Huffpost UK uk

Young Offender Uses 'Breach Of Human Rights' To Get Curfew Changed So He Can Smoke

Posted: Updated:
Print Article

A curfew that prevented a young offender from going outside to smoke at night has been changed because a judge ruled it breached the boy's human rights.

The 16-year-old, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was forbidden from smoking inside the youth care home where he lived and was not allowed to step foot outside the property after 7pm to smoke in the garden.

The property's garage where he was allowed to smoke was also prohibited by the curfew so he decided to attempt to change the terms of his curfew in a case that cost the tax payer £1,000.

cigarette

The curfew prevented the youth from smoking at night

Returning to Stockport Magistrates Court, where he was originally sentenced to a youth rehabilitation order for assault and criminal damage, the judge agreed with his lawyer that it was a 'human rights issue' and the curfew was amended.

Quick Poll

Should young offenders be allowed go outside to smoke on curfew?

VOTE

Liberal Democrat councillor Kevin Hogg said: "He committed a crime and should be punished. The whole system is going stupid. All this so a child can smoke.

"The court should have just told them not to waste its time."

Others however, have highlighted the failings in the original judgement.

Anna Mazzola, a human rights lawyer at Bindnams LLB told the Huffington Post: "There has a been a lot of anti-human rights rhetoric about this.

"In fact, the real issue is how it was that a 16 year old was under conditions which would have required him to breach his licence in order to pop into the back garden for a few minutes.

"It is in no one's interests to set unreasonable licence conditions, particularly for children."

Around the Web

Youth Justice — Ministry of Justice, New Zealand

What makes juvenile offenders different from adult offenders?

Young offender's curfew changed so he can smoke

California to End 'Life Sentence Without Parole' for Youth

Juvenile Sex Offenders: Locked Up for Life?

“Dear Juvenile Injustice” – Richard Ross on the State of America's Youth ...

Life in a young offenders' institution | Society | The Guardian

BBC NEWS | UK | 'Too many' young offenders jailed

BBC News | UK | Youth justice: How it works

Troubled teens lend a hand in Sudbury

Teenage computer hacker in police raid

Oxbridge application deadline: a timely reminder of students' potential

Prison Is Too Violent for Young Offenders - Room for Debate ...

Youth Offenders: Legal Guidance: The Crown Prosecution Service

Young offenders leaving custody for life of homelessness and ...

Michael Crowley; writer and youth justice worker

'Drastic improvement' needed to protect public from young offenders