Huddersfield College: 500 Pupils Given Detention For Forgetting Sharpeners And Rubbers

The Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: 17/04/2012 14:21 Updated: 17/04/2012 14:47

Stationery Detention
Pupils were given hour-long detentions for forgetting basic items such as pens and pencils

Hundreds of pupils were handed detentions on their first day back at school - because they forgot to bring sharpeners or rubbers.

In one form group at Colne Valley Specialist Art College in Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, 20 out of 22 students were given detention.

By the end of the day, the number was reported to have hit 500, equating to one in three pupils at the secondary school.

Sarah Sykes, mother of 11-year-old Hannah, told her daughter to boycott the hour-long detention, dubbing the crackdown "ridiculous".

"I think they have taken it too far," she told local paper the Examiner. "Are they running a military school or a high school?"

Quick Poll

Was the school justified to impose such harsh consequences?

VOTE

Other punished offences included forgetting calculators, pencil sharpeners and rubbers.

One pupil was reprimanded despite their calculator being in the maths classroom.

"I got a detention even though I didn't have maths today," the student said.

But headteacher Carol Gormley defended the school's strict new policy, saying a letter was sent out to parents during the Easter holidays to ensure their children had the required equipment on their return to school.

"It is extremely disruptive to learning when large volumes of students need to borrow stationery. We educate our students to be responsible for their own organisation and it is unacceptable to arrive at school without basic equipment.

"It can be difficult for parents to appreciate how much this particular problem can get in the way of teaching in such a large school," Gormley added.

FOLLOW UK EDUCATION

Hundreds of pupils were handed detentions on their first day back at school - because they forgot to bring sharpeners or rubbers. In one form group at Colne Valley Specialist Art College in Hudders...
Hundreds of pupils were handed detentions on their first day back at school - because they forgot to bring sharpeners or rubbers. In one form group at Colne Valley Specialist Art College in Hudders...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 44
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
05:27 AM on 04/22/2012
Gormley by name, Gormless by nature...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissFrijole
My bite is worse than my bark.
02:18 PM on 04/19/2012
As a kid, I developed an anxiety disorder about forgetting things at school or at home. I would forget a textbook at school on Friday and have homework due on Monday. I had no way of doing the assignment. At my school, if you missed three assignments in a given period, you got detention. That's all well and good, but for me, that meant my dad was going to spank the sh&t out of me. He went nuclear every time I got detention for something stupid. I was raised with fear. Now, I am neurotic about everything. If something isn't done on time, I almost have an aneurysm...
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
12:17 PM on 04/19/2012
Must have been a rubber shortage in Huddersfield!
09:08 AM on 04/19/2012
Another no news day.
KenInd
We too shall get through this.....
10:34 PM on 04/17/2012
"....forgot rubbers...."

Oh, I get it. PHSE requirements:

Hotshots for Years 6-8
Durex for Years 9-6th Form.
09:58 PM on 04/17/2012
Horray!! It might be a simple sharpner to a parent... but it is a student who can't complete their work, who interupts others from doing their work when they ask those around them for one and finally a teacher who can't help another student complete their work because they are too busy handing out stationery (which ultimately will be broken/lost/taken by the students). Students and parents need to take responsibility it is not the job of a teacher to provide basic equipment, they are there to teach!
09:12 PM on 04/17/2012
Sometimes it is necessary to make it clear where the line of discipline needs to be drawn. Why make a major issue out of something that has a disciplinary purpose and will help the pupils to understand what an unfair and difficult world we live in. The parents should apply the principles and the children read the fine print. If you ever find yourself whinging that its not reasonable or fair the prepare to fail and live a very disappointed life. Far better to understand the implications of your actions and possible repercussions it will far better prepare you for what you will have to cope with in the real world.
07:55 PM on 04/17/2012
Our children's school also sent a "zero tolerance" letter out just before Easter hols. We do get these from time to time to remind us of school policy and discipline. Lateness, top button done up, shirts tucked, all books and stationery for each subject - or else detention. Nothing like focusing the mind. They attend a large school and discipline is vital.
07:24 PM on 04/17/2012
Parents telling their offspring to rebel against the school and we wonder why discipline has disappeared.
07:56 PM on 04/17/2012
Precisely. Mine had letter also before hols. Yesterday I reminded them everything it said before they walked out the door, or beware of detention consequences. Parents need to support the school.
06:40 PM on 04/17/2012
No swearing at teachers, no bad language, no disruption of lessons, no truancy or bad manners, no uniform misdemeanors? I'd have thought many schools had their work cut out just dealing with major anti-social behaviour without chasing after those who forget sharpeners and rubbers. The children at this school must be very well behaved if they are punished for relatively minor transgressions.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fwdinsight
07:11 PM on 04/17/2012
Maybe they are because they do punish and not promise to.
07:58 PM on 04/17/2012
If my child did not have a pen/pencil for a lesson they would also receive detention. Rules are mandatory for a large school. With over 2000 adolescents discipline needs to reign.
06:37 PM on 04/17/2012
I love the first line. "...they forgot to bring ... rubbers". In the US rubbers has a totally different meaning (condoms).
06:36 PM on 04/17/2012
Pencil Sharpeners! Never why are they allowed in school? they contain blades "Elf and safety"we used to unscrew the blades and bore holes in our desks of course I now realise it was wanton Vandalism. But without us many school furniture manufactures would have gone out of business. Also a close friend of mine would have died when we tied a noose in a roller blind cord and put it round his neck the flirted it back up. Only when he went purple did a friend get out his small pencil sharpener blade and cut the cord. God those terrible 1960's school days how did we survive?
06:21 PM on 04/17/2012
This is excellent! Pupils need to understand that school is a discipline itself and sooner that people understand this the better. The education system in this country is a farce generally and this school is exhibiting proper standards.
06:09 PM on 04/17/2012
It's not 'harsh'... students get detentions all the time. It's just another instance of schools' inconsistency of principles. They want to nurture students to become independent, mature and self reliant, but administer childish sanctions for petty mistakes. I found that often a school's efforts to enforce a rule and it's punishment wasted more time than the disturbance they were trying to combat in the first place.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fredro
06:56 PM on 04/17/2012
Stay in after school and write 100 times: 'its punishment', not 'it's punishment' where 'its' = 'of it'. 'It's' = 'it is'.
majdf18148
I have nothing to declare but my curiosity
08:04 PM on 04/17/2012
(S)he got it right the first two times which is more than many achieve. Might just be a typo or a slip of the finger. I despair of the huge number of people who are unable to cope with the apostrophe s as in plural, possessive singular and possessive plural. But then again I recognise I am a pedant and also suffer from mild OCD, I don't think the majority of people give a fig about such things and why should they as long as they are understood. Apart from me of course it drives me to distraction!
08:00 PM on 04/17/2012
Well I don't agree, I think you will find all those who receive detention will turn up the next day with both a pencil and rubber.
08:25 PM on 04/17/2012
Having not long left high-school, I would strongly suspect that you're right in that most will come equipped the next day, but give it a week or two and you're back at where you started. I'm not saying don't bother giving out punishments, but It's just that I found far more serious issues weren't given as much attention as things like this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norman Mitchison
05:46 PM on 04/17/2012
And the cow jumped over the moon......