Teenagers Should Take Charge Of Lessons To Encourage Them To Teach, Say MPs

PA  |  Posted: 1/05/2012 05:53 Updated: 1/05/2012 11:17   PA

Teachers Classroom

Teenagers should be put in charge of lessons to encourage them to train as teachers, MPs said on Tuesday.

"Teaching taster classes" should be offered to sixth-formers and undergraduates to show them the benefits of a career in the profession, according to the Commons Education Select Committee.

It also called for would-be teachers to be observed in the classroom before they are offered a training place to check their suitability for the job.

In a new report, the influential committee examined the best ways of recruiting and retaining the best teachers.

Evidence has shown that very good teachers boost pupils' grades and make a significant difference to their students' future earnings, it said.

The report says that allowing young people to try out teaching could improve the quality of applicants and lead to a lower drop-out rate.

The government should consider developing a formal "internship" system, similar to one run in Singapore, to allow youngsters to experience the "content, benefits and career potential" of teaching before committing to it.

These "taster sessions" should include actual teaching, rather than just observing lessons, the committee said, with students given feedback afterwards.

"Applying to do teacher training is a 'high stakes' decision and the purpose of these sessions is to give people a chance to try out their own aptitude before committing," the report said.

"We believe this approach could help both deter some people who are not best suited to teaching and persuade others to consider it."

The committee also called for all teacher trainers to observe potential recruits in lessons before offering them a training place.

"Our evidence was clear that teacher quality cannot be fully established without observing a candidate actually teach," the report says.

The MPs backed ministers' plans to toughen up the literacy and numeracy tests taken by trainee teachers but suggested caution over the introduction of a test of candidates' personal skills.

The committee said it welcomed the idea but called for the Department for Education to publish details of what the test might include and keep it under close review.

It raised concerns about the government's move to use a potential teacher's degree class to determine whether or not they get a bursary to train.

Under the government's plans, anyone with a third-class degree will not be eligible for funding. But the committee said that the bursary scheme alone will not attract more people into teaching.

"Whilst bursaries will help to attract people with strong academic records, greater effort is also needed to identify which subset of these also possess the additional personal qualities that will make them well-suited to teaching," the report says.

It also backed ministers' plans to create "teaching schools" to train teachers.

While it acknowledged that these schools will be expected to work with universities, the committee warned against any reduction of universities' role in teacher training which would bring "considerable demerits".

The report suggests the creation of a National Teacher Sabbatical Scholarship scheme to allow outstanding teachers to take time out of the classroom to work in a different school, undertake research or refresh their subject knowledge.

It echoes a suggestion made by Ofsted chief inspector Sir Michael Wilshaw, who said in November that good teachers who suffer "burnout" should be given time off.

It also called for the government to develop plans for a new "College of Teaching", a professional body modelled along the lines of Royal College or chartered institutes seen in other professions.

Committee chairman Graham Stuart said: "It's crucial that we have an educational system which celebrates great teachers, keeps more of them in the classroom, supports their development and gives them greater status and reward."

Loading Slideshow...
  • Zoo keeper Jo Shirley from ZSL Whipsnade Zoo, Dunstable, Bedfordshire, with an orphaned baby wallaby that is being hand-reared by keepers. Picture date: Monday April 30, 2012. The orphaned baby wallaby is busy settling into her new home - which comes in the shape of a rucksack. Tiny Tilly is being hand-reared by keepers at ZSL Whipsnade Zoo after she was found out of her mum's pouch a month ago. She is being looked after by keeper Jo Shirley who carries her around in a substitute pouch made from a rucksack wherever she goes - just as her real mum would do. Photo credit should read: Steve Parsons/PA Wire

  • London Mayoral candidate Ken Livingstone at the launch in south London of a poster supporting his campaign to be Mayor of London today. Picture date: Monday April 30 2012. The London mayoral election takes place on May 3. See PA story POLITICS Mayor. Photo credit should read: Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire

  • A seagull lands on a man's head at Circular Quay in Sydney, Australia, Tuesday, May 1, 2012.(AP Photo/Rob Griffith)

  • Jeon Sang-Guen of South Korea competes in the Men's +105kg during day seven of the Asian Weighlifting Championships at Yichung Culture & Sports Center on April 30, 2012 in Pyeongtaek, South Korea. (Photo by Chung Sung-Jun/Getty Images)

  • Manchester City manager Roberto Mancini and Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson (left) argue on the touchline.

  • Women dressed as witches dance during the Walpurgis Night at the famous Hexentanzplatz (Witches' dance ground)' in the Harz mountains near Thale, northern Germany, Monday, April 30, 2012. Hundreds of costumed devils and witches meet to celebrate Walpurgis Night, a traditional religious holiday of pre-Christian origins. (AP Photo/Jens Meyer)

  • A torn safety net on One World Trade Center provides a window view of the Manhattan skyline, Monday, April 30, 2012 in New York. One World Trade Center is being built to replace the twin towers destroyed in the Sept. 11 attacks. It reached just over 1,250 feet on Monday. That's just taller than the observation deck on the Empire State Building. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan, Pool)

  • Palestinian protester, wearing a national flag mask, takes cover during clashes with Israeli troops outside Ofer military prison near the West Bank city of Ramallah on May 1, 2012, following a demonstration in support for prisoners held in Israeli jails. Clashes erupted between stone-throwing youths and the Israeli army, who fired tear gas, rubber bullets and a foul-smelling liquid known as 'skunk' to break up the demonstration. AFP PHOTO/ABBAS MOMANI (Photo credit should read ABBAS MOMANI/AFP/GettyImages)

  • Militants and labour union members gather around a burning the effigy of Philippine President Benigno Aquino in Manila on May 1, 2012 as part of the May Day protests demanding higher wages and policies that would make it harder to fire workers. Aquino has said he is trying to help labour but has warned that giving too many benefits will make the country less competitive, costing more jobs. AFP PHOTO/NOEL CELIS (Photo credit should read NOEL CELIS/AFP/GettyImages)

  • Swan glide through the flooded riverside walkways in the shadow of the cathedral in Worcester. (PA)

FOLLOW UK EDUCATION

Filed by Lucy Sherriff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 48
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
21:37 on 02/05/2012
I routinely get selected Year 6 children to come out to the whiteboard and take the rest of the class through the strategy they used to solve a Maths problem, for example. It's a powerful way of engaging the whole class and it gives them a break from my voice! Also the child in question learns to express often quite tricky ideas, and communicate them effectively - while handling the whiteboard technology!

I think it's a good idea, but like many things, it requires a good teacher to supervise it.
23:55 on 01/05/2012
no they shouldn't.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NOSHER
20:48 on 01/05/2012
i think they should put some of these people who pass this comment ie mp s should be made to teach i was a bad pupil in the way i carried on and joked on and i wouldnt have a teachers job if they gave me 3 times the wage they get now ,they have a hell of a lot of rubbish to put up with and they do as good a job as they can when .i did anything wrong i got the cain or a clout around the ear it did me good .but now a days there are too many do gooders that wont let the teachers be incharge and the kids no that ine been a better man with that discipline
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
20:21 on 01/05/2012
I have the utmost respect for teachers who work in state schools that are overcrowded, and have a large number of disinterested pupils. Curriculum is king and judgement by exam results and inspections is a sword of Damocles.
I am often reading comments about the huge amount of 'Extra' work teachers do at week-ends and in the holidays. (Maybe some teachers need to learn time management and planning)
Maybe some teachers are frightened they cannot get enough information accross in lessons and set too much homework or too many projects. Either way- there are some who appear to cope adequately and others who struggle.
With a few senior pupils supervising lessons the strugglers may find a way to catch up!
19:22 on 01/05/2012
That idea is 'old hat'!
This comment has been removed.
17:16 on 01/05/2012
This brings back memories. I left school at 16 and at 17 I went back to teach music lessons to a number of classes for a while, simply because I wanted to put something back into what was a very good school.
14:22 on 01/05/2012
There are far more fundamental issues to attract people into the profession than just early teaching practice. The role of teachers has never been more important and yet their social standing has never been lower. This is not the fault of teachers but of the poor support offered by parents. Parenting has become a very detached activity and not focussed on the child. Often parents will abdicate their responsibilities expecting the teacher to perform such basic parenting as potty training.
The recent report following the London riots emphasised the important role of teachers in breaching the gap in parenting, particularly where parents have failed to instill positive attitudes and discipline in their child. Given that such behaviour seems to be rife then that is an awesome responsibility. It will not happen until teachers are more valued by the whole of society and given the unquestioning support of parents.
This has recently been discussed by the Silverlinksnetwork which is worth commenting on.http://www.silverlinksnetwork.com/news-a-politics/41-education-standards
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
21:29 on 02/05/2012
That's a really interesting link! Thanks.
13:27 on 01/05/2012
We already have a PM and MP's that act like teenagers in all political parties running the country.
Time this country gave itself a good shaking up.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fozwords
Abandon hope when you post on here
16:52 on 01/05/2012
Thats our job mate a tthe next election.
Southern law girl
Researching my viewpoint....
12:57 on 01/05/2012
In theory this is an excellent idea providing, as stated by digbury, the concept is not used as a way of bolstering up staff shortages. This would give 5th and 6th Formers the chance to build confidence and an opening into the public speaking arena. On the latter, in most cases that is all that is needed, a starting chance. Once that confidence is built in the world is their 'oyster'.

I have always thought the idea of twinning up pubic and state schools, in that the public schools who get top results could pass on their experiences to state schools, including an input from bright teenagers to partner state school children who are having problems with simple skills such as reading, writing, and maths. I agree there are points for and against, but it gives pupils who are having problems a chance to improve. I have a friend, when she lived in England, helped at a local state school with children who were having problems, the results were amazing, the one to one basis worked wonders! She was bored after retiring, so I suggested she helped a local school, she did, it worked!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fredro
13:44 on 01/05/2012
While it seems somewhat condescending of you to suggest that the ability/need stream is all 'pubic-' or public-schools-to-state-sector, in essence I agree with you.One big advantage of age-peer 'teachers' is their familiarity with the problems etc. confronting slightly younger pupils. I taught at a college of drama for 14 years, initially not much older than my students. Gradually, I lost that early peer-contact, which resulted in often more-informed and -professional teaching on my part, but with an important loss in empathy and understanding.
Southern law girl
Researching my viewpoint....
17:49 on 01/05/2012
Hello again!

Sorry about the Freudean slip, or parapraxis if you prefer ;-)

Not sure about the condescending bit, LOL, but the State Sector could certainly do with some fresh input. I understand the peer-contact problem, but sometimes 5th and 6th Formers are able to approach the pupils more on their own level. Anyway, it's certainly a subject to moot.

Regards!
06:20 on 10/06/2012
State schools do not need public schools to tell them how to teach, I find this patronizing in the extreme. What state schools need is idiot politicians micro managing the curriculum and a robust discipline system which blames and yes PUNISHES the offender.
State schools in poor areas have many problems completely beyond the understanding of public schools.
Supposed essay on poverty from Eton College.
Father was poor Mother was poor even the butler was poor.
I think that says it all.
Durham University has to tell freshers about the poverty in the city as they have no understanding of just how some people live.
This comment has been removed.
12:24 on 01/05/2012
The Commons Education Select Committee should be run by schoolchildren. Yeah right.
11:49 on 01/05/2012
let poles do it they 'll work fer nowt
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Mickey Mouse 1
There are no lies or deceit on a chess board.
11:47 on 01/05/2012
"Teenagers should be put in charge of lessons to encourage them to train as teachers, MPs said on Tuesday."

Is this another way of saying that teenagers are wasting their time in school because they won't get a job outside when they leave?
11:08 on 01/05/2012
looking at many schools exam results and bad behaviour i was under the impression that the kids did run a lot of schools.
12:23 on 01/05/2012
Couldn't agree more,The teachers aren't allowed to be in control.
Southern law girl
Researching my viewpoint....
13:44 on 01/05/2012
Ditto!