Scottish Independence: Referendum Needs 'Second Question', Says George Galloway

PA/The Huffington Post UK  |  Posted: 14/05/2012 14:48 Updated: 14/05/2012 15:47

Veteran MP George Galloway has said the Scottish independence referendum should include a second question calling for more devolved powers instead of secession.

The Dundee-born politician, a former Labour MP who returned to Westminster under his Respect platform in the Bradford West by-election in March, said he opposes independence but backs a second question on "full economic powers short of secession".

First Minister Alex Salmond has not ruled out including a second referendum question on greater economic powers for the Scottish Parliament for those who vote No to independence, commonly described as devo-plus or devo-max.
Writing in Scottish politics publication Holyrood Magazine, Mr Galloway said: "I'm a pretty well-known opponent of independence and I'll certainly be campaigning hard against it.

"Alex Salmond, until recently a consummate operator, has sullied himself and surely damaged his party in the polls with the leaked emails about kissing and not telling with (media tycoon Rupert) Murdoch. When you trawl the gutter, you harvest the filth.

"But where we do agree, and I thought I'd never say this, is on the economy."

The left winger said the Tory-Lib Dem coalition at Westminster has been a "soaring failure" on the economy and said his former Labour stablemates' "clothes have been stolen" by the SNP in Scotland with its "popular social democratic" policies.

Galloway said: The Scottish Government needs power over the economy, pulling the levers for the worthy rather than the wealthy, which is why I favour a second question option on the ballot paper, however it's phrased and whatever it's called.

"Devo-max? Independence-lite? However it's described, it should be full economic powers short of secession."

FOLLOW UK POLITICS

Veteran MP George Galloway has said the Scottish independence referendum should include a second question calling for more devolved powers instead of secession. The Dundee-born politician, a former...
Veteran MP George Galloway has said the Scottish independence referendum should include a second question calling for more devolved powers instead of secession. The Dundee-born politician, a former...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:40 on 15/05/2012
I was going to post FB chum Alan Smart's note on this,but I'm delighted to see that he's just this moment resurrected his blog, especially for gorgeous. I suggest anyone interested in the Independence debate read it carefully.

http://ayewecan.blogspot.co.uk/2012/05/george-galloways-sectarian-disgrace.html
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
13:10 on 15/05/2012
Nice one Mark. Thanks for that.
00:22 on 27/05/2012
Thanks for the link. Mr Galloway is full of passion but for all the wrong reasons. Everyone should have self determintion EXCEPT Scotland. Once Scotland becomes Independent mr Galloway will lose his security blanket. ie:Scotland. The English people will see him as nothing more that a carpetbagger and turf him out. Where will he go then? I find him narrowminded and a bully.
08:11 on 15/05/2012
What's in a name? "Devo Max" ("full powers short of independence") is, depending how you look at it:
(a) a last-ditch attempt to stop the SNP
(b) a fallback safety clause for the SNP
(c) the best solution, preferable to either independence or the status quo.
There are many people in Scotland who take the last view, but the proposal seems to be seen outside Scotland as one of the first two.

It is this third group who need to up their game and explain their position. Just which powers would be retained by Westminster and what would be the implications of that? Until then the single question seems the best way to have a clear debate.
photo
ScottishScript
"I am not a number, I am a person!"
20:14 on 14/05/2012
"Alex Salmond, until recently a consummate operator, has sullied himself and surely damaged his party in the polls with the leaked emails about kissing and not telling with (media tycoon Rupert) Murdoch. When you trawl the gutter, you harvest the filth."

This from the man who publicly proclaimed his respect for Saddam Hussein?

George knows fine well any contact Salmond had with Murdoch is miniscule compared to Westminster politicians. It only highlights the problems we have in our democracy with media barons throwing their weight around and with luck Levinson will find a way to tackle it.

Galloway's views on Scottish Independence clearly reveal his true colours as a professional politician who yearns for Westminster limelight. That and the fact he seems keener on representing a certain religious demographic in London, rather than fellow Scots means I don't take his views on Scotland seriously.

He’s a smart guy and a good debater, unless Christopher HItchens was in the room. Hitchens would regularly mop the floor with him. See them on the Tube, good stuff.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wesinohio
Energetic Progess
16:39 on 14/05/2012
I love Scotland. That country deserves to be called a country and deserves its own identity, and some kind of independence, but they also probably benefit from being in the UK. Had a few pints at Gellion's Pub near the River Ness in Inverness near the Highlands last August and went to the Fringe Festival in Edinburg - the city had 3 times its usual population during that festival. Had the best pizza ever at a little Italian restaurant on the Royal Mile, bought a nice wool scarf at The Woolen Mill. Sat next to a nice Scottish gal on train, a web designer, and I loved the accents. I said to one woman on a train, "listening to you is just like being on vacation!" And here's the announcement at every train stop: "Mind the gap when alighting the train".
09:08 on 15/05/2012
'Some kind of Independence' ?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wesinohio
Energetic Progess
14:13 on 15/05/2012
Just independence would be fine.
00:15 on 27/05/2012
What does "Some kind of Independence mean" ? Only Independence will do
16:15 on 14/05/2012
The second question should actualy be, who wants Galloway living with them, us or our Scottish friends....methinks were stuck with him, as he is now reaping the expenses/benefits gravey train once more in Westminster.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
16:46 on 14/05/2012
I don't mind George really. I can't take him too seriously most of the time, but once in a while he comes out with something that is worth listening to. The problem is, if you want to find the bit worth listening to you have to wade through all the other guff he comes out with. On this occassion, this particular spouting off is one of the guffy ones. One question would be just fine in my book.
16:54 on 14/05/2012
Correct, he does have a habit of upsetting the applecart, and on occasion it certainly needs it! But if you wade through the poo he spouts, he does come up with relevent stuff, but people generaly can be put off as it will be "oh another load of waffle from George" without actualy bothering to hear what he has to say.  Me personaly, dont like him but have a VERY grudging respect!  Good day to you west Loth.
photo
hearthammer
If left is right and right is wrong, decide!
15:24 on 27/05/2012
I feel exactly the same about Geroge. I especially liked his stance with the half wits in the US senate!
photo
tc-byrne
Victoria Concordia Crescit
16:14 on 14/05/2012
I think most people were wondering when this tommo was going to put his 2p worth in , not really worth the effort it's been said by others,yawn!!
16:03 on 14/05/2012
I don't quite understand how someone who so publicly and shamelessly abased himself before Saddam Hussain (and other tyrants) can criticise someone who maintained minimal contact with Rupert Murdoch, a major businessman with interests in Scotland. Surely the height of hypocrisy from Galloway? ? ?