Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Amy Lamé

GET UPDATES FROM Amy Lamé
 

For Some People, EVERY Tuesday Is Fat Tuesday

Posted: 21/02/2012 12:07

It's FAT TUESDAY today- also known as Mardi Gras, Carnevale, or closer to home, Pancake Day. We are meant to clear out our cupboards, use up any butter, eggs, sugar. Today is a gut buster- we are encouraged to line our bellies with richness and fat in anticipation of 40 Lenten days without booze, chocolate and meat. And just when I'm getting ready to go into dietary lockdown, the menu is looking very interesting.

Condiments at the ready, people, because a Dutch scientist has created a laboratory hamburger - grown from stem cells claimed from a cow. It's the world's first synthetic burger but with a £200,000 research price tag, it won't be putting Mickey D's out of business anytime soon. But will we forsake taste for a futuristic all you can eat carnivorous buffet? The petri-dish protein will be mixed with a marble of fat and flavourings to make it palatable, as well as chemicals and antibiotics to stop it rotting. Deee-licious!

Thankfully there won't be any Dutch Frankenburgers on the menu at Burger Queen, a beauty pageant for fatties infused with the spirit of a camp 1970s gameshow. Over five weeks in March, a dozen contestants will don stretch sequins and compete in rounds of Talent, Taste and Trend. The winner will be chosen by a panel of judges with yours truly at the helm - a sort of chubby Simon Cowell - though I promise to leave my tight t-shirts at home. It's more than just an evening of flabulous fun; Burger Queen 2012 serves as a focal point for an exciting new brand of fat activism that definitely hasn't been cooked up in a laboratory test tube.

The event's creator and host Scottee wants to empower fatties and create an open and honest discussion around body politics. "It's a positive event that embraces health at every size and encourages ownership of the word fat," he explains. There are some pretty radical politics at its heart. "At Burger Queen, to identify as 'fat' is to identify as other, regardless what that might be; so you don't necessarily need to be fat in order to identify as fat. Got it? Good. Every radical political movement needs a supporting cast of multi-sized justice-fighters, after all.

Scottee, founder of Burger Queen

Until now, the issue of obesity has been very much an "us" and "them" dynamic- think Supersize vs Superskinny writ large. Burger Queen is asking everyone - regardless of body size - to step into a pair of wide width stilettos and try our chubby lives on for size.

According to Scottee, the timing has never been better. "2012 is an ideal moment to strike back as we are subjected to the Olympics, which just so happens to be sponsored by some of the worlds most calorific brands." Irony, anyone?

Our awareness of fat - fear of it, fascination with it - is heightened in this era of economic austerity. Fat has become not just an aesthetic issue, but a moral issue as well. Documentaries on obesity and competitive TV programmes disguised as light entertainment tell us fat people are broken, unhappy and a drain on the NHS. The government has been accused of browbeating fatties, actively encouraging a trickle down effect of bullying and discrimination. The murky world of dietary advice is played out on our TV screens, magazines, and radio airwaves.

Last week on Radio 4's Woman's Hour, Dr Susan Jebb, chief advisor to the UK government on obesity, lectured a woman who had failed at every dieting attempt - according to Jebb, she just needs to try harder in order to slim down. Dr Jebb is a member of Scientific Advisory Boards for Coca-Cola, Heinz, PepsiCo, Nestlé and Kellogg's. Interestingly, Heinz produce Weight Watchers foods - overpriced, undernourishing products that contribute to the organisation's paltry 6% sustained weight loss "success" rate. But they won't tell you that; they want your money, and shareholders like a restless, fat mass of people brainwashed into thinking Weight Watchers is the answer to all their chubby troubles. Not until we recognize the dichotomy of the weight loss industry - the fact it NEEDS us to be fat, unhappy and desperate to shed weight in order to make money from us - will we be truly liberated. Burger Queen is exploring this issue in a very real way.

Scottee has been on a different commercially available diet every week and has documented his experiences; a short film exploring the physical and psychological effects of the diets will be screened at each Burger Queen event. So which was the hardest to stick to? "The well known replacement shake was the worst," he claims. "I was so surprised how little I was allowed to eat and the side effects of headaches, vomiting and lack of concentration that are discussed on their official online forums." Despite losing 5lbs he has regained 2lbs in as many days and found himself thinking about hiding food - something Scottee hasn't thought about since he conquered his addiction to eating in secret years ago.

The essential issue at hand is whether fat is a problem to be solved, or just a fact of life. Scientists may be able to make uniform, perfectly balanced burgers in a petri dish, but humans are much more than a collection of cells glued together with protein, fat and vitamins. We are messy, complex, diverse; thin, fat, and everything inbetween. We educate our children that difference is a glory to be embraced, so we need to include BQ - burger queens - in our list of BME, LGBTQ, ad infinitum. And remember... for some people, EVERY Tuesday is Fat Tuesday.

Burger Queen is every Thursday in March at the Royal Vauxhall Tavern, London. www.burger-queen.info

 

Follow Amy Lamé on Twitter: www.twitter.com/amylame

It's FAT TUESDAY today- also known as Mardi Gras, Carnevale, or closer to home, Pancake Day. We are meant to clear out our cupboards, use up any butter, eggs, sugar. Today is a gut buster- we are enco...
It's FAT TUESDAY today- also known as Mardi Gras, Carnevale, or closer to home, Pancake Day. We are meant to clear out our cupboards, use up any butter, eggs, sugar. Today is a gut buster- we are enco...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 45
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
18:49 on 21/02/2012
personally I think variety is the spice of life - we all come in different shapes and sizes and that's fine. Not everyone is a blue eyed blonde, not everyone wears size 5 shoes. As long as you're happy, what is the problem? It's who you are that counts. One of my friends is a larger lady with a personality to match - she was/is an outrageous flirt and has never been short of male company! And her female friends love her because she is very caring and fun to be with. To the fat haters she says: 'love you darling' and just regally sweeps on by!
22:44 on 13/03/2012
Yes, she may be happy being fat, she may be a great woman, that is perfectly beleivable; but she is not living a healthy lifestyle! Scientifally, physically, and medically speaking she is doing herself harm.

Last I heard the colour of your eyes and your shoe size did not affect your health.
11:15 on 28/03/2012
But that not your business is her life nhow does that affect you
22:50 on 13/03/2012
She may be an amazing woman, intellegent, funny and happy with plenty of friends - there is no denying these facts. But that is besides the point - physically, scientifically, medically, she is harming herself. It is not a healthy lifestyle to lead.

Last time I checked having brown hair or size eight feet did not adversely affect your health. I should know, I have both. Or mabybe I should go for a check up, just in case...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William Anderson LMHC
Licensed Psychotherapist, Weight Control Expert
18:08 on 21/02/2012
Having been out-of-control obese for 25 years, I am in a good position to report how miserable it is and how misunderstood it is. Solving the problem is not just a matter of "trying harder." Neither is obesity a sign of a character flaw. Overweight people need some compassion and valid assistance, commodities in short supply, while being judged and held in contempt is normal. That needs to change. However, accepting obesity as something that is OK, just a fact of life, is not an answer to the problem. Obese people who are loved and valued as they are still suffer miserable consequences of the obesity.

We need to stop treating obese people badly, and we need to stop the smug preaching of fitness-oriented know-it-alls, ignorant of the real issues related to obesity, its causes, and the solution. But celebrating obesity and overeating as if they were OK only adds to the problem.

I finally discovered how to solve the problem as a behavior therapist, lost 140 pounds, and I've maintained my ideal body weight for 25 years. Now I help others.

Please, stop beating up on yourself if you're overweight or beating up others who are. But don't make the mistake of accepting obesity as OK. When you want to know how the problem can be solved, please read my book.

William Anderson, LMHC
Author of 'The Anderson Method - Secrets of Permanent Weight Loss'
www.TheAndersonMethod.com
22:45 on 13/03/2012
Wise words.
photo
US American
"...lightning ain't distributed right"
17:43 on 21/02/2012
P90X
16:45 on 21/02/2012
This event is a reactionary statement against the hours of point and laugh documentaries that insist that fat people are unhappy, broken and in need of help - this is echoed in some of the comments below.

Burger Queen is about fatties having a laugh, feeling empowered and showing the world that largely we are happy & well rounded (boom, boom) people that have no interest in whether your born fat, die fat, made yourself fat or don't deserve to be fat.

Lets not turn this discussion into 'but why are you fat?' or the fight for fat acceptance - this is much greater - this is a group of porkers saying we are not bothered you don't like us
or have a problem with the way we look. We fatties love you all regardless if you don't 'get it'.

This is fat pride babes - EAT IT!
16:48 on 21/02/2012
Well, said Scottee!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissFrijole
My bite is worse than my bark.
16:34 on 21/02/2012
I don't think being overly fat is healthy. There is a fine line between embracing your body at its natural size, and going overboard. The body has a set point; a weight that it has decided to maintain and no matter what you try to do about losing that weight, you will gain it back, unless you have a rigorous workout routine and change your diet. When you disregard healthy eating and stick whatever tastes good into your gaping hole of a mouth, then it is your own fault that you are fat. People who honestly try to lose weight but are stuck should either change their diet and workout plan, or accept that they are stuck at that size forever.
15:57 on 21/02/2012
don't forget the entertainment industry's and fashion industry's role in creating the fat/thin psychosis. entertainment and fashion claim they promote healthy but we all know that the skinniest actresses/models get the roles. only occasionally do the industries put up a normal sized (or even overweight person) - and they do so for self aggrandizement (movie sales, magazine sales) rather than for any real sense of diversity.

i bet if the entertainment/fashion industries didn't put so much emphasis on sick-thin models, there would be less tension for women and young girls to feel like they need to look like that. this would reduce backlash tendencies to over eat. I bet the extreme images of thinness make potentially normal sized women binge. not sure empirically - just a hypothesis.
18:11 on 21/02/2012
Our impression of what is "normal' in america is totally warped toward the fat. While there are fashion models that are dangerously skinny movie actresses are largely just normal sized. Go to countries in norther europe or asia, almost no one is fat. Living over there it really put the size of American's in perspective. We think people are normal when they are actually quite overweight.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
millebocca
veni, vidi, clicki
15:48 on 21/02/2012
this IMMTADO gal buys fully into the notion of erasing the obsession w contrived eating (aka diets) for both "skinny" people and "fat" people. in overweightedness, a balance can be struck that can help avoid outright, clinically-defined obesity and allow for some modicum of healthy living/exercise that can be truly incorporated into one's everyday. conversely, the slender/thin state can avoid anorexic manifestation by avoidance of forced behaviors that also backfire.
there are choices all along the way - key is not to resign oneself irrevocably at the first sign of self-perceived "failure"
(IMoveMyTushAndDon'tOvereat)
15:48 on 21/02/2012
Really interesting to read all your comments, validates the plight somewhat and only encourages me to produce more events like these. You're all invited to open your eyes, learn and watch us drain the NHS before its imminent reform as guests, just drop me an email and we'd gladly welcome you. I could have spent an hour replying to all your comments but fat is about love and I love you all.

Happy Pancake Day Haters.
15:29 on 21/02/2012
An excellent article. And I'm not an expert, but I'm pretty sure being fat has a lot to do with the genes. Metabolic rates, and the distribution of fat cells, differ for reasons over which an individual has no control, just as do levels of skin pigmentation or sexual orientations. That isn't the whole picture, but it is fair to say that some people are born fat (others may well have fatness thrust upon them). Saying that fat people are 'a drain on the NHS' is fatuous - so are smokers, drinkers, drivers, athletes (they wear out their joints), mothers (do you know how much it costs to birth a baby?), compulsive dieters and, most of all, Lenten, pinch-faced types who say things like 'you brought it on yourself, fattie', and who all (deservedly) end up with stress-related illnesses. (And in case you think I have some personal axe to grind, I should point out that I'm one of those naturally slim people who can eat whatever he likes and never gain a pound. That's irrelevant, I'm just showing off). I say Viva! and Mangia! to my fat brothers and sisters!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
16:05 on 21/02/2012
Studies have shown that being obese has very little to do with genetic make up. That's why you often see a fat family with a fat dog. Most people who are overweight eat too much and don't exercise enough, it's that simple.

Instead of creating silly mysticism behind the reasons for obesity, people should be empowered to gain a healthy weight by being encouraged to eat a healthy diet and take regular exercise.

Almost anyone obese can become a healthy weight. The secret is not faddy diets (which rarely work) but simple changes such as sensible portion size and lifestyle choices that make exercise part of daily routine - such as walking the dog for an hour every day.

Obesity can be fixed just like poor dental hygiene can. People who lose weight in a sustainable way tend to be happier and live longer. That's why it would be wrong to encourage people to think that obesity is ok.
17:02 on 21/02/2012
here's a study:

Obesity--is it a genetic disorder?
Loos RJ, Bouchard C.
Source
Human Genomics Laboratory, Pennington Biomedical Research Center, Baton Rouge, LA 70808, USA.

and I quote from the abstract:

"Twin, adoption and family studies have shown that genetic factors play a significant role in the pathogenesis of obesity."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
16:28 on 21/02/2012
There is a genetic influence on weight gain. The % is up for argument. What is pretty clear though is that humans do not get obese if they have a healthy diet and get enough exercise.

There is not a gene for obesity. It takes dedication.
17:06 on 21/02/2012
I never said there was 'a gene' for being overweight, rather that being fat is influenced by factors over which we have no control. And therefore Amy's observation that discrimination against fat people can be compared to discrimination against LGBT people had a certain validity (even if there isn't a point-to-point comparison). The question here is not whether being overweight is healthy or not - it's whether it's acceptable to derogate those people who are.
15:22 on 21/02/2012
"The essential issue at hand is whether fat is a problem to be solved, or just a fact of life...so we need to include BQ - burger queens - in our list of BME, LGBTQ, ad infinitum"
The rest of the article is reasonable enough, but this quote is pretty lame. Fat is a fact of life, an fact of an unhealthy life of constantly over-consuming. Other than for those with serious mental health or glandular issues (almost no one) it is a completely conscious choice to over-consume. Maybe it is hard to not be overweight, but it is hard to go to work every morning, it sucks to pay bills, many things are hard.
15:05 on 21/02/2012
Umm, there is absolutely nothing natural about obesity, it isn't a fact of life. While there are rare cases of people with glandular or serious mental health disorders that lead to obesity most people just eat too much bad food. The article is correct that diet industry foods are junk, but eating a healthy low calorie diet is great. There is almost no good excuse for obesity (this doesn't mean be a size 0, just be healthy and have basic fitness) and "fat acceptance" is like "Hummer H2 Driver acceptance" or "Poor Dental Hygiene acceptance".
13:48 on 21/02/2012
Charming, insightful and articulate as always Ms. Lamé - I hope that some people will take it to heart.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
13:43 on 21/02/2012
Broadly speaking, being overweight is a consequence of eating too much and not getting enough exercise. It's comparable to how having bad teeth is a consequence of eating sugary foods and not brushing your teeth enough.

Being overweight is a choice, and given the health consequences, it isn't a good choice.

It is therefore unreasonable to compare it to being LGBTQ or BME.
photo
dim
one in a can
16:09 on 21/02/2012
Disagree. Just recently it's been proven that BPA that we are being dosed with messes with our endocrine system enough to throw the system out of wack and cause obesity despite drastic dietary measures. Foeti develop differently because of the mothers' exposures.

If people are willing to PAY to have their STOMACHS STAPLED, being overweight is obviously NOT by choice.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
16:25 on 21/02/2012
They choose to have surgery rather than change to a healthy diet. It's a choice. The longer you leave it, the harder it gets.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
18:13 on 21/02/2012
Dim, it is a choice in the vast majority of cases, because the vast majority of people can lose weight by eating less and exercising more.

If you can show me a link the any peer-reviewed study that says there is a physiological reason why one person takes more calories from their food than another then I will be delighted to admit I'm wrong, but the medical profession does not hold this position.

There is some evidence to suggest there are genetic factors why some people carry on eating even though they've had enough, but again this can be simply remedied with sensible portion sizes and regular exercise.
13:39 on 21/02/2012
Rock on.. The media and food producers advertize and companies produce unhealthy products and then scold the people who eat them, saying they have no self control. Almost every commercial in the US for fast food and candy bars feature young slim active people enjoying the product without any consequences. I love looking at women in the 1920s who were considered pretty, they are not stick thin and look and feel like real women
15:10 on 21/02/2012
But Americans in the 1920s weren't obese for the most part. People aren't meant to be obese. No one likes rail thin models, but don't delude ourselves into saying obesity is natural, healthy or pretty. It is a sign of over-consumption and a sedentary lifestyle, it harms the environment, our health and our pocketbook
23:06 on 13/03/2012
I'm sorry but your argument does not hold water. Just because you see somthing on television it does not mean you must consume it to exess. Ronald McDonald does not come into your home and hold a gun to your head and drag you to McD's every week does he? It is a matter of self control, people make the choice to eat bad food. No matter the size of who is on the adverts people do know, its called Junk Food for a reason. Plus, after you eat nothing but candy and burgers then you get fat surely the link would be made then in their own minds? You would then have to use self control to stop eating the junk.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
13:38 on 21/02/2012
The idea that fat people should be accepted just like LGBT people is offensive to LGBT people. The same goes for BME (I assume this means black & minority ethnic).

Fat is not a fact of life - you do it to yourself. You eat too much, and you exercise too little. I don't think you should be victimised, but it's fair to say fat people are a drain on the NHS. It's not healthy!

Should we accept diversity? Of course. Should we prevent people from commenting on diversity? Of course not. Should we be allowed to criticise those who waste our shared resources? Yes, we should.
photo
dim
one in a can
16:12 on 21/02/2012
You are wrong. It's not something you do to yourself. People torture themselves both with ridiculous diets and even surgery to deal with it, usually failing in the process. If you think you can control your body so well, try GAINING a lot of weight in a short period of time. See how that works out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
16:23 on 21/02/2012
Why a short period of time? People do it through their whole lives. Also what you do to yourself as a child (or more accurately, what your parents do to you) has a much greater impact.