Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Andy Burrows

GET UPDATES FROM Andy Burrows
 

Student Visa Restrictions Damaging & Badly Communicated

Posted: 14/05/2012 00:00

In the first of a new series exploring the radical changes the British higher education system is undergoing, I look at how new student visa restrictions are affecting international students.

Last year Theresa May announced that 260,000 fewer student visas will be given out over the next five years, through harsher restrictions on fake colleges and bogus students. Whilst it is clear that preventing fake students from illegally gaining visas is a positive thing, I believe the problem has been hugely overblown, and the solution poorly managed and badly miscommunicated.

Misuse of Figures


The basic problem here is that headline grabbing statistics have been used to the advantage of the government in order to impress British voters, whilst the very same figures have had the exact opposite impact on prospective international students. The headline figure of 260,000 fewer visas sounds like a high number and makes the government appear to be taking action. However, to prospective students abroad, the figure inevitably makes Britain appear less welcoming.

What's more, critics say that these figures have very little grounding in fact. The government claim they will only be cutting bogus students, and yet the very fact that they are in the UK illegally means there is no way of knowing exactly how many of them there are (and indeed, the number has already dropped significantly from the initial claim of a 400,000 reduction).

Miscommunication of Changes


Unfortunately, this is indicative of the dreadful miscommunication of the policy changes. Many experts believe that the changes to the visa system will not actually hinder genuine students from gaining a visa to study in the UK much at all. ". Yet, despite this, there is the growing sense amongst 'legitimate' prospective students that obtaining a study visa to Britain is now a near impossibility.

Indeed, amongst the hundreds of international students I come in to contact with each year, visas are by far their biggest worry, and almost all of them still believe there to be a student visa cap (despite this idea being thrown out at a very early stage of negotiations last year). The communication has been so poor, that the relatively minor changes in policy have done major damage to the reputation of Britain's higher education system.

Students Classified as Immigrants


A further problem, is that the government appear to have forced through this legislation for the wrong reasons. It is no secret that the new directives are to help them achieve their promised cuts to immigration numbers. With this, there is the strong suspicion that international students are being made scapegoats. The government promised unrealistic cuts on immigration, and instead of tackling the harder entry points it was far easier to control the number of 'students' slipping through the visa system.

Ultimately however, the real problem is that overseas students coming to study in Britain are counted in immigration figures, which is clearly nonsensical. A typical student coming to the country to study, will bring the UK £10,000 in fees and at least a further £15,000 in living expenses each year for three years, before returning to their own country. That they are lumped in with all other 'immigrants' not only distorts the numbers, but leads to knee jerk visa changes in an effort to gain votes. This is especially important in the current climate, where immigration is such a hot topic on the political agenda. It drags international students into a debate they really are not part of, giving them a bad reputation in the process.

Overall, the wrong classification of students as immigrants, coupled with the miscommunication of new policies and an apparent disregard for the reputation of British higher education, will inevitably begin to deter international students from the UK. Though very little has actually changed in terms of the student visa application process, the damage that has been done to the international reputation of Britain's higher education system is certainly noticeable.

NB: This post focusses only on the changes to the Tier 4 student visa system. A detailed look at the changes to Post-Study Work visas will come in a later post in this series.

 

Follow Andy Burrows on Twitter: www.twitter.com/foreignstudents

FOLLOW UK STUDENTS
In the first of a new series exploring the radical changes the British higher education system is undergoing, I look at how new student visa restrictions are affecting international students.Last year...
In the first of a new series exploring the radical changes the British higher education system is undergoing, I look at how new student visa restrictions are affecting international students.Last year...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ZeoGetty
A soul with a conscience
09:16 PM on 05/20/2012
A fascist Britain is forming thanks to the Tories and Theresa May. I just don't understand how the higher education sector will survive without international students. The UK needs its international students what with the cuts in education spending. The International students are also the ones who spend lots of money in retail, the economy needs them. International students will be considering other countries anyway what with the changes to the post-work visa. What's the use of getting a good degree without working experience? These students would struggle with just a degree from a foreign country when they go back. Work experience is vital! The changes in employment law means employers will now fire and hire as much as they like with very little regulation. May proposes that migrant workers make a minimum of 350000 pounds to be able to work in this country, is she for real? British students will stop going to universities eventually due to higher fees and the labor market will consists of unqualified workers who will, forever, work for poor wages living from paycheck to paycheck. This crusade is planned out for the goal is clear: WIDEN THE GAP BETWEEN THE POOR AND THE RICH. Do you think May or any of them Tories struggle with their children education? of course not.
photo
librarianesque
The Right was Wrong, the Left was Right.
05:47 PM on 05/14/2012
Very well thought out, Andy. I studied in Britain. People's lack of knowledge and limited understanding regarding student 'immigrants' is abhorrent and quite frankly, discriminatory. My visa clearly stated that I had no recourse to public benefits. My family paid in full, about 100,000 USD over the duration of my course--in school and living fees. Being an overseas studier does not come cheap, and in no way are the majority of us abusing the system. I find it bothersome when that is inferred, as many are paying to be here, no matter what they look like. When I stayed on to find a job, I can't tell you how many people got defensive about my financial situation--as if I were staying afloat by misuse of benefits. Nope.

Certainly, I am very grateful and do not regret my degree, but feel slightly disappointed by my experience and especially the disorganisation of Home Office and Teresa May, as well as sour attitudes towards immigration. It was obtuse to do away with the post-study work program. What is the rationale behind this and what are they replacing it with? No answers. May strikes me as functionally ignorant of the very real implications of changes under her leadership.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Burrows
11:26 AM on 05/15/2012
Thanks. It is ridiculous how much international students bring to the country (financially and culturally) and yet they are so often victimised as scroungers by the government and press. Much of it is purely short term vote winning rather than properly thought out policies.

I'll be looking at the changes to the post-study work visas in a week or two, but again the changes appear so misguided.
photo
librarianesque
The Right was Wrong, the Left was Right.
12:02 PM on 05/15/2012
Thanks for your reply Andy, and empathy. I appreciate it, and hope I did not come across as boorish. I'm interested in hearing your perspective on psw and will be on the look out for more of your articles. Take care.
03:35 PM on 05/14/2012
We have sloppy, ideologically driven government acting with little thought. They can do so because our systems of accountability are so weak.