested that the British military may have known about their p...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 92
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
Kraptonfactor
They're coming to take me away ha ha, hee hee, ho
12:25 AM on 04/13/2012
I have read quite a few comments and all I can think of is that parents have had to watch their children and babies die of hunger and thirst and I find it heartbreaking regardless of the whys and wherefores of the ill fated evacuation in an ill equipped vessel.
01:51 PM on 04/12/2012
I bet someone will try to sue britain and blame us
01:43 PM on 04/12/2012
Yes, the World isn't the nicest place to be. Until humankind learn to be civilised and stop wars, hatred, bigotry and all the usual stuff, it will continue to have its casualties.
01:23 PM on 04/12/2012
We cannot carry all the ills of the world on our shoulders.
01:19 PM on 04/12/2012
What were we supposed to do? Bring them back to the UK? They would have stayed for good.
12:56 PM on 04/12/2012
I cant see the problem. Most of them live here already, sometimes a cloud has a silver lining. And this happens to be one of those occasions.
12:42 PM on 04/12/2012
WHO TO BELIEVE ? IF TRUE SO SAD.
12:27 PM on 04/12/2012
Why make this issue of a British helicopter being there when the French had a ship nearby. This was also a war zone just think for a moment if this was 72 armed people on the boat there is no way a helicopter would be allowed near it.
12:18 PM on 04/12/2012
The report is all guess work and the 'eye witness' accounts are dubious.

Be careful what you believe, particularly from University theoretical studies.
11:51 AM on 04/12/2012
Nothing new here, this happened all the time during WW11.
Another specious reason for our entry into WWII was to save the Jews. In fact, we routinely refused entry to Jewish refugees at our ports and sent their boats back to the death camps. We even refused passports to the family of Anne Frank, specifically including Anne. But we will never hear this from mainstream media. We will only hear fairy tales. We surely did not enter the war to save the Soviets because, like Churchill, we watched with glee as the Germans and Soviets bled each other white.
11:18 AM on 04/12/2012
I cannot imagine anyone not reporting this abandonment before now....If it was true.Our troops would have made a report about the alledged sighting and summoned help.They are like that....the best in the World.
10:35 AM on 04/12/2012
Wicked treatment, just wicked......... we just don't care any more do we.......
10:28 AM on 04/12/2012
lets not blame those people for getting on the boat in the first place. even tho they didnt take enough food with them its not their fault. they didnt make sure the vessel they went to sea in was up to the trip, but no one can blame them.
NO!! lets blame everyone else for not saving them. WE should have been there for them......
sorry I see that now.
please lets start a fund so we can put sea worthy boats all long the coast of these countries so no more lives are lost.
(shouldnt really put ideas in camerons mind, he might just do it)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:11 AM on 04/12/2012
HP, get a life and jump off the knocking Britain merry-go-round
majdf18148
I have nothing to declare but my curiosity
08:50 AM on 04/12/2012
I refuse to believe, until otherwise proven, any allegation that British Forces would deliberately abandon stranded sea going people fleeing a war.Our forces are recognised throughout the world for their humanitarian work, their compassion and their willingness to put others before themselves.The odd blip,where POWs have been allegedly mistreated. does not deter me from my belief in our brave troops. Let's wait and see the outcome of further investigations before we start apportioning any blame to anyone. I am confident I won't have to retract my own words.
09:35 AM on 04/12/2012
While I believe your position to be noble, I also believe you to be wrong.
What nation will claim that their soldiers, who protect them, are lacking in humanity?

Just look at the whole Abu Ghraib episode where the average US citizen refused to believe the horrors their fellow countrymen, many of them reservists, visited on innocent Iraqi prisoners.

How about Baha Mousa?
War is ugly and the the rather view of 'our' soldiers being gallant and honourable in the face of extreme danger is perhaps a little outdated - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8RfmqYWkXY
(I expect the 'a few bad apples' response to this video...)

I also don't understand what you mean by 'deliberately abandon' - is a soldier who is acting under orders not to help civilians and carry on with their mission deliberately abandoning civilians?

I am sure when, and if which it probably won't, the truth comes out it will be a lot more complex than is convenient for the press...