Grand National Steeplechase Under Fire From Animal Rights Groups After Death Of Two Horses (VOTE)

PA/Huffington Post UK  |  Posted: 15/04/2012 20:42 Updated: 15/04/2012 23:47

The world's most famous horse race has come in for criticism after the death of two horses, that of joint favourite Synchronised and According to Pete, both from falls.

On Sunday, the triumphant trainer behind Saturday's surprise Grand National winner threw his weight behind improved race safety.

Outsider Neptune Collonges literally won the historic annual steeplechase event by a nose in an electrifying finish.

VOTE: Scroll down to vote

But the triumph was overshadowed by the two deaths, which have stirred debate around the ethics of annual event.

Four horses died at the famous Merseyside meet last year, including Dooneys Gate and Ornais during the big race itself.

Trainer Paul Nicholls agreed on Sunday that anything that can be done to make the race safer "should be."


Tony McCoy and Synchronised are felled at Becher's Brook

Angry animal rights leaders hit out after the race on Saturday branding the Grand National "mob entertainment."

Andrew Tyler, director of Animal Aid, described the race as an "utterly depressing and melancholy experience."

He added: "The Grand National is a disgusting and shameful spectacle masquerading as sport.

"There is nothing sporting about an event that routinely kills so many horses."

On Sunday the RSPCA added its voice to calls for the race to have a radical overhaul.

Spokesman David Muir called for the number of runners in the race to be reviewed and said jump design and race length should also be looked at.

"I am not happy about drop fences like Becher's," he said. "It appears the horses still had difficulties with it."

Champion trainer Paul Nicholls admitted that the deaths of the two horses had overshadowed Neptune Collonges' victory "a little bit".

As he basked in the success of yesterday's victory he insisted that he just wanted to "enjoy the moment".

But he went on to accept that safety had become an issue and should be addressed.

"I just want to enjoy the day today," he said speaking at his training stables in Ditcheat, Somerset.

He added: "But, of course, if there is anything that can be done to improve the safety of the race then it should be done."

Quick Poll

Should the Grand National be banned?

VOTE

Following its victory, Neptune Collonges was the toast of a West Country village.

Villagers in Ditcheat, Somerset, came out in their droves on Sunday to give the grey champion a hero's welcome - after a night of celebration in which the champagne flowed freely.

Any hangovers they may have been nursing were nowhere to be seen as they gave the horse a rapturous reception. The village is home to trainer Paul Nicholls's stables.

Hundreds swarmed around the victor, his trainers and carers, cheering and applauding loudly.

Patrick and Sara Finch, from the nearby village of Parbrook, were surprised and slightly bemused by the massive turnout for Sunday's victory parade.

DEBATE: Scroll down to add your comments

"It is all a lot more than we were expecting but it is really quite something. This is something very big for Somerset because we don't have a lot of sporting heroes," Mrs Finch said.

The horse took several tours around the small well-heeled village. Roads and lanes in every direction were filled with parked cars and people straining to get a glimpse of the winner.

Many who would not usually pay too much attention to a horse race strained to get a glimpse of the champion.

Others patted the gelding's jockey Daryl Jacob on the back and took his picture.

Mr Jacob, who was all smiles, said: "I am absolutely delighted. This is a great horse who galloped from fence to fence and jumped without let.

"A lot of Paul's horses are very very fit and strong and that has paid off. It is fantastic."

The victory parade followed a night of revelry - with more than 40 bottles of champagne being sold in the village pub, The Manor House Inn.

Landlord Simon D'Offay said: "It was full to the rafters last night - it was a fantastic celebration. There must have been a good couple of hundred people here.

"We must have sold between 40 and 50 bottles of champagne last night alone.

"I have been here three years and this is the busiest that I have ever seen it."

Sue Sutcliffe, a neighbour of Mr Nicholls, added: "I live up on the hill and see them training every day. I've got horses of my own and this is a very horsey area.

"I'm really delighted that something like this has happened."

Saturday's nail-biting race at Aintree was decided by a photo-finish.

On Sunday those who care for Neptune Collonges admitted that the world's most famous steeplechase on Merseyside would be his last race.

Quick Poll

Would the Grand National be safer with fewer horses?

VOTE

Head Lad, Clifford Baker, who has tended to the horse for many years, told Sky News: "He is basically retired now so he won't race again. He deserves his break - I am pleased for him.

"There is nothing better than to see a good horse like this win a race like that and come back down here and for everybody to see him - it is absolutely brilliant."

However, the victory was marred by the tragedy of the two deaths.

Mr Baker added: "It is always sad to have horses die but unfortunately it is part of it sometimes.

"We're here to celebrate winning so that is what we are going to do."


Neptune Collonges is paraded at Paul Nicholls Manor Farm Stables

FOLLOW UK

The world's most famous horse race has come in for criticism after the death of two horses, that of joint favourite Synchronised and According to Pete, both from falls. On Sunday, the triumphant tr...
The world's most famous horse race has come in for criticism after the death of two horses, that of joint favourite Synchronised and According to Pete, both from falls. On Sunday, the triumphant tr...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 202
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
12:23 PM on 04/18/2012
FFS will someone finally ban this barbarity? Decent, compassionate people do not want to see horses put at risk let alone killed.
02:20 PM on 04/17/2012
Getting really fed up with the number of ill informed comments:
1) Horses were not ‘whipped until they bled’ . There were 9 vets, representatives from numerous animal welfare groups and hundreds of police at Aintree, none of whom reported any whip abuse. Use of the whip in racing is covered by the Animal Welfare Act 2006 and includes this statement by the RSPCA, " The whip is used primarily for safety, correction and encouragement purposes. The RSPCA does not believe that a ban would be safe or practical". There are strict rules as to how the whip can be used to prevent harming the horse. If you see the whip moving back and forth quickly at the side of the horse, this is called ‘swinging the whip’ – the horse is not being beaten. The technique is used to keep the horse straight.
2) Those involved in steeplechasing are not ‘greedy’ and only in it for the money. As Reality Always Bites points out, few of the horses have any stud value. More than 90% of owners lose money and most young jockeys and stable hands work all hours for a pittance.
3) In perspective - 8 million viewers watched My Big Fat Gypsy Whatever saw the horses getting hobbled at the side of the road without food or water, beaten and galloped on tarmac-ed public highways... and found the whole thing hilariously entertaining, making celebrities out of animal abusers. No complaints there, though! That's the real scandal.
08:15 PM on 04/16/2012
the grand national has been around for 165 years its not going to be banned!! and the RSPCA and the directors of the GN are working together to make it safer for both jockeys and horses! if you dont like it dont watch it or read the news about it simple as!
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
08:11 PM on 04/16/2012
To all those who want to ban horse racing I hope you realise that the Fre*8h will just eat all the unwanted horses.
Have you spotted the changes in recent years. The reduction in start numbers to forty, the lowering of fences and the changes to take off and landing points.
All this has created a false security where the horses go faster!
Speed is not usually the greatest attribute of a long distance steeplechaser.
Measured jumping and stamina were the standard when horses like Red Rum were winning.
So my solution is to put the fences back the way they were (Thirty years ago) so that horses and jockeys will respect them and you will see less fatalities.
07:18 PM on 04/16/2012
I would like to know how many of these people asking for the national or indeed horseracing to be banned eat meat, fish, eggs ?? it surprises me that they are so outraged by horse racing where sadly a few horses die each year compared to the millions of animals we kill to eat meat fish and eggs ( and many of these animals are kept in appalling conditions before being slaughtered ) So for those of you who are so horrified by the fact we breed these poor animals for racing !!! get a grip.. will you be thinking about the poor cow that was killed next time you tuck into your roast dinner, these animals are treated well and are not abused as many of you seem to think. As for the National the one thing I do agree on is that things need to be changed, they should stop lowering the fences, take out beechers, reduce the field and only allow horses with proven stamina and jumping ability to be entered.
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
07:58 PM on 04/16/2012
Horses entered in the grand national have to display proven stamina and jumping ability by winning a steeplechase of three miles or more.
I agree that they should stop lowering the fences. lower fences encourage faster racing.
09:26 PM on 04/16/2012
You are correct, the entrants do have to display proven stamina and jumping ability but there is a difference between staying and winning at 3 miles and staying and winning at 4 and a half miles, some of the entrants have never raced beyond 3 miles and many are inconsistent and sloppy jumpers which combined with the number of horses entered is always going to cause problems
06:36 PM on 04/16/2012
LETS ALL DO THE RIGHT THING, AND call this a grand national history, one horse dying is bad enough, lets stop playing around with other creatures life's, we have many sports to still keep us all occupied without using animals,
06:02 PM on 04/16/2012
I don't think the Grand National should be banned, but it certainly should be made safer for the horses and jockeys. If this cannot be done, then yes it should be banned. Losing horses and at worst Jockey's this race cannot be worth the loss.
04:32 PM on 04/16/2012
I cannot bear the thought of another Grand National next year. It's a depressing national disgrace that we put money and a quick thrill over and above animal welfare. If a domestic animal had been whipped or raced to death, the owner would have been prosecuted. There should not be one law for the Grand National and one law for everyone else. The changes made to the course this year were pathetic. The RSPCA knew damn well that the course was still dangerous and yet they did nothing to prevent the horses from being sent to their deaths. So much for them being committed to the prevention of cruelty to animals. They have failed in their duty, yet again, to safeguard the horses in the Grand National. Making changes will never be enough because the horses' safety can never be guaranteed; therefore, it is immoral for us to keep putting them in danger. Anyone with an ounce of decency would want to safeguard animals. This cruelty must stop NOW.
03:53 PM on 04/16/2012
It is no longer acceptable to cause distress and pain to an animal for entertainment. Synchronised bolted at the beginning of the race because he spooked but he chose to avoid the fence when he reached it and preferred to be caught instead! If this horse "loved it, i'm sure he would have jumped the whole course without stopping wouldnt he?. How many of you racegoers have seen the injuries these horses suffer close up. I expect not many of you, since the screen is erected immediately so as not to cause you any offence. Imagine a broken back,leg,neck, you should be disgusted with yourselves for supporting such cruelty and convincing yourselves that it is sport.
04:35 PM on 04/16/2012
Synchronised didn't break his leg when it fell at Beechers but several fences later when he was free running and jumping fences without a jockey !! It is obvious from the posts that the people that want the National banned are those that aren't interested in Horse Racing anyway. I dont like football and with the incident with Muamba and the death of an Udinese player lets ban that as well. In fact lets ban everything we don't like and stay in bed....no doubt there is someone who does like bed so it looks like we are stuffed !
06:26 PM on 04/16/2012
wrong, i like horse racing but not the grand national, it is a horse killer end off
12:46 AM on 04/17/2012
I am quite aware that Synchronised was riderless when he fell, and I'm also aware that horses continue to run with a herd, especially when amongst the chaos experienced on Saturday. I cannot see how you can compare a footballer to an animal, he obviously chooses to play his sport and doesn't get whipped to play beyond his ability. I suspect that over half of the horses in that race shouldnt have been entered, getting around the course is pure luck not skill. Loose horses can bring down the best of steeplechasers, believe me this race will be banned or changed beyond recognition before long. Sorry to spoil your fun!
03:51 PM on 04/16/2012
Seriously, This is the problem with children and university these days. They spend so much time looking at social awareness and forget the true form of life. We are gifted with powerful brains but obsess with harming annimals and human society, Where will those people be in the future. I will tell you in the exact same place. There is too much faffing about harming gods creatures, I would gladly die for a good person any day and you should say the same or you are a waste of our time, In short these horses are probably much more self aware than you foolishly give them credit. They are our heros, they are our leaders and live and die in a much more noble cause than one of you people complaining could ever come to terms with in you mistaken dysmorphia. Unless we embrace our own annimal nature we will all just simply sit about and complain and never understand what is is to be truly human and live and die in one life, one instance for somthing that changed the way we could live, it is our responsibility and nature.
03:38 PM on 04/16/2012
Yes it is sad that those horse died, but it is upto the greedy owners and trainers to stop their horses from running in the race.
Greedy owners just want the winning horse so they can brag to everyone and then use the horse for stud or breeding for mega bucks.

I love this race after stating the above, it has been around for years, although i don't bet on it i just love to watch it. I also know that not every year a horse is hurt or killed. It would be like saying no greyhound racing as dogs do get hurt and die.
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
08:03 PM on 04/16/2012
Silly uninformed comment award- To musseycat!
Steeplechasers are 99% geldings. (Not a lot of good at stud)
03:25 PM on 04/16/2012
How can this be sport when two beautiful horses died? Nothing is worth this, it is disgusting and terrible, I can't understand how the Grand National has been allowed to carry on in this way. I am not saying it needs to be banned totally but obviously changes need to be made - fewer horses should run and the fences should be re-developed and lowered and Beacher's Brook should be taken out altogether. I have a horse and it breaks my heart to see these wonderful animals being treated in this way. And we call ourselves a nation of animal lovers ...
03:58 PM on 04/16/2012
They were two lovely horses,but get a grip on life,We nearly lost a footballer a short time ago,God forbid if he had of died would the counrty have stopped playing football.
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
08:07 PM on 04/16/2012
Have you spotted the changes in recent years. The reduction in start numbers to forty, the lowering of fences and the changes to take off and landing points.
All this has created a false security where the horses go faster!
Speed is not usually the greatest attribute of a long distance steeplechaser.
Measured jumping and stamina were the standard when horses like Red Rum were winning.
03:18 PM on 04/16/2012
I hate the grand national, those poor horses, and I am also sick of people saying that the horses enjoy it, don't make me laugh they are pushed to do it by the jockey's, if the horses new that they only had 1 in 20 chance of survival they would not want to race, I would never put a horse I owned in such an awfully discusting race, and its not only the grand national its the whole picture of horse racing, I wish it would stop now!!!
03:04 PM on 04/16/2012
Well said to all
02:15 PM on 04/16/2012
I didn't watch the race live as it upsets me (I don't bet either) and whenever I have done in the past I always had a cushion in front of my face so it was a waste of time anyway. From what I can gather Synchronized was "telling" his Jockey that he didn't want to race by throwing him off, therefore causing a false start..and who can blame him only a month after winning the Cheltenham Gold Cup. Desert Orchid never ran in the Grand National and he is ONLY remembered for his other great achievements, which is the way Synchronized would've been remembered if only he'd been withdrawn from the Grand National. This is what he wanted but greed on the part of the owner took over on this occasion. On the flat, if a horse refuses to go in stalls after a few attempts he/she tends to be withdrawn. The same should apply in jump races using this awful tape system, which should be modified in some way but I've no idea how! As for the baying crowd at the start..why don't they just SHUT UP! This ALWAYS spooks the horses and is it any wonder loads always fall at the first fence! Lessen the field to around 25 as well, 40 is way too many.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:02 PM on 04/16/2012
If you watched from the full start of the race on beginning to canter to the starting area Synchronised didn't throw his rider - he actually shied at part of the tape fluttering and by doing that unseated the jockey. The horse ran on easily and was eventually captured. The course vet, who is used to dealing with horses under stress, pronounced the horse fit to take part but only after closely first watching the horse pace and then take a stethoscope for heart and lung soundings.

Had the vet made a decision that the horse should not race, neither owner or trainer would have any input into the matter.