Paula Stevenson 'Bribed Nurse With £100 Gift Voucher Over Fears Daughter Was Being Neglected', Inquest Hears

Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: 01/05/2012 10:16 Updated: 04/05/2012 13:27

A bereaved mother sobbed as she told an inquest she bought a £100 gift voucher for an NHS nurse in the hope of better care for her one-year-old daughter.

Hayley Fullerton died of heart failure at Birmingham Children's Hospital on November 11, 2009, one month after her first birthday.

She had been born in Northern Ireland on October 6 2008 with a heart defect and a hole in the heart, and underwent palliative surgery at the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast weeks later, Birmingham Coroner's Court heard.

SEE ALSO 'I'm Really Sorry': Mother Apologised To 'Neglected' Daughter For Being Unable To Help Her (PICTURES)

In October 2009 Hayley was flown to Birmingham Children's Hospital for corrective heart surgery. Her mother Paula Stevenson told the court the operation was a success and Hayley was transferred to the hospital's Paediatric Intensive Care Unit.

However, while in the hospital's care, Hayley's right lung collapsed and her health began to deteriorate, Mrs Stevenson said.

The 40-year-old told Aidan Cotter, Coroner for Birmingham and Solihull, that after her daughter was discharged from the intensive care unit she was placed in ward 12, where she "thrived".

Scroll down for more pictures of Hayley Fullerton

Hayley pictured celebrating her first birthday. She died a month later

The mother said she voiced concerns with hospital staff when she found out that Hayley was to be moved to ward 11 on November 2 because she was worried that staff on that ward would be unfamiliar with her medical history.

Staff assured her that Hayley would be placed in a high dependency unit but instead she was "dumped" at the end of a ward, Mrs Stevenson told the inquest.

She said: "I was horrified to find Hayley dumped at the door, the furthest away from the nurses station. Hayley was not in high dependency and I knew I had been lied to.

"I was extremely upset and felt that Hayley was being punished and placed as far away as possible because of my reluctance for her to be moved.

"No-one took any notice of Hayley's monitors, even when they alarmed."

Mrs Stevenson added: "I even bought a £100 gift voucher in an attempt to bribe one of them. I hoped the other nurses would hear about it and look after Hayley in the hope they would get one too but nothing worked."

Mrs Stevenson, who is from Northern Ireland but now lives in Australia's Gold Coast with Hayley's father Bobby Fullerton, said her daughter struggled with her breathing, slept a lot and began to look "puffy", raising concerns that she was retaining water, but she said that when she or her parents raised concerns to the hospital staff they were dismissed and assured that everything was "fine".

Hayley was later placed in an isolation unit in what Mrs Stevenson believes was a move to silence her, not because of any medical concern.

She said she spoke to hospital staff and told them she believed her daughter had been neglected, adding: "This makes me wonder whether my constant pleas for help had caused Hayley to be put in isolation in order to shut me up."

Mrs Stevenson said: "I was too scared to make a fuss because the last time I did Hayley was dumped at the door instead of being placed in high dependency. I wish I had.


Hayley was born with a heart defect and a hole in her heart

"I could not believe that Hayley had just been left to deteriorate. I could not believe what was happening. All along the family had expressed their concerns about Hayley's breathing and had even asked if there was a problem with her lungs, yet nothing was done.

"All she did was sleep. I missed my little girl so much and I felt as though I hadn't seen her eyes in so long, her big blue eyes. What was happening to Hayley was destroying me.

"We had known all along that there was something wrong with Hayley's lungs. I do not understand how things were left to get so bad."

Asked why she did not submit a formal complaint at the time, Mrs Stevenson said: "I did not want to waste my time completing the documentation when Hayley needed me.

"Looking back, I wish I had made the formal complaint because maybe that would have changed the dreadful outcome for Hayley.

"I didn't want to go away and make an official complaint because then all the focus was on the complaint and not the baby."

On November 11 both of Hayley's lungs collapsed and she suffered a cardiac arrest. Mrs Stevenson, who was by her daughter's side when she died, told the court: "I saw that Hayley was really gasping for breath.

"Her eyes were panic-stricken and they started rolling back in her head. I could see that her neck was starting to collapse in.

"I knew within seconds that she was in serious trouble. I cried for help but nobody heard me. The door was shut because we were in isolation.

"Hayley looked awful, she was like a fish out of water. She was gasping and gasping for every breath."

Mrs Stevenson said there were around 15 people in the room working to save her daughter. She said: "All the time I was stroking her head and telling her she was the best wee girl in the world.

"They worked on her until their hands hurt. All I could see was the monitor flashing (cardiac) arrest.

"All the time I kept squeezing her hand gently just to see if she would squeeze it back. Hayley never squeezed my hand back. It was cold and lifeless.

"After 19 minutes everyone had stopped looking at Hayley and they were now all looking at me with pity in their eyes.

"At 20 minutes he (the doctor) confirmed my worst fears. He said, 'sorry mum, we've lost her', and all I could think about was that I was no longer a mummy because Hayley was my only child and she was dead. I was in shock and utterly devastated.

"The treatment has led me to question how can the staff at Birmingham Children's Hospital fail Hayley so abominably?"

Mrs Stevenson added: "I was livid at the ward 11 staff, my family and I had warned them.

"I truly believe if the medical team had listened to me and my parents Hayley would still be alive today. They turned their backs on her. She was overlooked, neglected and suffered while she was alive.

"I cannot begin to explain the impact that this has had on myself and my family. Both Bobby and I are devastated. Hayley's experience at Birmingham Children's Hospital can only be described as brutal."

The hearing continues.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Hayley Fullerton

    (PA)

  • Hayley Fullerton

    (PA)

  • Hayley Fullerton

    (PA)

  • Hayley Fullerton

    (PA)

  • Hayley Fullerton

    (PA)

  • Hayley Fullerton

    (PA)

FOLLOW UK

A bereaved mother sobbed as she told an inquest she bought a £100 gift voucher for an NHS nurse in the hope of better care for her one-year-old daughter. Hayley Fullerton died of heart failure at...
A bereaved mother sobbed as she told an inquest she bought a £100 gift voucher for an NHS nurse in the hope of better care for her one-year-old daughter. Hayley Fullerton died of heart failure at...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 216
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
11:49 AM on 05/02/2012
oh such a beautiful baby my heart goes out to the family such a tragedy we never know what is around that corner do we . i am so sorry i do really feel your pain god bless all of you .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daviejohn
All the world's a stage,
10:21 AM on 05/02/2012
A tragic story, while there may be some blame individually to be put at a particular door, it is not fair to blame the whole Hospital. Nursing staff in general have the patients care at heart, but there is always a percentage where this ethic can not be said to be true. I hope the family are able to recover fully from their ordeal.
06:28 AM on 05/02/2012
Sadly believe the mother. It has been well known for a long time that our elderly are almost routinely left in their own mess and given no help to eat or drink and it comes as no surprise that the childrens wards are going the same way.
03:01 AM on 05/02/2012
Why this rush to condemn an entire hospital, its nursing staff and doctors without hearing their side of the story? Has it occurred to anyone that there may be no case to answer. How odd that this woman, who now lives in Australia, has waited almost three years to publically complain after an alleged incident of negligence that resulted in her childs death.

If something as heartless as she describes had happened to any normal person, they, and their families would have pursued it immediately with the authorities. Failing that legal action against the NHS would surely have been the next step to take. Since none of those options seem to have been taken at the time, it has to raise some reasonable doubt about the validity of her account of what actually did happen. Call me cynical, but let's hope that this is not a long-distance retrospective claim in the hope of compensation being paid for by the UK taxpayer. Justice is best served by the legal system and not by witch hunts prompted by inconclusive press reports.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ms Chopsy
Don't let reality ruin your day!
03:59 AM on 05/02/2012
Ok, you're cynical! You talk of a rush to condemn yet think this woman is a money grabbing liar! I imagine anyone who has spent any time at all in a hospital can see how this might have happened. Has there not been enough undercover filming done yet to convince you?
05:09 AM on 05/02/2012
Ms Chopsy,

I merely expressed a view that that may be a motive or a possibility, I never mentioned that I thought it was a certainty; I did say, let's hope that this was not the case. It is not quite the same as some of the 'absolute' accusations levelled at hospital staff thus far on this thread . That is my opinion and the last time I looked we were all entitled to have one. The fact that it differs from your own is irrelevant to me, as mine should be to you.

For your information I have spent time in NHS hospitals in the past. The last occasion five years ago was for a particularly nasty heart attack and were it not for the promptness and professionalism of ambulance service paramedics, the nurses and doctors in intensive care I would have been another statistic in an obituary column. I'm sure the service varies marginally from location to location and the food is never going to be five-star cuisine; but one can only comment and judge on their own experience. I now enjoy full health with only minimal medication required - so what would you expect me to say? I shudder to think where we would be without the NHS however imperfect you and others may deem it to be. Trusting that you never have need of it.
12:15 AM on 05/02/2012
It's a no win situation because once they decide they don't like you for whatever reason, the lack of professionalism quickly sets in. And then they decide they don't like your relative either because they don't like you and they all close ranks in their unfairness. GP's are the same. They will freeze you out if you rock the boat in any way, making it so that you have to find another doctor. But it's not so easy for us to discharge a family member and take them to another hospital is it. You don't have any rights in an NHS hospital because you're not paying directly. With private health care you have more leverage to make requests and demands, either nicely or unnicely. You tried various tactics to get proper health care for your child, even resorting to bribery. What more could you have done! The NHS has become an institution without a soul!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:28 PM on 05/01/2012
lovng parents worry about their children, it's normal to want the best for your child, the nurse shouldn't have excepted anything, nurses work very hard and do a good job.
10:58 PM on 05/01/2012
I have nothing but praise for the wonderful staff at the Birmingham Children's Hospital, you can only speak of your own experience, the way my son was looked after and how me and my partner were treated was exceptional.
10:54 PM on 05/01/2012
The NHS in the UK used to be the best treatment possible, it is now the worst treatment ever. Filthy hospitals, staff who do not speak English,cleaners who have no idea how to clean and the list goes on and on. At one time Doctors and Nurses became Doctors and Nurses because they cared, it is now just a Job and if neglect happens who cares is the attitude !!!!. Bring back the Matron who ran the hospital; with precision and get rid of all the paperwork pushers who are draining the NHS and lining their pockets.
11:18 PM on 05/01/2012
You are talking rubbish. Have you ever travelled the world and actually experienced hospital care abroad? I doubt it, if truths known I doubt if you have even been out of the country. I have, I have travelled extensively and have received medical and hospital care abroad and let me tell you, you don't know how lucky you are to live in the UK and to receive such good care, its not the norm throughout the world. Some care abroad is good, most is bad because of lack of money but overall none are as good as the care you get in the UK free. As for your remarks about cleaning, doctors and nurses, matrons and pen pushers, you are just repeating parrot fashion what you are programmed to think. Try thinking for yourself and resist being a parrot for those with ulterior motives, try to look at things objectively and reach your own conclusions, not someone else's.
02:37 AM on 05/02/2012
My mother ended up in a hospital in Crete, apparently the best on the island - they don't provide bed pans or empty them, you have to supply your own and if you can't empty it yourself, have a relative to do it. They provide tablets, but if you want water to take them, someone has to go to the shop across the road and buy it for you. The wooden rail around the wall to stop the bed damaging the paintwork, was a motorway for the cockroaches. Mealtime choice "Rice or Soup" if you had rice it came from a pot - if you had soup.... it came from the SAME pot only they used a ladle instead of a strainer. Her injury they sliced like a gammon waiting for garlic cloves and didn't bandage or cover it. She wasn't allowed to fly because of her injury and seeping wound. I flew from England and DROVE her back to the UK in 3 days (including two overnight ferry crossings) 1600 miles. She cried with joy when we saw the sign for Dover Hospital
08:21 AM on 05/02/2012
For your information I have workd abroad and have travelled to many countries and yes I have had treatment whilst abroad. You do not know what you are talking about. I have children who live abroad.
10:40 PM on 05/01/2012
I hope the nurse who accepted the £100 voucher was severely disciplined. Nurses are not allowed to accept gifts of £5 and over
10:36 PM on 05/01/2012
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_yAV-K_ssg&feature=g-upl

This is what alot of NHS are like
11:03 PM on 05/01/2012
What the hell has two sleeping security guards got to do with the care provided by nurses?
10:05 PM on 05/01/2012
My heart goes out to you ,,,We are all full of "if onlys" What a shocking story ...
09:50 PM on 05/01/2012
There are some fantastic, dedicated people working in our NHS, and demands on the service must be very stressful on staff. But I'm sure I'm not alone in hearing too many stories of neglect, insensitivity and even bullying of people by some in the profession, especially by those in the position of caring for people who are particularly vulnerable and in no position to 'fight back'. In my own family, I've had experience of both amazing, life-saving care on one hand and disgraceful cruelty by someone who should never be in a caring profession on the other! I believe for every official complain made, there are dozens more that go unreported...and so it's up to those dedicated staff to ensure that those giving the NHS an ever increasingly bad reputation are outed and ousted!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
inkwell92
10:00 PM on 05/01/2012
Well said
10:12 PM on 05/01/2012
i totally agree, as a nurse myself i have seen some nurses who do not deserve to be called a caring professional, families are not the only ones who complain, staff do to. But due all the government rules and regulations, its not as easy to get rid of staff as we would like to think. Unfortunelty the staff that have care and compassion for the patients they look after are branded with the same mark, as you can read in this discussion (or stoning it feels like to me).

What this family had to go through is awful and my heart goes out to them for the loss of there little girl.
09:50 PM on 05/01/2012
my heart goes out to this family what a terrible thing to go though rip little angle xx
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
denspark1560
09:49 PM on 05/01/2012
The NHS is still a magnificent institution that despite constant Government interference, is still something we Brits should be proud of. As one who has spent a lifetime in and out of hospital I have never ever felt I've had anything but the best of care at all times.

I'm not defending what happened in the case of this child, I don't know the full facts, only the mother's version is given here. I'd rather wait to hear the hospital's story as well. Too many on here have slammed the NHS just for the sake of having a moan.
10:01 PM on 05/01/2012
I think a child dying because they didn't listen is more then just having a moan and my dad has had no problems till now with the NHS there are a lot of people who have had problems with the NHS
11:08 PM on 05/01/2012
You DO NOT know that this child died due to neglect, your comment, like many on here is based on nothing but personal bias and thoughtlessness, there are two sides to every story, fast jerking movements are bad for the knees!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
denspark1560
12:17 AM on 05/02/2012
It seems you mind is already made up as to who is right and wrong in this case. No one more than I cares for the life of one baby, but to come down on the entire NHS service as most have on Huff Post tonight leaves me gobsmacked. There is good and bad in all occupations, we hear of corrupt policemen, doctors, lawyers, firemen, and of course most are politicians. There is bad people in every occupation. I still hold that the NHS is something we should hold dear and be proud of. Most nurses are magnificent at their job and care deeply for their patients. It's unfair to use the example of what could be one small batch to condemn the whole apple barrel.
10:23 PM on 05/01/2012
Actually it isn't;it is a grossly bloated,wasteful bureaucratic nightmare that is rapidly getting out of control.The quality of the staff has nose-dived over the last 50 years.It should do less but better.People must realise that the only way this beast can be tamed is if a lot of what it does ,or tries to do,is done by private hospitals under insurance policies.The NHS can then concentrate on caring for people who have serious illness,as It was meant to do.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:46 PM on 05/01/2012
A few people in here have vouchers for comments?