GCSE Exams To Be Replaced By English Baccalaureate Certificate (EBacc)

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 17/09/2012 15:54 Updated: 18/09/2012 13:35

GCSE exams are to be replaced by a qualification known as the English Baccalaureate Certificate, Nick Clegg and Michael Gove have said.

Writing in the Evening Standard the education secretary and deputy prime minister said the "radical reforms" would require "careful preparation".

"We propose introducing new English, maths and science certificates in September 2015 with other subjects following.

The announcement came an hour before Michael Gove is due to make an official statement to the House of Commons regarding the new exam system.

ebacc

The pair wrote a joint article announcing the EBacc

The article, published on the Standard's site at 3.30pm, would have coincided with Gove's official statement to MPs but this was pushed back by an hour due to an urgent question tabled by Labour on Afghanistan.

Clegg and Gove said the new qualifications would be dubbed the EBacc - a name which currently exists as an umbrella term for a combination of core GCSE subjects.

The duo added: "They are the foundation on which further study, vocational learning or a satisfying apprenticeship can be built. Success in English, maths, science, a humanities subject and a language will comprise the full English Baccalaureate.

"In the battle to make our society more open, mobile and free it has been good to know that by working together we can overcome those forces that have held our children back — the entrenched establishment voices who have become the enemies of promise."

Many students, posting on TheStudentRoom forum, welcomed making GCSEs harder.

"I would make GCSEs a little bit more challenging so that it could bridge the gap between GCSEs and A-level study," on student wrote.

Another said:

"I would change the current GCSE qualification, and in so doing, make it harder for people to just rote learn the syllabus and the mark schemes and get a good grade without actually understanding the subject."

Gove and Clegg added special provision would be made for students not sitting the mentioned exams and schools would be required to detail their achievement in each curriculum area to help them progress.

"These reforms are radical — so we will consult widely," they added. "Their introduction will require careful preparation. So we propose introducing new English, maths and science certificates in September 2015 with other subjects following."


Professor Robert Coe director of the centre for evaluation and monitoring at Durham University, said coursework is not the problem.

“Coursework and modular exams have been getting a bad name recently but there are good educational reasons for including both in assessments. The problems come when you combine them with a high-pressure accountability system that includes league tables, closing down schools that don’t meet ‘floor targets’, and the general perception that exam results measure educational quality. The truth is that no kind of assessment can really withstand this kind of pressure.

“It is not obvious how the new qualification will be different from GCSEs. Of course you can give it a new name and say it will be rigorous and be like the O-levels were, but what does this mean?

“People like the idea of the O-level exam because it represents an elite, high standard.

“There are certainly problems with the current GCSE, and it is right to make it more challenging for the highest attainers. Exam questions have relied too much on recall of facts, requiring regurgitation of formulaic and predictable responses rather than understanding or hard thinking. If the new exams better reward the kinds of learning we actually value then the change will be very welcome.”

Christine Blower, general secretary of the National Union of Teachers, called the proposals a "blatant two-tier system".

"The premise for the Government’s changes appears to be based on the rather spurious reason that too many pupils are succeeding.

“What is being proposed here is blatantly a two-tier system. Pupils who do not gain EBacc Certificates will receive a record of achievement which will most certainly be seen to be of far less worth by employers and colleges.

“Placing a cap on those who can gain top grades means that many students will miss out on the recognition and opportunities they deserve and harks back to a time when only a few were expected to go on to higher education.

"Setting up examination systems to ensure only a few succeed is counterproductive."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

 
 
  • Comments
  • 147
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
01:06 AM on 09/23/2012
Pair of can'ts.
09:59 PM on 09/22/2012
the sooner these plebs are out of power the better condems is quite an appropriate name
10:08 AM on 09/21/2012
Can someone remind me why a journalist is making our education decisions again?

I mean, he has absolutely no background in education, no qualifications that can be readily transferred to education, and nothing in his life to suggest he knows the first thing about education.

I mean, surely Cameron wouldn't have elected someone with absolutely no right to do the job simply on the basis of them being old Eton buddies? That would be an absurd and insane way to run a country.
09:45 PM on 09/21/2012
You'll have to ask whoever voted this shower in! There was a time when thread like this would be crammed full of the "sillycons" backslapping themselves over a job well done. Now there doesnt seem to be quite as many of those voices!
08:52 AM on 09/20/2012
Something had to change as GCSE's were not respected as a qualification. Coursework based qualifications were always open to abuse by teachers keen to keep their standards up. And whatever happened to just accepting that not everyone is academically minded? It is okay to labour or learn a trade. And for those with a more academic bent, universities and employers should be able to seek out those of higher abilities as it is what keeps a country competitive on a global playing field.
09:41 PM on 09/21/2012
Who's going to be the first to "give up" on their kids and sentence them to a life of hard manual labour. I would rather my kids got a degree in Golf course design than have to "knock up" cement for 8 hours a day!
10:24 PM on 09/22/2012
So when all our kids have got their degrees in golf course design, and are up to their 'ying-yangs' in student debt, how many of them will be able to earn an income as a golf course designer? Maybe they can all job-share? You could count the number of golf courses being opened or re-modeled in the UK on the fingers of a badly mutilated hand.

Better to grasp the nettle and prepare for reality than to invest in a pipe dream for ultimate disappointment. Most of us are ordinary people who will get on fine in ordinary jobs. There's nothing wrong with that.
01:35 PM on 09/19/2012
Another example of our so called representatives meddling in things that they have very little understanding of and will ultimately muck up to the detriment of young people and the country. They will then re invent the wheel say it is the best thing since sliced bread and wait until more of their ilk come along and muck it up all over again.

Are politicians just wonderful people.
12:13 PM on 09/19/2012
I am amazed that this Government have only just brought in which they are calling Englishbaccalaureate. Baccalaureate has been used abroad for several years and is a much fairer system than the GCSE, whether it be A.B.C.D.E. level.
I think the system needed to be changed in this Country, even Employers were disregarding GCSE results which students achieved. So now we are now in line with other Countries who do recognise the Baccalaureate Exams. I think this is a good move forward for students.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:45 PM on 09/22/2012
Well the UK school system needs to be matched with the French one. UK pupips just have it too easy .
11:20 AM on 09/19/2012
TWO LITTLE MUPPETS THAT HAVE COME OUT OF THE WOODWORK AND HAVE CHANGED ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT SYSTEMS IN OUR SOCIETY WITHOUT ANY DISCUSSION THATS DEMOCRACY FOR YOU.
05:21 PM on 09/21/2012
Well said.
10:47 AM on 09/19/2012
How many times are they going to mess around with the exam system.
Unless we have a settled system, how can any potential employer understand if the exam that some one has achieve mean anything of use to their company.
Every few years kids have to explain what their qualifications means, in regards to another qualification.
What is wrong with the system we have?
What was wrong with A, O, CSE ?
Stick to one system which everybody can understand and value, after all a student can only seat the exam which is placed in front of them, course work as well.
03:21 PM on 09/20/2012
GCSE has problems. Coursework assessment was conceived before "internet". There is now a serious authenticity problem. Second problem is that in many schools half the students "fail" to achieve the 5 C standard. Another problem is the A grade inflation. And what is going on with these Neets? Defo time for a shake-up.
03:34 PM on 09/20/2012
OK Tony, you make fair comments on the subject at hand.
I am not an expert, far from it, but for years depending on whom i am talking too from which generation they are from, we seem to have to talk about our qualifications as equal too another, rather than one standard that everyone can recognize.
09:49 PM on 09/21/2012
Yes but poor old Nick Clegg is desperate to associate himself with something that can be given a positive spin so he has "rowed" himself in on this!
photo
casual agent
Advocate for social justice
12:13 AM on 09/19/2012
I didn't know Mr Bean (Michael Gove) had a Side-Kick...We should Re-Name them"The Dangerous Brothers"..lol
01:49 PM on 09/21/2012
No no ....its Black Adder and Baldrick surely ......they're always full of 'shrewd and cunning plans' that never work out ......
04:45 PM on 09/21/2012
Together, they may have an IQ equal to that of Baldrick.
This comment has been removed.
10:42 PM on 09/18/2012
When are they going to stop mucking around with our children's futures? The next thing you know is they will go back to the old 11 plus and grammar schools.
10:36 PM on 09/22/2012
The sooner the better. Local state grammar schools provided opportunity for intelligent kids from ordinary families to become doctors, solicitors, politicians, or whatever they were interested in. Now, unless you're from a posh neighbourhood, or better still, privately educated these children's aspirations have been stifled in the rush to award everyone a prize. Now we don't even have teachers that can spell.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
britalia56
09:46 PM on 09/18/2012
dont clegg and gove make lovely couple?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jaydjay
10:53 AM on 09/19/2012
in a word NO
01:50 PM on 09/21/2012
Yes ...but a couple of what ?
08:03 PM on 09/18/2012
This is a cloak to steer away from the English exams, which are no longer required in the UK. Students will be now able to study a paper in their own language
05:59 PM on 09/18/2012
These people do not know what they are doing, I am so sorry for the children.
I do not put my trust in any human Goverment especially those who reject the righteousness of God
04:05 PM on 09/18/2012
This new exam has a very academic sounding name, which makes me feel the average teenager will be turned right off. Even Gove just saying the words makes it sound like the most boring, stuffy and elitist humbug! Can we please give young people a good education by teaching to a high and acceptable standard, ensuring fairness across the board in exam marking, and, for goodness sake firing up interest and enthusiasm by talented staff passing on their skills. Instead, eyes will be glazing over all over Britain I should think.