Abortion In Northern Ireland: The Grassroots Network Railing Against The 'Barbaric' Treatment Of Women

The Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: 30/04/2012 17:10 Updated: 30/04/2012 17:10

Abortion Northern Ireland
The 1967 abortion act does not apply to Northern Ireland

Every year women scrimp, save and lie to their families just to get access to basic healthcare.

Some sell their pensions, use a loan shark, beg strangers for help or pawn their engagement rings. It doesn't sound like 21st century Britain but last year, there were more than 1,000 of them. The reason? They were getting an abortion, and they were from Northern Ireland.

The 1967 Abortion Act act, which legalised abortion in England, Wales and Scotland, does not apply in Northern Ireland, making it almost impossible for women there to get an termination on the NHS, even in the case of rape or incest.

Mara Clarke has heard from more than 450 such women in the last three years, each one with a different story - and a different reason for asking for help.

The founder and coordinator of the Abortion Support Network, a volunteer run group inspired by similar grassroots network in the US, which helps fund women in Ireland and Northern Ireland to get terminations, says women are often forced to borrow money to travel to mainland Britain alone and in secret for a terminations.

So why did she set it up? That’s not the right question, she says.“The question is, why in 2012 does an organisation like us have to exist? The people in Ireland are barbaric and inhuman towards women without financial means,” she said.

“If a woman in Northern Ireland gets pregnant, she has to pay for a private abortion, and travel, and lie to people. It is almost impossible to get an abortion in Northern Ireland.”

For Gillian Nicheallaigh, a 37-year-old ASN volunteer originally from Ireland, it’s about helping women who are in the same position she found herself in almost 20 years ago when she travelled to Britain as a student to have an abortion.

She said the experience was “made much more difficult by how it's treated and the secrecy.” She had to borrow money and get help from her boyfriend at the time, describing the experience as “awful.”

“I still find it absolutely unbelievable, incredible and disgusting it's nearly 18 years, 17 years since I experienced what I had to go through, young girls, women, students are still in the same position. I'm aghast,” she says.

"Everyone has always assumed that if you have an abortion you carry a shame with you. I carry neither. Emphatically it was the right decision. I have no shame.”

But in the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland, not everyone feels the same: “I know grown, adult women who are parents basically collapsing under the pressure of the secrecy they have to exist within because they felt they couldn't tell anybody for fear of the stigma. They are worried their friends would treat them differently,” she says.

“I think a lot of women in Northern Ireland don't realise they have the same legal rights as the rest of the British citizens and are faced with just as much stigma.”

Clarke says the stigma can be toxic: “Some of these women won’t tell anybody they’ve been raped because they are scared someone they know would hear.

“We have been contacted by the mothers of at least two young people who were so terrified they tried to self abort. One of them, her daughter had taken medication to try to abort but she was still pregnant,” she says. “These are desperate women begging a stranger in another country for help.

“There just seems to be this huge culture of shame. This idea that oh, you had sex, you are a dirty slut, the punishment is motherhood.”

Then there are tales of women who have had the word murderer painted across their houses by boyfriends who have found out, or who have had to beg, borrow and steal just to fund a termination.

According to the ASN, women sell their pensions, use money lenders, don’t pay their rent, return Christmas presents and sell their engagement rings.

“What would you do if you were desperate? The majority of women already have at least one child, they range from 14 to their late 40s,” Clarke says.

“I can’t even tell you the number of times the words recession, redundant, unemployment comes up.”

“Everyone says Ryan Air’s cheap - not when these women need to fly, it isn’t.”

Audrey Simpson, the director of the family planning association (FPA) in Northern Ireland says they have protesters outside their building, which offers pregnant women counselling, almost every day - some calling women murderers and following them down the street.

Simpson says the protesters feel emboldened in Northern Ireland because the "argument has been won" in mainland Britain.

"They say Northern Ireland is the last bastion to create an abortion-free state. They're determined the law will not be liberalised in every way."

As for any law change, they've been involved in a near-11 year legal process just to get guidelines distributed to obstetricians in Northern Ireland.

"Some terminations are legal here, to protect the life of the mother. That's a very wide-ranging definition and clinicians don't know how to interpret that.

"We went to court in June 2001 firstly to get the law clarified and secondly to get guidelines sent to obstetricians. It's taking 11 years to get a good practice guidelines."

For now, Simpson says the women are the ones suffering: "If you're being forced to leave your country to do something your country is subtly saying what your doing is wrong. They have gone through a school system and a church system where more often than not that abortion is murder."

She says the ASN is she only network she knows that help women financially, but warns “this problem is going to get increasingly worse.”

"Women can't be open. Northern Ireland has a large village mentality, so you have to go to the airport and if you see someone you know you have to lie. It's totally ludicrous, we are UK citizens so what's different about women in Northern Ireland?

"I think women are now becoming, as the economic situation bites, are becoming more vocal and saying 'why as women are we being punished' just because we happen to have an unplanned or a crisis pregnancy.”

BPAS, the biggest abortion provider in Britain, acknowledge that there a problems. Public Policy Manager Abigail Fitzgibbon said the situation is “deeply unfair.”

"I think the thing about abortion in Northern Ireland is that it's clear from the abortion statistics that women who live in Northern Ireland do have abortions.

“Because they cannot access them legally at home they end up travelling to England. It's not the case that there's no need for them, they have to travel and it can be extremely expensive and distressing.”

Clarke doesn't want to just help teenagers who have have been raped "though we have plenty," she wants to help everyone who needs support to get a termination.

“This isn’t a moral thing, it’s a class issue. If you have money it’s not a big deal, you have a passport, you have a credit card. Women without money can just have a baby,” she says.

A letter from a 42 year old mother-of-three not originally from Ireland who used the network shows just how much their help is needed.

“I didn’t really know what an odyssey I had to experience in order to have an abortion, living in Ireland,” the woman writes.

“Thank God, my GP was very understanding and I was able to get an appointment with a family planning clinic the next day. It was so reassuring to find understanding and guidance there. Up to that moment I hadn’t even thought about financing this.” When the bank refused to extend her overdraft, she went to Clarke.

Now, for the first time demand for their help has meant they’ve had to turn women who cannot afford to pay for an abortion away.

The FPA’s Simpson says that as effects of the recession worsen in Northern Ireland, more women who cannot afford to pay for an abortion or travel abroad will resort to “unsafe” practices like buying abortion pills online.

“The recession is beginning to really bite here and they've heard you can buy early medical abortion pills on the internet and some are resorting to that. The BBC investigated this and found some of the pills women were buying were not those pills.”

So are women putting their health at risk? “The abortion pill is a very safe drug but it is prescribed under medical conditions, it's not to be taken in their own homes”

Clarke, a former US resident, says there are small signs that the attitude toward termination is changing in mainland and Northern Ireland. In the north it’s acknowledged a small number of terminations do take place every year, mostly in the case of foetal abnormalities.

But she wants to more change: “We wish that more people would realise when you criminalise abortion it’s poor women you are hurting. For most women, what really causes the distress is the fact they can’t access services. Their test is positive and their world just collapses.”

FOLLOW UK

Every year women scrimp, save and lie to their families just to get access to basic healthcare. Some sell their pensions, use a loan shark, beg strangers for help or pawn their engagement rings. I...
Every year women scrimp, save and lie to their families just to get access to basic healthcare. Some sell their pensions, use a loan shark, beg strangers for help or pawn their engagement rings. I...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mirola
Read between the lines
10:08 PM on 05/01/2012
Northern Ireland has got a lot of catching up to do with the rest of the UK, let alone the rest of the world, on almost all fronts, we are at least a decade behind the times. Personally I think we can blame The Troubles for that as for decades life almost stood still, hardly any developments on whatever front, one blamed the other blamed the army blamed the police from bomb to bullet and back, almost no time for anything else.
Hopefully Stormont is, albeit slowly, waking up to the world to recognize that things need to move on, this is just one of these things..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skulander
01:56 AM on 05/01/2012
That's the huge hypocrisy in Ireland. They're not a "pro-life" nation as they so often boast. They are a nation that traps its women and force them to use drastic measures to access basic health care. Ireland should be ashamed of itself.
11:39 PM on 04/30/2012
I am not a pro-lifer but I do feel that all omen should have the right to have an abortion if they are a victim of rape but I do not think that women should be able to use this as a form of contraception.
11:13 PM on 04/30/2012
Northern Ireland women are second class citizens as this proves. Ulster is a poor uneducated theocratic backwater, tribal closed on Sundays is the best way to describe it. Just look at the numerous slack jawed kids running about the streets and soon you'd be wishing they had been aborted because they are growing up unwanted and unloved by parents that drink to forget how they became trapped by a mistake. If you think I'm being over dramatic then just try living here after you've lived somewhere civilised .
10:50 PM on 04/30/2012
This is a very controversial subject, but being honest I am appalled that to this day in the century we are in; it is still going on. One thing I am concerned about, is that still, the onus, the blame, the shame is placed solely in the hands of the women. Some of these women are facing a taboo subject and, even the subject of sex itself is still taboo within some groups. The pressure must be appalling, especially when so many women in need of abortion are only young. It is about time we highlighted their bravery in what they are enduring, and stop placing negative stigma upon them.
This comment has been removed.
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
09:00 PM on 04/30/2012
If the pro lifers and religionists get their way in the UK, it won't be long before English, Scottish and Welsh women are secretly queuing up for Dutch termination clinics....and paying through the nose for it, like these poor women.

RESIST
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deluk
disgusted.
09:09 PM on 04/30/2012
Luckily people are resisting,and the pro lifers and religionists are such a tiny if vocal minority that they will never hold sway.
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
09:15 PM on 04/30/2012
Quite right, thanks for the reminder - I sometimes forget that empty vessels make most noise, and those pro-lifers are certainly that!
07:52 PM on 04/30/2012
eternallaw, are you a woman?

Shaming women into having children is not the right way to act if you want to stop unplanned pregnancy.

Education about safe methods of sex (a rarity in secondary education systems in this country) is the correct method of stopping unplanned pregnancies.

Many women DO NOT feel shame or distress about having abortions. This does not make them cruel or heartless. It is simple a fact. These women had to make choices, choices that for many were easy. The life with an unwanted child however, would be incredibly difficult. You should not force women into isolation because of unplanned pregnancy, they didn't want this to happen IT WAS UNPLANNED!

So much anger at the moment so I'll end my comments here. There is simply too much shame surrounding this issue and that is why it cannot be openly and rationally discussed. No one suggesting forcing women into having abortions, but the right to choose, the right to be able to make that choice, surely it is inhumane to take that away.
06:49 PM on 04/30/2012
Until the attitude to sex changes these problems will persist. It has become far too easy for young women to regard abortion as a form of contraception. This article talks about shame like it's a bad thing - no it isn't. Shame helps to instill morality. It is precisely due to a general lack of any sense of shame that makes young people act the way they do, and why society as a whole is in the state it is. People want to do whatever they want and don't even consider there may be consequences. Support women yes but not by giving them a simple get out clause. Lets not forget, some women have an abortion and never get over the grief. Abortion destroys lives, not just foetuses
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
09:05 PM on 04/30/2012
The only thing shame has ever helped to instill is guilt.
And just how do young people 'act'? 95%, very responsibly, intelligently, empathically. You clearly don't know "young people".

eternallaw, get a grip! If you want to blame someone for the ills of society, look no further than the Houses of Parliament and their cronies.
07:23 AM on 05/01/2012
Guilt is a natural reaction that people are forgetting how to deal with or are choosing to ignore which is why we now live in a "blame somebody else" culture. I DO know young people, which is why I am qualified to make this remark. If 95% of young people acted responsibly, the figures of unwanted pregnancy and std's would be a damned sight lower than it is. When are people going to start taking responsibility for their own actions?? Supporting people to help them deal with their mistakes is what I condone, not a quickfix and blame parliament!
11:22 PM on 04/30/2012
Shame on you, eternallaw. Are you going to support the children that these women and their partners (or is it just women who should be ashamed in your world?) cannot afford? The day I hear pro-lifers giving a hoot about the unborn after they become, you know, people is the day I'll think this has anything at all to do with saving 'destroyed lives'.
07:28 AM on 05/01/2012
Well if you actually read my comment you would see that I favour support for women. That would include their children, however, it's better to not get into this situation in the first place.
06:03 PM on 04/30/2012
It's comments like the above by Clownzozo that mean we will never have a rational debate on this issue. Facts simply do not matter to some people.
This comment has been removed.