Pregnant Woman Naila Mumtaz 'Killed By Evil Spirit'

PA  |  Posted: 24/04/2012 19:42 Updated: 24/04/2012 19:42   PA

Birmingham Crown Court
Members of Naila Mumtaz's family are facing murder charges at Birmingham Crown Court

A pregnant 21-year-old died after being smothered and assaulted by family members who later claimed she may have been killed by an evil spirit, a jury has been told.

Birmingham Crown Court heard that Naila Mumtaz was pronounced dead in hospital in 2009 after the emergency services were called to her home in the Handsworth Wood area of the city.

Her husband, Mohammed Mumtaz, brother-in-law Hammad Hassan and Mr Mumtaz's parents, Salma Aslam and Zia Ul-Haq, deny charges of murder and manslaughter.

Opening the case against the defendants, prosecutor Christopher Hotten QC said Ms Mumtaz was found "ashen" and lying on a bed by ambulance staff in the early hours of 8 July, 2009.

Jurors heard that Ms Mumtaz, who came to Britain in May 2008 after an arranged marriage in Pakistan, was found apparently lifeless by paramedics who arrived at her home in Craythorne Avenue at about 4.30am.

During his opening speech, Mr Hotten said: "Efforts were made to revive her but they failed and at 5.05am she was pronounced dead and with her passing so ended the potential for the life of her unborn child.

"Was she or may she have been possessed by an evil spirit which took her life, as the defendants were to suggest both at the time and after her death?

"Did she die as a result of some undetected or unknown illness or will you be sure that, as we say, she was assaulted, smothered by these four defendants?"

Mr Hotten said the cultural context in which the young woman met her death was of importance to the case, and that a "framework" of telephone evidence would be put before the jury.

Jurors were told that numerous telephone calls were made to Ms Mumtaz's relatives in Pakistan, the emergency services and other individuals in the hours before she was taken to hospital.

During the calls, it is alleged that Ul-Haq claimed that a spirit had been sent from Pakistan, while a female at the house in Craythorne Avenue was allegedly heard to say "don't call an ambulance yet - we will cure her ourselves".

Mumtaz, 24, Ul-Haq, 51, Aslam, 51, and Hassan, 24, all of Craythorne Avenue, also deny causing or allowing the death of a vulnerable adult.

Part-way through Mr Hotten's opening speech, Mumtaz collapsed in the dock in a distressed state and the jury was sent home until Wednesday.

FOLLOW UK

A pregnant 21-year-old died after being smothered and assaulted by family members who later claimed she may have been killed by an evil spirit, a jury has been told. Birmingham Crown Court heard th...
A pregnant 21-year-old died after being smothered and assaulted by family members who later claimed she may have been killed by an evil spirit, a jury has been told. Birmingham Crown Court heard th...
Filed by David Hobbs  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 32
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
15:38 on 25/04/2012
For all sorts of reasons I am not colour racist I am cultural racist
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
14:53 on 25/04/2012
Wow, any competent solicitor would have advised them that ignorance of the law is no defence, and that given their beliefs, they should have pleaded insanity.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PiperSniper
13:41 on 25/04/2012
Shouldn't these comments be "closed"?
photo
edmurfin
Old man, on Bonus Time:-)
10:09 on 25/04/2012
People from a culture which, in many ways, remains primitive, complete with atavistic notions like the existence of peevish minigods and badtempered demons, all of them curiously addicted to taking up residence in human beings or causing harm to them. It's rather worrying to know that ones new neighbour, recently arrived from a country still in process of being civilised, may still have a jungle village mentality. I doubt people worry much about a person's colour - they do worry about the person's culture and about the likelihood of it clashing with their own. Calling such worried folk 'racist' is too simplistic a response.
The defendants in this case, with talk of evil spirit, may be simply trying to convince our system that they are just 'ignorant savages', in the hope of that being accepted as grounds for a mitigation plea after a stiff sentence handed down if proven guilty.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
minimemo
Can I be your friend...if they let me out...
10:07 on 25/04/2012
Mumtaz collapses in the dock.....seems to be a cultural thing when faced with any kind of due legal process.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Saint wright
Dyslexic old chippy
10:00 on 25/04/2012
http://youtu.be/INll6Y5iqbM

please have a look at this Pat Condell i love it?
09:40 on 25/04/2012
Send these heathens back to where they came from, we don't need ignorant people like this in our country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kehlan Sutai Inigan
08:47 on 25/04/2012
If I go to Pakistan or Saudi (not likely) I would have to obey their laws. I can imagine the reaction if I said "Sorry we do things different in the UK, I want to live by UK laws, its my cultural right" so why are they allowed to come here and ignore our laws because it suits them?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Saint wright
Dyslexic old chippy
08:04 on 25/04/2012
Criticism of religion is not racist. In fact open disagreement and the freedom to criticise tradition, culture and religion are essential for social progress. Turning a blind eye to the wrongs, threats and injustices committed by religion and religious states and laws is unfair to the innumerable people who are wronged, threatened and treated unjustly. No religion should be immune to criticism.

i could make the case that the religon they follow should be banned in a civilised country?
07:59 on 25/04/2012
Why do we have to suffer these people here
07:10 on 25/04/2012
No value for life, tis country or the people that live here too! Islam does not belong in the WEST!
05:31 on 25/04/2012
& were still ment to support the beliefs of diffrent cultures we would be called racist to intervin
01:00 on 25/04/2012
Poor woman.Probably didn't live up to their expectations, and that's why she was murdered.
How many more women have been murdered by relatives. We shall never know.Evil b's.
photo
carneliancrystal
Do I believe all the propaganda of course I do
00:13 on 25/04/2012
All evil spirits are covered in skin, warm to the touch, breath air, eat to survive. They endure bodily functions and experiences the same as normal men and women, and are even prone to illness at some times of their existence. Its not too nice when you come up against one or more though. I've exorcised one or two in my time. This womem it appears paid the ultimate price for not exorcising them?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tulliallon
00:10 on 25/04/2012
if these people insist on coming to THE UK the first thing they should know we dont tolerate bone shaking mumbo jumbo might be ok in there old land in uk its called murder