European judges have upheld Britain's blanket ban on political advertising, after the coalition government insisted it was necessary to prevent "those with the deepest pockets" dominating political debate.
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) delivered its judgment on Monday after long-running case brought by an animal welfare group.
In 2005, Animal Defenders International was blocked from screening a TV advertisement which juxtaposed images of a girl and then a chimpanzee in chains in an animal cage.
Culture Secretary Maria Miller said: "Political adverts are – and have always been – banned on British TV and radio. That ban has wide support and has helped sustain the balance of views which is at the heart of British broadcasting – and ensures the political views broadcast into our homes are not determined by those with the deepest pockets.
"This case was not about the particular views of this organisation, but about the fact the Broadcast Advertising Clearance Centre considered that broadcasting this advert would breach the ban on political advertising in the UK."
The 2003 Communications Act bans all TV ads "of a political nature or directed towards changing the law; influencing elections, government policy or public opinion on controversial matters; promoting a political party or in connection with an industrial dispute".
However, Tory MP George Eustice, who served as David Cameron's communications director between 2005 and 2008, told HuffPost UK that the ban should be lifted.
"My view is, as a point of principle, I think this should be decided by the UK parliament. I don't think this was right use of the ECHR," he said.
"But on the substance of the issue I think our laws are very antiquated and out of date, we are in a situation where it's okay to advertise to children at 6.30am when their parents are in bed, but advertising political ideas to grown-ups is considered out of bounds," he said.
Eustice said the UK has the "most draconian" political advertising rules in the free world and noted that most other European countries allow some form of political advertising on television.
Opponents of such ads feared that overturning the ban would lead to an explosion of US-style attack-ads that dominate presidential campaigns across the Atlantic.
The battle between Barack Obama and Mitt Romney saw almost $1bn spent on more than one million presidential campaign ads - most of them negative.
An analysis of the adverts carried out in November found that 87% of the adverts run by the two campaigns were negative - compared with just 13% that were positive.
However Eustice said the "free for all" of American campaigns would not be repeated in the UK and invoking them as a case against changing UK law was not a "legitimate argument at all".
"We have a different political culture in Britain, we wouldn't end up with advertising with an American accent, we'd have advertising that fitted our culture," he said.
"There are some very clear rules, you can't use footage of your opponents without their permission," he said. "The kind of 'flip-flop' ad done against John Kerry, that wouldn't have been allowed. And the 'read my lips' ad done against George Bush would not have been permitted."
Eustice added: "You could allow political advertising but keep limits on the amount you can spend on it."
In March peers on the Lords communications committee controversially recommended Sky News should be freed from its obligation to provide unbiased political coverage.
If the recommendations were accepted it would allow the rolling 24-hour news channel to emulate its American sister station Fox News, which is widely seen as having a pro-conservative bias.
However John Ryley, the head of Sky News, swiftly rejected the suggestion. He told HuffPost UK: "Sky News will remain committed to impartial news coverage with or without an obligation to do so. Our choice would be to remain impartial in the event that obligations were lifted."
Related on HuffPost:
Ann Coulter Calls Obama "Retard"
Ann Coulter <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/23/ann-coulter-obama-retard_n_2004828.html">called President Obama a "retard"</a> during the 2012 election. She made the remark on Twitter after the third and final presidential debate between Obama and Mitt Romney. "I highly approve of Romney's decision to be kind and gentle to the retard," she tweeted.
Karl Rove Argues With Fox News About 2012 Election Night Call
In one of the wildest moments of the 2012 election, Fox News contributor <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/06/fox-news-argues-obama-ohio_n_2085817.html">Karl Rove challenged the network's decision to call the race for President Obama</a> on the night of the vote. The network made its projection, but Rove said it was "premature" and "early" to make any real decisions. Anchor Megyn Kelly then walked backstage to speak to the number crunchers, who then explained that Rove was wrong.
Geraldo Rivera: "I Think The Hoodie Is As Much Responsible For Trayvon Martin’s Death As George Zimmerman Was."
Geraldo Rivera caused a huge uproar in March 2012 when he blamed Trayvon Martin's hoodie for his death. Martin, an unarmed teenager, was shot and killed by George Zimmerman. Rivera <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/05/21/geraldo-rivera-trayvon-martin-benjamin-crump-hoodie_n_1532576.html">doubled down on his attacks</a> on what he called Martin's "thug wear," though he eventually<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/27/geraldo-rivera-apology-trayvon-martin-hoodie_n_1382814.html"> issued a public apology</a> for his explosive comments. Even Rivera's son said that <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/23/geraldo-rivera-trayvon-martin-hoodie_n_1375080.html?ref=media">he was ashamed of his father's remarks</a>.
Bill O'Reilly: 'Whitney Houston Wanted To Kill Herself'
Bill O'Reilly came down hard on Whitney Houston the Monday after she died. "Whitney Houston wanted to kill herself," he said. "Nobody takes drugs for that long if they want to stay on the planet. She follows in the footsteps of Elvis, Janis Joplin, Michael Jackson, and scores of other entertainment figures. The hard truth is that some people will always want to destroy themselves, and there's nothing society can do about it."
Fox News' Liz Trotta On Women Raped In Military: 'What Did They Expect?'
Fox News contributor Liz Trotta was reacting to news that the military will allow women to work closer to the front lines when she made a series of incendiary statements about rape. She said that the rate of sex crimes committed by army personnel was up, and continued, <blockquote>Now, what did they expect? These people are in close contact, the whole airing of this issue has never been done by Congress, it's strictly been a question of pressure from the feminists.</blockquote> Trotta also alleged that "feminists" have demanded too much money to fund programs for sexual abuse victims. "You have this whole bureaucracy upon bureaucracy being built up with all kinds of levels of people to support women in the military who are now being raped too much," she said. She <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/20/fox-news-liz-trotta-rape-military_n_1288769.html">later doubled down</a> on her original remarks.
Keith Ablow: "Don't Let Your Kids Watch Chaz Bono On 'Dancing With the Stars'"
Keith Ablow, a Fox News contributor and the network's resident psychiatrist, has generated controversy with his dubious theories, which include his assertion that Chaz Bono's appearance on "Dancing With the Stars" would lead children to reconsider their gender. He also suggested that <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/21/keith-ablow-fox-news-newt-gingrich-marriages_n_1220761.html" target="_hplink">Newt Gingrich's infidelity would make him a better president</a>, and that <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/15/keith-ablow-joe-biden-debate_n_1967272.html" target="_hplink">Joe Biden showed signs of dementia</a> during the vice-presidential debate.
Steve Doocy on Hillary Clinton: "Face Lift, Perhaps?"
Steve Doocy speculated that Hillary Clinton recently had a face lift. "Is this the face of presidential ambition?" Doocy said. "Days after retiring as Secretary of State, somebody has launched a website for her, showing off this glamorous new face. Face lift, perhaps? Well, that’s fueling rumors about a run for president in 2016, but her aides say it’s simply a way for fans and the media to reach her."
Megyn Kelly: Pepper Spray Is "Food Product, Essentially"
Megyn Kelly and Bill O'Reilly were discussing the pepper spray incident that rocked UC Davis when Kelly wondered whether the spray used by police had been diluted. She said pepper spray is "a food product, essentially," adding that the spray was "obviously abrasive and intrusive."
Eric Bolling: Obama Hosted 'A Hoodlum In The Hizzouse'
Eric Bolling <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/13/eric-bolling-accused-of-r_n_876214.html">courted allegations of racism</a> when he criticized Obama's visit with the president of Gabon, saying, "It's not the first time he's had a hoodlum in the hizzouse." As he said "hizzouse," a picture of rapper Common appeared on the screen.
Brian Kilmeade: 'We Keep Marrying Other Species And Other Ethnics'
In reference to a study that claimed people who stay married are less likely to suffer from Alzheimer's, Kilmeade said that the results do not apply to the United States because: "... we keep marrying other species and other ethnics. See, the problem is the Swedes have pure genes. Because they marry other Swedes .... Finns marry other Finns, so they have a pure society. In America we marry everybody, we marry Italians and Irish."
Sean Hannity: Obama Wouldn't Have Killed Bin Laden 'If He Had His Way'
Sean Hannity was reluctant to credit President Obama with killing Osama bin Laden. He was discussing Obama's foreign policy with Republican pollster Frank Luntz: "They’ve got a foreign policy that shows a lot of weakness," Hannity said. "I know the President will say they got bin Laden, putting that aside." "And the public gives him credit for that," Luntz said. Hannity replied, "But it wouldn’t have happened if he had his way, and I think that could be proven as well on tapes."
Ann Coulter: 'Can We Get The Ad To Find Obama's Cocaine Dealer?'
Ann Coulter called for someone to put out an ad to <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/08/22/ann-coulter-obama-cocaine_n_933151.html">find President Obama's "cocaine dealer"</a> during an appearance on Sunday's "Fox and Friends." Coulter's comment came as she was opining that the media have given Republican presidential candidates a harder time than Obama ever got when he ran in the 2008 election. She noted that someone has already taken an ad out asking, "have you had sex with Rick Perry?" "Can we get the ad to find, you know, Obama's cocaine dealer now that he's two years into his presidency?" Coulter asked,
Fox News' Liz Trotta Jokes About Killing President Obama
Fox News contributor Liz Trotta joked about killing President Obama. She was discussing Hillary Clinton's reference to RFK's assassination when defending her decision to stay in the race until June 2008. Trotta accidentally said that someone was talking about "Osama" getting knocked off, instead of "Obama." "Well, both if we could," Trotta then joked, laughing.
Ann Coulter To Hannity: 'Our Blacks Are So Much Better Than Their Blacks'
In 2009, Ann Coulter said that conservatives blacks are <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/11/01/ann-coulter-herman-cain-our-blacks_n_1069172.html">"so much better"</a> than liberal blacks. "Our blacks are so much better than their blacks," Coulter told Fox News. "To become a black Republican, you don't just roll into it. You're not going with the flow. You have fought against probably your family members, probably your neighbors, you have thought everything out and that's why we have very impressive blacks in our party."
Brian Kilmeade: 'All Terrorists Are Muslims'
"Fox and Friends" co-host Brian Kilmeade defended Bill O'Reilly after his infamous visit to "The View." "Not all Muslims are terrorists," Kilmeade said, "But all terrorists are Muslims." Later, he addressed the remarks, saying, "What I should have said, and I’d like to clarify, is all terrorists who killed us on 9/11; with the Cole; and the Khobar; and the ‘98 embassies; that’s what I should have said."
Bill O'Reilly: "You Want Me To Give You My Hard-Earned Money So You Can Have Sex?"
Bill O'Reilly <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/03/bill-oreilly-sandra-fluke-limbaugh_n_1318249.html">did not hesitate to take Rush Limbaugh's side</a> in the furor over the radio host's comments about Sandra Fluke. "Let me get this straight, Ms. Fluke, and I'm asking this with all due respect," he said. "You want me to give you my hard-earned money so you can have sex?"
John Bolton: Hillary Clinton Has "Diplomatic Illness"
John Bolton, former U.N. ambassador and Fox News contributor, alleged that Hillary Clinton was <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/18/john-bolton-hillary-clinton_n_2322782.html?utm_hp_ref=hillary-clinton">faking a "diplomatic illness"</a> to avoid testifying about Benghazi. Clinton's testimony was postponed after she fainted and suffered a concussion in December. Bolton claimed "every foreign service officer in every foreign ministry in the world" is familiar with coming up with such "diplomatic illnesses" when they "don't want to go to a meeting or a conference, or an event." "And this is a diplomatic illness to beat the band," he said.
Bob Beckel: "I went swimming. My eyes blew up, and it made me look Oriental."
Bob Beckel: "When's the last time you heard about rape on a college campus?"