Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alister Morgan

GET UPDATES FROM Alister Morgan
 

Arsene Wenger Should Have Bought British to Avoid Arsenal's Current Woes

Posted: 25/08/2011 14:23

Samir Nasri finally completed his £25m move from Arsenal to Manchester City Wednesday and you could almost hear the sigh of resignation from Arsenal fans so soon after the departure of Cesc Fabregas to Barcelona. Another young and gifted player, (yet to peak in football terms), who made their name in an Arsenal shirt has left.

Pictures showing a grinning Nasri holding his new number 19 shirt will be everywhere for a while but in this case it would be more appropriate to replace his new squad number with his reported weekly wage of '£180k'. Make no mistake, this was a match made in monetary heaven revealing the same kind of mutual attraction that has paired rich old men with young beautiful women throughout the ages. However, I suspect that Arsenal could have avoided these recent departures if Nasri was born in Manchester and not Marseilles and Fabregas in Barnet not Barcelona.

I'm not going to criticise any player for maximising his earnings but there is an important lesson to be learned from this and other recent high profile Premiership transfers. Arsene Wenger ignored English talent for far too long and now when he finally has some English talent to integrate into his side his most valuable foreign players can't jump ship fast enough.

Over the long term, nurturing young foreign talent will rarely be as profitable as securing homegrown superstars for top Premiership clubs. Nasri & Fabregas were Arsenal's most important players (apologies to the perpetually injured genius gifted Robin van Persie) and both have been sold against the will of the Wenger and the Arsenal fans. The £55m in transfer fees Arsenal received cannot hope to replace them like-for-like but the key focus here isn't revenue profit on a balance sheet, its profit on the pitch and winning trophies. This summer Arsenal are significantly richer but further than ever from all-important silverware.

Wenger revolutionised Arsenal in 1996 building some great sides but there have been two significant changes to the modern game that have affected all Premiership teams. Firstly most academies are filled with foreign teens (a trend Wenger continues to pioneer), the second is the power shift from top managers to top players. The former diminishes any chance of unearthing British talent while the latter erodes a manager's ability to coerce unsettled players to sign and see out contracts. In past years buying British was never a priority for Wenger and this summer Arsenal paid a price for that policy. When Nasri and Fabregas wanted to leave they are able to force through a transfer.

In recent years John Terry, Steven Gerrard and Wayne Rooney have all expressed a desire to leave their clubs. Each of these players are marquee performers for elite Premiership teams in terms of influence on the pitch and revenue generation off it. The fact that all three decided to stay at their clubs is down to one thing: they were English and their connections to their clubs ran deeper than better prospects and higher wages on offer elsewhere.

Sir Alex Ferguson proved the value of having a core of British players in his all-conquering Manchester United sides while Kenny Dalglish has spend around £77m on four English players since becoming Liverpool FC manager last year. Chelsea's top players have always included a strong UK contingent while Spurs routinely field more English players that any other top-six Premiership side. Only Manchester City follows Wenger's lead with a merry-go-round of expensive foreign imports coming and going.

Success in football often comes with continuity and top British players stay at top Premiership clubs much longer than their foreign counterparts giving managers more time to create successful teams. Paul Scholes, Gary Neville, Steven Gerrard, John Terry and Ryan Giggs are a few who have played out glittering careers with a single club but Cristiano Ronaldo, Fernando Torres, Cesc Fabregas, Samir Nasri , Carlos Tevez and Luka Modric are football nomads available to the highest bidder once they fancy a change of scenery.
Sometimes buying British is best!

 

Follow Alister Morgan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/alsy77

FOLLOW UK
 
 
  • Comments
  • 37
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
21:17 on 28/08/2011
Shocking display today by Arsenal.

Could have easily been double figures.
02:29 on 28/08/2011
I doubt seriously, Mr Morgan, that you understand modern football economics or footballers in the least. In regard to John Terry, Steven Gerrard and Wayne Rooney in all three cases what they got was more money. Someone needs to set you down and explain the basics of negotiating, agents, manipulation of the media, and modern footballers. I can't help but wonder if you've ever gotten a raise that wasn't cost of living. Good Lord, what naivete.

If you had the first clue about Arsenal then you'd know that the club has a strict wage scale that informs the signing and negotiating of players. It is a major component of the club's strategy of signing younger players to groom them in the Arsenal way. In a football culture of senseless transfer fees and eye-popping yearly salaries, it is the club's attempt to add some sanity to the process. That Arsenal have had problems keeping players from clubs willing to spend jaw dropping amounts without concern for breaking even, much less ever breaking into the black, has not one damn thing to do with where the players are from. Further, even the most basically informed football fan, much less Arsenal supporters, have understood that Cesc Fabregas was going to go back to the club he supported in his youth filled with friends he has known for years. He even took a pay cut to return to his home, family, and lifelong dream. Write about something you actually know about.
23:47 on 27/08/2011
Uninformed article....slightly xenophic too. To be diplomatic about the trend, UK born players often aren't so sought after as overseas players, for many reasons, including that the clubs and players themselves price themselves out of the market. Consider Carrol went for almost the combined price of Fabregas and Nasri, which is absurd considering he's less than half the talent and potential of either. Brits are just as greedy, they also tend to get their demands met more readily. Recal Mark Hughes freely signed for a catalogue of clubs up and down the country, but when Piere Van Hooijdonk wanted to leave Forest he was cast as a villian. It's called hi-tech lynching and the papers are guilty by compliance.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:43 on 27/08/2011
As a Tottenham fan I should celebrate Ars... loss and I do, but I must confess I'm a big fan of AW.
To the benefit of EPL fans his team plays such beatiful football that even I cannot bring myself to hate it. Let's be realistic, his style reqire creativity that not alot of British based players posses. Show me a British equivalent to Nasri or Cesc available on the transfer market for fiscally disciplined team like Ars... and I'll agree with your "buy British" slogan. Buy best you can is a bit more realistic approach.

They have great young Brits in Ars... who going to benefit from the opportunity of playing bigger roles.So even your patriotic pledge does not hold water.

Samir Nasri went on to an extremely ambitious project, doubled his wages and if I'm offered something similar (F1 Ferrari team Technical Director position would be my engineering "ManCity") I would do that too. He did not do Samuel Eto'o's Makhachkala thing. He fits in there.

BTW the 2 reasons Rooney did not leave is that ManUre gave him 250K a week and Real and Barca were not that interested. Very British Sol Cempbell did leave...
Following your logic should Barca doubt loyalty of Messi cause he's not born on the same continent?
The answer is no, until they are staying on top and paying going rate for the best in a biz.
23:21 on 26/08/2011
inch verstehe konnen sie mirsagen nein pending comments?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
19:24 on 26/08/2011
Two words:- Ashley Cole. English, but left Arsenal for money, just like Nasri.

Shockingly bad article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dgoshilla
16:21 on 26/08/2011
That was a great article. Here in the US we've finally started focusing on youth development under MLS franchises and it's paying huge dividends. Home grown talent is crucial.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cplKlyde
I voted for change and all I got was a T-shirt
02:19 on 26/08/2011
Hey Alister instead of jumping on the anti-Wenger band wagon how about a post on something important like the lack of black coaches and managers in English football?
23:17 on 26/08/2011
lol a good manager have to be good don/t matter what color they are .
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cplKlyde
I voted for change and all I got was a T-shirt
02:10 on 26/08/2011
So much nonsense I don't know where to start. You like to hold up Ferguson as an example but tell me where was his last goal keeper from? Where is the current goal keeper from Where is Chichorito from? How about Berbatov
As to the ridiculous notion that Rooney stayed at Man U out of loyalty to team or to England; are you high? The boy stayed because Ferguson agreed to pay him 250000 a week.
Would I like to see more English/Britsh players in the Premier League? Yes but don't make Wenger out to be some sort of guy who is out of touch with current trends. In modern football you buy the best players you can afford no matter where they are from.
09:23 on 26/08/2011
nice comment mate.... felt exactly the same when i read it.... quoting rooney as the epitome of loyalty when the tantrums he threw were far more than subtle!!!!! this guy must ve been high when he wrote this!!! :)
01:27 on 26/08/2011
It doesn't matter whether the players are British or not.


It's down to what kind of players Wenger is buying.

As soon as Arsenal moved to the Emirates for some unknown reason instead of buying strong tall players with flair and steel, he decided to buy midgets.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
19:22 on 26/08/2011
Permit me to offer a possible explanation of this to you.
You are 100% correct, Arsenal have goe from a team designed to compete in the Prem built on poeeseeion speed of attack and power, to one based on tippy-tappy football designed to win the Champions league, a la Barca.

You can't tackle in Europe and that puts big strong teams at a disadvantage. They're a great team, but look how often Barca players go to ground. Thus in a Euro competition Barcelona beat ManU at a canter. But in England where you play 38-45 competitive games a season a small team is at a huge advantage and I'd back ManU every time.
21:14 on 26/08/2011
Man Utd have that mix of small players and experienced players though. Wenger has seemingly gone entirely for young midgets. They lack that Keown/Dixon/Adams etc....steel.
17:43 on 25/08/2011
@Foto EffeX @Luuke - Ramsey is Welsh. Please stop calling him English?!
16:09 on 25/08/2011
Having said, i think your article will generate a lot of debate amongst Arsenal fans, some who want more British marquee signings.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jubo
Extreme Centre
16:07 on 25/08/2011
With all due respect... Since Wayne Rooney, what British talent?
17:46 on 25/08/2011
Wilshere, Milner, Richards, Welbeck, Henderson, P Jones, Smalling, Cleverly, Walcott, Sturridge, Gibbs, Rodwell... I could go on? Granted all aren't World Class but most will hold their own in the Prem
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cplKlyde
I voted for change and all I got was a T-shirt
02:12 on 26/08/2011
Wilshere will be when he is healthy , I think Walcott could be if he were moved to the left side. And Smalling is going to be massive just watch.
02:27 on 26/08/2011
I think jubo has a point. And of the names you mention, the biggest ones are Wilshere, Milner, Richards, and Walcott - and of those aren't Wilshere and Walcott at Arsenal?

I don't follow EPL that closely so I apologize if I've got that all wrong.
15:53 on 25/08/2011
"Arsene Wenger ignored English talent for far too long and now when he finally has some English talent to integrate into his side his most valuable foreign players can't jump ship fast enough."

It is not the job of a club manager to pick players based on nationality it is his job to pick players based on their merit.

The fact remains, Arsenal are a club looking for success. Having British Talent makes no different. May be Wenger should have procured better foreign talent than the likes of Senderos, Schillaci etc.

Having British/English talent doesn't really suffice as a point seeing as the English National Team has flopped for the last 40 odd years. Why don't foreign teams sign English players? Overpayed and overpriced. Apart from Wayne Rooney and possibly Ashley Cole, not one Englishmen would get into a top European Team.

Barry Irish makes a brilliant point too.
15:52 on 25/08/2011
The greater 'loyalty' of British players to the club that developed them or with whom they first turned professional is hard to find. Perennial champions ManU currently boast only four British players who came through their youth system: Evans, Wellbeck, Cleverley, and Fletcher. (Giggs was developed by Man City, but played all his professional career with United). The other British players on the team (Jones, Ferdinand, Owen, Smalling, Carrick, Young, Rooney) were just as quick to jump ship from other Premier League teams for a bigger pay-cheque as any other nationality.