Andrew Lansley Risk Register Veto 'Permissible', Says Attorney General Dominic Grieve

The Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: Updated: 16/05/2012 13:12

Health Secretary Andrew Lansley's decision to veto the publication of a report into the risks of NHS reforms is "permissible" and "not extraordinary" according to the Government's chief legal adviser.

In a direct clash with the Information Commissioner, who criticised Lansley's decision, Attorney General Dominic Grieve said the Health Secretary's veto was allowed.

'I don't think it can be said that what has been done is so unusual and so outside what the government has indicated it would do that it is in some way an extraordinary decision. It's quite clear the Act allows it to happen. If you look at what the rules and guidelines say, the government's decision is that [the decision] was completely compatible," he said.

"You can’t take controversy out of this type of area, it’s bound to have some controversial elements" he warned.

Grieve was speaking to the Commons justice committee on the implications of the Freedom of Information Act.

He warned MPs that there was a "possibility of a chilling effect" in publishing minutes from Cabinet meetings. Grieve said there was a "real risk" of decisions going un-recorded because people would be "so worried" about their remarks being made public.

The November 2010 Transition Risk Register set out internal Government assessments of the risks posed by the reforms in the Health and Social Care Act, which became law in March after a tortuous passage through Parliament.

Ministerial vetos have previously been used to prevent records of Cabinet discussions being made public.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Prime Minister David Cameron

  • Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg

  • Chancellor George Osborne

  • Foreign Secretary William Hague

  • Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt

    After a stressful year in the DCMS, Jeremy Hunt moves from Culture to Health, replacing Andrew Lansley.

  • Home Secretary Theresa May

  • Cabinet Office Minister Francis Maude

  • Chief Secretary To The Treasury Danny Alexander

  • Minister without Portfolio, Ken Clarke

    Having stepped down from the Justice Department, Clarke is supposedly staying in Government rather than hanging up his boots. Chris Grayling will replace him as Justice Secretary.

  • Justice Secretary Chris Grayling

    Chris Grayling, formerly in the Department of Work and Pensions, will step up to hold the job vacated by Ken Clarke.

  • Culture Secretary Maria Miller

    Maria Miller has taken up the DCMS job after Jeremy Hunt moved to the Department of Health. Miller is one of the few new faces in the cabinet.

  • Defence Secretary Philip Hammond

  • Communities Secretary Eric Pickles

  • Education Secretary Michael Gove

  • Minister for Internation Development, Justine Greening

    Greening, who has been subject to plenty of rumours since her fallout over a potential third Heathrow runway. Greening was in No 10 for over an hour on Tuesday, presumably arguing her case and battling to stay in the cabinet. She will now take over Andrew Mitchell's spot at DfID.

  • Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin

    McLoughlin, who has spent the past two years handling backbench rebels as Chief Whip, moves to the DfT, taking over from under-pressure Justine Greening. Greening has yet to be moved.

  • Energy Secretary Ed Davey

  • Attorney General Dominic Grieve

  • Cabinet Office Minister Oliver Letwin

  • Baroness Warsi

    Warsi, one of the earlest victims of the reshuffle, has been ousted as party co-chairman and is to be replaced by Grant Shapps. Warsi instead moves to to the Foreign Office as a junior minister, while also working as faith and communities minister.

  • Party Co-Chairman Grant Shapps

    Shapps, who was the housing minister, is bumped up to party chairman, taking over from the demoted Sayeeda Warsi.

  • Environment Secretary Owen Paterson

    Spelman leaves her post, to be replaced by the former Northern Ireland secretary Owen Paterson.

  • Work And Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith

  • Leader of the House Andrew Lansley

    Despite recently setting in motion huge overhauls to the NHS, Lansley has been moved to fill Sir George Young's spot as Leader of the House. Jeremy Hunt will succeed him in the Department of Health.

  • Business Secretary Vince Cable

  • Northern Ireland Secretary Theresa Villiers

    Theresa Villiers, who gave nothing away as she approached Parliament with a wide smile on her face on Tuesday, replaces Owen Paterson. Paterson has moved to Defra.

  • Welsh Secretary David Jones

    Cheryl Gillan was one name always likely to be taken off the list, and she is replaced by David Jones, who served beneath her as a Minister for Wales.

  • Scottish Secretary Michael Moore

  • Chief Whip Andrew Mitchell

    Andrew Mitchell has moved moved from the Department for International Development to the role of Chief Whip, replacing Patrick McLoughlin.

  • Lords Leader Lord Strathclyde

FOLLOW UK POLITICS