Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ally Livingston

GET UPDATES FROM Ally Livingston
 

The Long Overdue Recognition of Fraser Forster

Posted: 08/10/2012 22:00

Celtic goalkeeper Fraser Forster has finally been called into the England squad. It is a call that is long overdue, well deserved and incredibly exciting. Ever since his penalty save against Hearts last season, the former Newcastle keeper has been nothing short of sensational. With every game he has gained confidence, and he has become easily the best goalkeeper in the Scottish Premier League.

Forster, and Celtic goalkeeping coach Stephen Woods, have ironed out some earlier weaknesses in his decisiveness when crosses came into the box. That improvement, combined with Forster's six foot seven frame and brilliant ability for shot-stopping has earned him an England call-up. It is Forster's success, but the contribution of Woods should not be forgotten. He has also been the subject of praise from Artur Boruc and Lukasz Zaluska, Celtic's other goalkeepers during this tenure. Especially in the goalkeeping department, these coaches can make all the difference. They work solely with one or two players and also have a significant influence on scouting for their chosen position. Forster cited Woods as a major factor in his decision to sign a full-time contract with the Bhoys, and Celtic's decision to recruit Woods for their coaching staff has paid dividends.

Forster probably would not have received a call from England manager Roy Hodgson had it not been for the England under-21 team wanting Jack Butland for a critical play-off match. I am of the belief that Forster should be England's number two goalkeeper. Butland is a keeper of undoubted promise but his rise to prominence is baffling. It is not the quality of the opposition that Butland was playing against when he initially was called up that I object to, but rather a simple question - if he was that talented, why was he not in the Birmingham team? Similarly, Norwich's John Ruddy is a good goalkeeper, but not of the same quality as Forster. Ironically, Forster was replaced by Ruddy as Norwich goalkeeper. Paul Lambert made his admiration of Forster clear, and was open in admitting that he was disappointed to lose him.

Whether Forster is number two, three or four for England, the simple recognition of being in the squad is huge. Every single Celtic player and coach tweeted their congratulations. It was clearly a success not just for one man, but the entire Celtic squad. Additionally, with one swift call, Hodgson has probably tripled Forster's value from the £2 million fee paid to Newcastle.

Forster's benefit is, in all likelihood, to Gary Hooper's detriment. The English striker was Celtic's star man against Spartak Moscow last Tuesday. Hodgson has four strikers that are justifiably ahead of Hooper in Danny Welbeck, Andy Carroll, Jermain Defoe and Wayne Rooney. If one of them gets injured, I still doubt that Hooper will be called up.

An anti-Scottish attitude has been embedded in the English game for far too long. Hodgson may have slightly altered this perception with the Forster call-up, but he would have been wary of the intense criticism he could have been subject to had England failed to win either of these games, given his two 'controversial' picks. Joe Ledley was right to claim that Forster's pick might help bring Hooper into the England squad, but it will take time. Barring an injury, Forster will not make his way off the bench. If Forster is picked for the friendly against Sweden, and impresses in that game, that may help to clear the path for Hooper to be included.

The Celtic striker could also help his chances with a couple of goals in the Nou Camp on the 23 October 2012. Yet it is ridiculous that domestic form alone won't be good enough to get him into the squad. Jay Bothroyd and David Nugent have made it to the squad from the Championship. In fact, Hooper scored more goals in one season in the Championship than £35 million Andy Carroll managed to, and he achieved that while playing for Scunthorpe. Nevertheless, it is only through further Champions League goals that Hooper will be able to break into the squad.

The inclusion of a Scottish-based goalkeeper may also be easier to justify then that of a striker. Goalkeepers are far easier to subjectively compare and analyse, regardless of their league. Shot-stopping, kicking, the number of mistakes made, positioning and so on, can all be demonstrated regardless of the opposition. That's why picking Butland, regardless of his division could be justifiable, but it also simultaneously reinforces my belief that Forster should have been included in the squad far earlier. Conversely, strikers are far more affected by the defences in front of them. Any goals can be attributed to a lack of defensive ability of the opposition. That lack of comparability will mean that Hooper's team will be held against him more than Forster's will be.

This is a buoyant moment both for Celtic and all of Scottish football. As Celtic manager Neil Lennon pointed out, for far too long the Scottish media has talked down our national game. There is plenty of talent north of the border, and hopefully this can be a watershed moment for that particular self-realisation. Even if that does not occur, it is still a personal triumph for Forster. His decision to join Celtic has been vindicated. With England call-ups, Champions League successes and the backing of a superb coach, Forster has the potential to be spoken before the names of Bonner and Boruc, as Celtic's greatest modern goalkeeper.

 

Follow Ally Livingston on Twitter: www.twitter.com/allylivingston

FOLLOW UK SPORT
Celtic goalkeeper Fraser Forster has finally been called into the England squad. It is a call that is long overdue, well deserved and incredibly exciting. Ever since his penalty save against Hearts la...
Celtic goalkeeper Fraser Forster has finally been called into the England squad. It is a call that is long overdue, well deserved and incredibly exciting. Ever since his penalty save against Hearts la...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:17 AM on 10/14/2012
Great Keeper, great guy as well, he was fantastic for us at Norwich, however John Ruddy has also proven himself to be of the same class, after all, both have had to earn their corn with some of the defensive problems they both had and have to deal with in the number one shirt at Norwich.
I am over the moon he has been given a call from Roy, the same as i was when John was, so good luck to them both and i wish them well.
As for the comment about Scottish football and not getting recognized.
I live in the east of England, so we know how you feel, but the best will always get there in the end.
We feel some of our young players don't get to play on the big stage because no one knows where East Anglia is, however rest assured, if you are good enough you will come through.
There is no anti Scottish league or any anti Scottish feeling where i live, that is for sure, ask the Norwich supporters and Ipswich supports about all the great Scottish players which have graced our pitches.
Also ask about the players who went North to Scotland and still were first choice for their position in the England team.
02:31 PM on 10/10/2012
"An anti-Scottish attitude has been embedded in the English game for far too long."...silly.

The Scottish league is weaker than ever. Being good in Scotland does not mean you are good, just that you are good against St Mirren or Clydebank.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
02:29 PM on 10/12/2012
Maybe, but you should pick players based on form and not reputation. Frasier Forster has been tested at the European level against quality teams and has come out on top there should be no reason that England should not select him. Equally Gary Hooper has shown quality in front of the net, a confidence to score, and most of all, a winning mentality.....how Andy - I'm still a punchline Carroll - gets a call up instead is beyond me. Yes week in and week out Carroll may play against better opposition, but if were honest he's been rubbish, lacks confidence in front of goal, and has never ever been part of a team where winning is expected.
11:32 PM on 10/09/2012
You say that it's ridiculous that domestic form wouldn't be enough to get him into the England squad and yet further on in the article you say that he may not get picked because a lack of defensive opposition ( i.e The Scottish League) could be attributed to his high goalscoring. Well exactly...so why would his exclusion on that basis be ridiculous. Scoring week in-week out against players from Ross County, Iverness CT, Dundee etc is not comparable to scoring against teams like Man City, Chelsea, Arsenal etc........If that's an anti-Scottish League attitude well that's because there are good and sound footballing reasons for it. To be judged worthy of being an international player surely it is only right that you need to prove yourself by playing at the highest level consistently
09:47 AM on 10/10/2012
My point is that Hooper's domestic form is enough, given that Bothroyd and Nugent were both capped at Championship level. However, I think it is easier for a manager to pick goalkeepers, rather than any other position, across leagues, as the skills can be seen against any opponent. Which is why I think he definately should have called Forster up, but generally I think Hooper's worth a shout, as we have seen other players with similar domestic form from similar, if not inferior leagues being given international recognition.
01:24 PM on 10/10/2012
He may well get called up but I think he would definitely need to play at a higher standard to have any chance of being consistently called up at international level. For example, Bothroyd and Nugent each received only one cap, substitute appearances at that. The only player I can remember from a lower level getting a regular call up for England was Steve Bull. Suprisingly, he was first called up when playing for Wolves who had only just been promoted to the old division two and hadn't even played in that division when Bull made his first appearance in May 1989. Technically then, he was still an old third division player when he made his first England appearance!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
02:33 PM on 10/12/2012
Exactly how many English players have scored at European level this year? I think maybe Michael Carrick...Englans picks its players based on reputation....Andy Carroll is constantly called up despite the fact that he's rather rubbish because he cost a lot of money and had a decent half season with Newcastle...2 clubs ago. Even now...the Terry/ Rio debate rages on....despite the fact that both should be collecting a pension rather than still putting on the England kit.
07:30 PM on 10/12/2012
Agree about Rio, still think Terry had a couple of years left.