Thousands Of Children Wrongly Identified As Having Special Educational Needs

PA  |  Posted: Updated: 15/05/2012 06:51   PA

Sen

The numbers of youngsters considered to have Special Educational Needs is likely to be cut after tighter rules will be introduced on which children are identified as having SEN, it was confirmed on Tuesday.

The move comes after Ofsted warned that many children were being wrongly identified as having SEN because of poor teaching.

In a report published in autumn 2010, Ofsted found that as many as half of all pupils identified for School Action, the lowest SEN statement category, would not be identified as having these needs if schools focused on improving teaching and learning for all with individual goals for improvement.

Official figures suggest that around one in five schoolchildren - roughly 1.7 million - are classed as having special needs.
Children's minister Sarah Teather said: "The current system is outdated and not fit for purpose.

"Thousands of families have had to battle for months, even years, with different agencies to get the specialist care their children need. It is unacceptable they are forced to go from pillar to post, facing agonising delays and bureaucracy to get support, therapy and equipment.

"These reforms will put parents in charge. We trust parents to do the right thing for their own child because they know what is best. The right to a personal budget will give them real choice and control of care, instead of councils and health services dictating how they get support."

The reforms will be included in a Children and Families Bill announced in last week's Queen's Speech.

Also, parents are to be given new rights to buy help for children with special needs under the biggest shake-up of the system for 30 years.

Under the plans, families will be given legal powers to control budgets for youngsters who need support.

Ministers are pressing ahead with the proposals in a bid to make it easier for parents to get their child help, without being passed between agencies.

The reforms will also see education, health and social services forced by law to work together to provide support for children with special educational needs (SEN).

The proposals were first laid out in a Green Paper in March last year, amid concerns that the current system for SEN children is too complex, and often leaves parents fighting for help.

In some cases, disabled children have had to undergo operations to correct growth problems caused by a system that has left them waiting months for a new wheelchair.

At the launch of the Green Paper, Christine Lenehan, director of the Council for Disabled Children, also suggested that some youngsters have been left in pain because their wheelchair is too small for them.

And in many cases, children have been forced to undergo dozens of assessments to establish their needs.

In their formal response to the Green Paper today, ministers confirmed that SEN statements (which set out a child's needs and requirements) and learning difficulty statements (which are usually for older children) will be axed and replaced with a birth to 25 assessment and care plan.

Parents with children who hold these care plans will be given the legal right to a personal budget to pay for help and support.

Among other reforms, SEN children will also have the right to seek a place at academies and free schools.

And there will be a new single category of SEN, replacing the current systems which have been deemed too complicated.

As part of the move, there will be tighter rules on which children can be identified as having SEN.

The move is likely to cut the numbers of youngsters considered to have SEN, and comes after Ofsted warned that many children were being wrongly identified as having SEN because of poor teaching.

In a report published in autumn 2010, Ofsted found that as many as half of all pupils identified for School Action, the lowest SEN statement category, would not be identified as having these needs if schools focused on improving teaching and learning for all with individual goals for improvement.

Official figures suggest that around one in five schoolchildren - roughly 1.7 million - are classed as having special needs.
Children's minister Sarah Teather said: "The current system is outdated and not fit for purpose.

"Thousands of families have had to battle for months, even years, with different agencies to get the specialist care their children need. It is unacceptable they are forced to go from pillar to post, facing agonising delays and bureaucracy to get support, therapy and equipment.

"These reforms will put parents in charge. We trust parents to do the right thing for their own child because they know what is best. The right to a personal budget will give them real choice and control of care, instead of councils and health services dictating how they get support."

The reforms will be included in a Children and Families Bill announced in last week's Queen's Speech.

FOLLOW UK EDUCATION

The numbers of youngsters considered to have Special Educational Needs is likely to be cut after tighter rules will be introduced on which children are identified as having SEN, it was confirmed on Tu...
The numbers of youngsters considered to have Special Educational Needs is likely to be cut after tighter rules will be introduced on which children are identified as having SEN, it was confirmed on Tu...
Filed by Lucy Sherriff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 80
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ben Wilson
What's the story mourning Tories?
11:38 AM on 05/17/2012
Throat divers should bear this in mind when people are critical of autism. Spotting the many things that require SEN is not an exact science. People will under and over diagnose. I have no doubt that I'd could have been diagnosed as having ADD and dyslexia, but in the era I grew up I was simply put on a table on my own and not allowed to talk!!! And it worked!
This comment has been removed.
05:01 PM on 05/15/2012
We have never had it so bad since the thatcher days
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norman Mitchison
03:37 PM on 05/15/2012
A little less political correctness ,and interference, from so called `experts` would be a massive boost and frugal.
02:50 PM on 05/15/2012
Just another government lame excuse to save money. A bird named compassion flew out of the Downing Street cabinet window when the the Tories parked their bums around the table of power.
02:26 PM on 05/15/2012
teachers have put up SEN nfor years to cover up thier own in adequacies Teachers constantly moan about lack of discipline in the classroom but will never take responsibility for it. My son was given all sort of diagnosis and I was pushed to go through the assesments as well ( I was sure that ther nothing wrong with my son all he needed good intensive study at primery school).All the assesments in school didnot proove any diagnosis. Now he is imporoving with right school and guidance but the lack of active teaching in primery school has left him bit behind from his peers and in confidence. But(INSH) will get there with grace of GOD.
03:27 PM on 05/15/2012
We can see you're trying your best, were you at the same school.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Brown1949
Not waving but drowning.
03:36 PM on 05/15/2012
And we worry about the children?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:20 AM on 05/16/2012
"Teachers constantly moan about lack of discipline in the classroom but will never take responsibility for it." - and parents constantly deny that thier child could be disruptive or, worse, don't care as they believe the Teachers should raise thier children to behave properly.

Teachers and Parents need to work together and support each other for the sake of the children.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
12:22 PM on 05/16/2012
Teachers can't do anything about lack of discipline in the classroom, you cannot punish kids nowadays. We were terrified of our teachers in the 70's kids today are not scared of anyone.
01:22 PM on 05/15/2012
There is very little about the role of parents in the comments today.
When children come into school with very limited vocabulary, poor to non existent social skills, no knowledge of stories, nursery rhymes, taking turns, being kind (!) etc school are doing well to identify such children as having special needs.
They HAVE got special needs and by formalising the process the school can make specific educational plans for that child.
Surely that is what we would want!
Money is NOT attached to all levels of identified special needs but a programme of development is. Let the schools get on with their job and lets encourage PARENTS to involve themselves more with their childs pre school attainments.

Has nobody read the "recent" information about some childrens vocabulary compared to others........ this has been known about for YEARS in schools and has been ignored.

Read a story a night to your child, turn off the TV / games for one hour a day, teach them nursery rhymes..... not rocket science but unbelievably valuable preparation for life.

Help your child to help themselves. Education is a partnership between school, society and home. Lets ALL do our bit.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:23 AM on 05/16/2012
Well said! I couldn't agree more.
01:21 PM on 05/15/2012
Parents are already burdened with a child who needs special needs they don't have the time to check what facilities are available, have they the money for it etc etc. The only reason they are being sent from pillar to post with it is simply because of the cuts. The question is, will there be any facilities anyway?????
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
minimemo
Can I be your friend...if they let me out...
08:06 PM on 05/17/2012
Often those who are misdiagnosed as having special needs are indeed deemed to be a burden to their parents! Starting school with no reading or social skills - the buck has to stop somewhere and we all as parents need to take responsibility for our own children.
10:27 PM on 05/17/2012
Some are just not ready to learn so early. As they preach all children are 'unique and learn at their own pace' Yet they do not practice what they preach.
01:04 PM on 05/15/2012
Oh sorry for my bad spelling....maybe i am special needs...hey who knows!
01:02 PM on 05/15/2012
This is just another scam to cut money from another social group trying to disguise it as something else. On the other end of the sacel my daughter is doing her yr9 exams and some kids get taken out of the exam hall invironment for "assistance" as my daughter puts it to help reading the exam questions!! Whereas my take on it is if you cannot read the questions then you have no business taking the exam! so on one hand you got the Gov't trying to cut things and on the other end of things schools failing to make sure kids can read and write properly. but dressing THAT up as "special needs" which it is NOT thats basic needs! So I am afraid we are all doomed as in the middle of all this is the parents who are brain dead and not reading to their children at home, or helping them in any way, so all in all...its a disaster
01:42 PM on 05/15/2012
So what are you saying exactly? That if a child is severely dyslexic he/she should not be provided with the necessary adjustments that make exams accessible? Were you aware that if you are unable to access exams you are unable to access further education and labour markets?
02:57 PM on 05/15/2012
No I am not exactly saying that. BUT on your reply ask yourself this.who is going to be giving these youngsters a one on one help when they ARE in further education or IN employment???...answer no one, and who WILL give them employment?...no one. Those problems should be sorted out in school very early on. as you go through school ONCE and you cannot play "catchup" all the time....such as further education college and Uni...its just impossible...THATS the problem.
12:52 PM on 05/15/2012
My son is Dyslexic and has been labelled 'special' for his entire time at Junior school. My battle to get my son tested for dyslexia took years because of the funding - he finally took it when he was 10 and it showed he had the IQ of a 14 yr old.
While he waited for the test he was labelled as 'special' and didn’t receive a great education. I believe this was down to poor teaching and the lack of funding. He is now 12 and has moved on to senior school and has come on leaps and bounds. He achieves A's for every subject for effort and B's for attainment. The Junior school they told me he didn’t put any effort in to his work and would never read or write to an acceptable level. Because of the teaching he now receives, his reading and writing is at the level that it should be for a 12 yr old.
I believe if teachers had more training in subjects like Dyslexia and had more availability to funding for such situations, children like my son would have a far better education.
01:25 PM on 05/15/2012
Yes can totally agree there. Dysiexia will only be diagnosed if they think the child in the first instance came from the right background/area in junior schools. Otherwise they are just thick. .
01:43 PM on 05/15/2012
Agreed!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michaelxx
12:27 PM on 05/15/2012
give the kids a clip round the ear when they misbehave. that will soon sort them out. too much P/C not enough common sense
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thomas Platt
01:48 PM on 05/15/2012
...and this has what to do with children with special needs?
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
12:22 PM on 05/15/2012
Too many schools have over-identified SEN for years now, because it enables them to massage their attainment figures and boosts funding (but only at the Action Plus/Statement level). It's an absolute nonsense that any mainstream school should have 25%+ special needs children.

The worst offenders are not inner city schools, which are dealing with a large number of real problems, but schools in the suburbs - where poor teachers, unable to differentiate their lessons for the lower attainers, pin the blame on the child by labelling them 'special'.

So yes, I agree with the idea of this reform, by and large. But the devil is in the detail, and I have a nasty feeling that we will move to a far worse system - a random, chaotic system where children with significant (but not severe) needs get ignored by schools because have lost the funding to pay for service level agreements and specialist teachers to help them - which is currently the case.

This is really more about cost cutting - although the sentiment is OK, the implementation won't be. Not one school has been involved in the trialling arrangements so far, and that is never a good sign.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:17 PM on 05/15/2012
teachers have put up SEN numbers for years to cover up thier own in adequacies and invented ADHD AKA naughty boy syndrome as a way of controlling kids who would have got a clip round the ear before. Teachers constantly moan about lack of discipline in the classroom but will never take responsibility for it. Next time instead of striking for cheaper pensions more hols etc try striking for the right to manage your school. Simply put expel naughty kids no appeals no b***hit out! watch the others fall into line.
02:13 PM on 05/15/2012
And what do you think happens to ADHD AKA Naughty boys who are repeatedly excluded? Well, the research clearly shows that a significant percentage become increasingly alienated from mainstream society and end up in the criminal justice system, mental health care system and with drug and alcohol abuse issues. Now logic tells me that it is cheaper to invest a little when these individuals are youngsters, thereby ensuring that they are able to succeed and remain included in mainstream society, than it is support them in various institutions as non-taxpaying, welfare dependent adults.
03:49 PM on 05/15/2012
Totally agree. But there is another side to that. Kids that are labelled ADHD (BTW not just boys) cannot stick up for themselves at school and usually become targets of bullies. Once a child has a label they are "clamped" down on more by the establishment and get blamed for every little thing they do that is deemed different.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:20 PM on 05/16/2012
Well if your scenario worked but it doesnt. We invest zip lock the kids up at 18 cost £1m your way we spend £300,000 on crap education therapy etc etc then lock the kid up cost £1,3m mmmmmm
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:25 AM on 05/16/2012
I've seen more Parents insist that thier child has ADHD where the Teacher is certain that they just need some discipline in general. Teachers and Parents need to work together and support each other for the sake of the children.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
12:29 PM on 05/16/2012
ADHD is not diagnosed by either parents or teachers, often parents know there is something wrong with their child and teachers do not acknowledge this. I was concerned my son was dyslexic and the headmaster just said my writing and spelling is awful too. My son only got the diagnosis (by an expert) when he was at college and it was only then he got the help he had needed all along.
12:14 PM on 05/15/2012
Now that the government want to reduce the deficit they attack the vulnerable. I have had to fight 3 education tribunals to get people to listen to me and the medical professionals in regard to my child's education, and why because the County Council refused to listen - why because it would cost them money to support my child. They tried their hardest to beat me down but as a lone parent I fought them and won each time. I didn't have a private solicitor but I did have the help from IPSEA would gave me the ammunition I needed to win my cases. Central government haven't got a clue what goes on in local and county councils. There was once the money to support our children who needed help with their education but now that the schools are overcrowded with children from the EU and further a field that money is being spent on interpreters to help these students. Why is everyone afraid to speak the truth?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OD4U
If its OK for one then its OK for all.
01:33 PM on 05/15/2012
Well done you for saying how it really is.
02:29 PM on 05/15/2012
Like you I am a lone parent who has successfully managed multiple tribunals on behalf of my child. I have also worked as a volunteer preparing cases for other parents. Central government most certainly does have a clue what goes on at county level, hence the proposed changes. There has never been enough money in the pot to adequately support SEN and County Councils are forced to manage limited budgets by not fulfilling their statutory duties in relation to SEN. They rely on parents not having the socio-economic resources to either identify or address the inadequacies in their child's provision. This issue has absolutely nothing to do with immigration and to go down this line of reasoning, as a significant proportion of the British public seem keen to do on a number of issues that currently exist, is neither constructive or insightful.