18 September 2014

Scotland Decides - But Why Wasn't There a Third Way?

We all know that the Scots didn't really want to choose full independence, don't we? We know that really, deep down, an option for the third way was the best option, right? Whatever happened to devo max? The old way of seeing the world in black or white, left or right, or on this case yes or no, is tired. We've all been tricked into thinking about this as an ultimatum. We've all been played by politicians who tell us they future can only be how they see it. It's not. We need to resist the temptation to try and knock lumps out of each other by drawing dividing lines between ourselves.

Alex Salmond Delivers Final Plea


Obama Tweets Message Against Scottish Independence Ahead Of Vote

Barack Obama
HuffPost Reports

Top Terrorism Expert Reveals ISIS Strategy To Unify Extremists In Jihad

Isis Fighters

And So There Must Come An End

Charley Kitley
Charlotte Kitley

Final Post Of Blogger Charlotte Kitley, Who Passed Away This Week

Gordon Brown Delivers Speech Of His Life In Defence Of The UK

Gordon Brown
Jeremy Sutton-Hibbert via Getty Images

Kay Burley Calls 'Stick-Wielding' Campaigner A Knob Live On Air

Sky News
Sky News

Mehdi Hasan And Jonathan Freedland Talk Anti-Semitism And Islamophobia


BBC Gives Pro-Indy Scots Fresh Ammunition With Georgraphy Howler

Allan James

More Politics
Salmond's Independent Scotland Could Fail In A Year.. Ed Miliband Heckled In Edinburgh

Here's What To Expect After Scotland's Independence Vote

Peter Macdiarmid via Getty Images

More WorldPost
Sole Agent Of Syria Horror.. Ebola By Numbers.. $1B.. Death For Mutiny.. Landmark Pact

Max Clifford Launches Appeal Against Eight-Year Prison Sentence

Max Clifford
Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire

Scottish Sun 'Bottles It' On Referendum With 'Naffest Splash Ever'

Scottish Sun
The Scottish Sun

'Independence Would Change How Scottish MPs Vote In Westminster'

Oli Scarff via Getty Images

Regardless Of The Outcome, The Scottish Debate Has Impassioned A Generation

Scottish Independence Referendum
Lynne Cameron/PA Wire

'This Has Been One Of The Unique Movements Of My Lifetime'


This Is How Bruising The Referendum Has Been For David Cameron...

David Cameron
BEN STANSALL via Getty Images

Miliband HQ Is Set To Be Demolished

Victoria Street Ed Miliband
John Phillips via Getty Images

Why Boris Could Really Have His Hands Full While Still London Mayor..

Boris Johnson
Peter Macdiarmid via Getty Images

Labour To Scrap Annual Conference If Scotland Votes For Independence

Labour Party Conference 2013
Gareth Fuller/PA Archive

Strategists Assuming 'Yes' Vote Would Result In Recall Of Parliament


Farage Warns Scottish Independence Campaign May Cause Riots

Nigel Farage
ANDY BUCHANAN via Getty Images

5 Reasons Why Many Scots Will Vote For Independence

BEN STANSALL via Getty Images

Yes, The Thai PM Really Just Said Tourists In Bikinis Aren't Safe..

Hannah Witheridge

..Unless They're Ugly


Who'd Be Dumb Enough To Sign A Petition To SUPPORT Isis?


Yep, Students Really Will Agree To Anything

Presented By BP
Advertise On The Huffington Post

Follow HuffPost

    1. View all RSS feeds

The 'Stictly' Curse Strikes Again

Ben Cohen Kristina Rihanoff
Rui Vieira/PA Archive

iOS 8 Is Out Now! Here's How To Get It...


Bayern Munich V Manchester City

Bayern Munich Manchester City
CHRISTOF STACHE via Getty Images

'I'm Not Going To The Gym... I Might Get Mobbed'

Lauren Goodger
Mark Robert Milan via Getty Images

More Entertainment
12 Funniest Country Song Titles Ever.. Travolta Addresses Gay Relationship Claims

A Scottish Referendum Playlist: 18 Songs For 18 September

Freddie Mercury

'EastEnders' Spoiler! Will Alfie Admit To Arson?

Eastenders Alfie Fire
BBC Pictures

It's Here: The British Remake Of 'Independence Day'

Independence Day Scotland Spoof

Not A Fan Of Pricey's Daughter's Name Then, Katie?

Katie Hopkins

How Will You Vote In The Scottish Referendum? Use Our Flowchart!

Scottish Referendum Flowchart

More Comedy
This Is How To Terrify Other Cats.. Scottish Referendum Playlist.. Oliver Begs Scotland To Stay

Did Joan's Doctor Take A SELFIE While She Was Under Anesthetic?

Joan Rivers
Yui Mok/PA Archive

Eva And Ryan 'Welcome Baby Girl'

Eva Ryan
Sonia Recchia via Getty Images

'I Shot Two Lions & Can Drink 14 Bottles Of Wine A Day'

Gerard Depardieu

This Photographer Taught 1,500 Puppies To Swim. These Are The Adorable Results.

Underwater Puppies
Seth Casteel

Naked Breasts Appear For The First Time In UK Shopping Centres - For A Good Reason


Which 'X Factor' Judge Are You?

X Factor

Sheridan Reveals Dramatic New Look

Sheridan Smith
WeirPhotos / Splash News

Will They Break Up Or Won't They? If The Scottish Referendum Was A Gay Romantic Comedy

United Queendom Scottish Romcom

Penis Pics And Back Scratching: Critical Advice For The Opposite Sex

Woman Whispering To Man
Paul Gilligan via Getty Images

'I Am A Woman, I Have Breasts And A Cleavage. Got A Problem?'

Deepika Padukone

John Oliver Begs Scotland To Stay, Despite That 'A***-Hole' David Cameron

John Oliver Scottish Independence