Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bansi Kara

GET UPDATES FROM Bansi Kara
 

The Decline in Teacher Status: Difficult Times Ahead?

Posted: 14/11/2011 00:00

In times of strife, I usually turn to Confucius and a large tub of ice-cream. As always, Confucius' words of wisdom allow me to take a moment to reflect on the aspect of my professional life that has started to become irksome. Lately - and this may indeed be a result of the darkening days and a sneaking suspicion that the Tory government is not on my side - I have felt that teachers have been receiving the short end of the stick.

In so many societies, the concept of the teacher is valued; in fact, in some societies, the profession is venerated above all others. Confucius makes it clear what he believes the role of the teacher to be: "If you think in terms of a year, plant a seed; if in terms of ten years, plant trees; if in terms of 100 years, teach the people." It is entirely ironic that I quote this particular snippet from the great Chinese philosopher.

When I was 16, my head teacher - a man of charisma, with an unfailing belief in comprehensive education - borrowed four students on the eve of the 1997 General Election from their classrooms, put them all in a taxi and drove them to Leicester Town Hall, where a fresh-faced, enthusiastic Tony Blair was last-minute canvassing for votes. As one of them, for me, wide-eyed, uninitiated into the realm of national politics, this was the opening of a door.

My head teacher managed to push the five of us to the front of the crowd, clutching a small wooden frame. He hadn't showed it to us. He harnessed the attention of Mr Blair and handed him the wooden frame. It was read aloud; there was a vague promise that it would be hung in the bathroom. It said: "If you think in terms of a year, plant a seed; if in terms of ten years, plant trees; if in terms of 100 years, teach the people." My head teacher revealed that his mother had embroidered it for him but that he believed the person running the country should have it to hand.

I started teaching in 2003, at the start of what I perceived to be a real shift in public opinions on teachers and teaching. I had grown up being told not to be a teacher, with that ever-present phrase "those who can, do; those who can't, teach" ringing in my ears. However, the TDA adverts that every teacher knows and loves (because we all take them outside onto a field to teach them about the planets at some point in our careers) had just appeared and Teach First was in its inaugural year. I joined the Teach First graduate programme because Tony Blair had said "Education, Education, Education" and that meant something to me.

In 2006, in the research document entitled: 'The Status of Teachers and the Teaching Profession: Views from Inside and Outside the Profession' generated by the University of Cambridge and the University of Leicester, it was clear that by this time, perceptions of the teaching profession had become more positive. They revealed that in 2006, there seemed to be a "renewed optimism amongst teachers about their work". It was the crest of a wave.

The research cited a renewed optimism because they had noted that their respondents had identified an exact period of time in which the public perception of the teaching profession suffered the most decline in the latter half of the 20th century - the years between 1979 and 1988. It is not rocket science, people - it was, according to the research, "a period of major review of education policies leading up to the 1988 Education Reform Act". In short, the last time a Conservative government was in power, teachers and their social status suffered the most.

Is it any wonder then that now, under a Conservative government, the Daily Mail sees fit to call head teachers "no better than the Left-wing rabble rousers who dominate the profession", as if a teacher's politics are more important than their ability to educate young people? Even the vanguard of the left has something to say about the state of education - Deborah Orr berating "the left" that "has spent the last decade excusing an education system that lets down the people whom it is supposed to care for most" nearly broke my heart.

It seems that teaching has never really escaped from a fatally corrosive virgin-whore dichotomy. On one hand, ITV celebrates teachers in a mawkish, quasi-celebritised manner in the Teaching Awards; on the other, the moment teachers decide to defend their profession and the benefits that make up for the decades of hard grind, they are vilified. As long as we are quiet, do as we are told and are willing to accept that our government does not believe that our work is fruitful, we may continue on without public abuse. Step out of that role for a moment, go on strike because we believe in something and we become the Hester Prynne of the working world, destined to wear a scarlet letter and harangued by the likes of the Daily Mail.

So, after all this, has Confucius made me feel any better? Well, no. There's a tub of ice-cream somewhere that might help, though.

 

Follow Bansi Kara on Twitter: www.twitter.com/benniekara

In times of strife, I usually turn to Confucius and a large tub of ice-cream. As always, Confucius' words of wisdom allow me to take a moment to reflect on the aspect of my professional life that has ...
In times of strife, I usually turn to Confucius and a large tub of ice-cream. As always, Confucius' words of wisdom allow me to take a moment to reflect on the aspect of my professional life that has ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mrld20
02:43 AM on 11/15/2011
You Brits could learn a thing from teachers here in the States... Here our teachers are given broad leeway to develop their own lessons and curriculums without some nut from the Ministry of Education (or w/e the Brits call their version of the Department of Education)...

Here in the States teachers are given better pay for being for creative and developing innovative lesson plans... And let's not forget to mention that everyone is trying to get into OUR universities and colleges...
07:10 AM on 11/15/2011
Teachers in the US are not given broad leeway. They are forced to teach lessons from large 3 ring binders that tell them exactly what the state and federal gov't wants/allows/needs them to teach. As far as developing curriculums, I do not know any public school educator who is allowed to do that. I myself teach at a university in North Carolina, but I taught 4th grade in NC as well, so I know from personal experience. Also I have many friends and relatives who are teachers. Some states or local counties do give merit pay increases for a variety of reasons. Also not everyone wants to come to the US for an education--I went across the pond for my graduate degree.
10:44 AM on 11/14/2011
I do not have more assistants to help me out, I have people being made redundant all around me, but I do not complain as it is the nature of business during difficult periods. My profession is not recognised by Awards on ITV and I do not have a great scholar marketing my profession, but it matters to me. So it would be of significant use to teachers public perception if they would stop creating such a negative atmosphere around them by believing they are entitled to so much more than the rest of us.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bansi Kara
06:51 PM on 11/14/2011
Thank you for your comments. I appreciate that not everyone can understand why teachers would be so defensive of their pensions, or why they might complain about losing value in a society that relies on them to develop a functional workforce for the future. I was raised to believe that teachers, in all fields, were the most valuable assets a country could have and it is a belief that I have held ever since. I recognise that you may not understand why I need a teaching assistant, or why I need less contact time. I ask you to consider that those things are needed not for my own well being but for the sake of my students. My pension, on the other hand, is something I would like to safeguard. With pay freezes, rising inflation, being the first generation to pay fees and with mortgage deposits as large as they are, financial security is incredibly important to me, as I am sure it is to you. Perhaps this is not an argument as to who has more benefits, someone in marketing or a teacher, but rather a question of recognising that we all face challenges and we are all entitled to defend ourselves against issues that will undoubtedly change our working lives and finances. The fact that I have couched this argument in terms of being a teacher relates to my own experience - the only thing I have to draw on.
09:26 AM on 11/15/2011
I agree with you Bansi and I find smcghe10's comments a little outrageous. It is typical of a general public who do not appreciate the importance of educating our children. Teachers shape our next generation and it is incredibly important we protect and safeguard them.

Good for you Bansi.
11:31 AM on 11/15/2011
Bansi, thank you for your insight. I would not say I am so hard nosed that I am not sympathetic to your article and must say you have made some very good points which have altered my view, particularly based on pensions to which I retract my earlier comments. I still cannot conform to your opinion on contact time and assistants though. I think there is a difficulty correlating less contact time for teachers, assistants and improved attainment for children and young people. I would even posit that as Teachers leave the classroom for a few hours per week it actually disrupts the children's learning more and decreases their concentration. I can understand slightly more of a case regarding assistants. This is a generalisation and I understand it is not based on fact, but Teachers did not have assistants when I was younger, with comparable or larger class sizes and it had less of an impact than I think teachers let on. The difficulty is that to agree on what has impacted most on children - class size, teaching standards, assistants, quality of materials, gains in curriculum, a completely different study would need to be developed which may have some consequences which teachers do not want to hear, or maybe it will seek to further your point.
10:42 AM on 11/14/2011
I understand Bansi's comments and I have a deal of sympathy for her and the profession. I too believe that Teachers are damned if they do, damned if they don't.

What I do have some issue with and it is one which I believe a cross section of the teaching profession suffer from is what can be perceived as an aloof sense of entitlement. It creeps into this article with quotes from Confucius and how 'In so many societies, the concept of the teacher is valued; in fact, in some societies, the profession is venerated above all others.'

As a way of illustrating my point, the teaching profession are currently considering strike action. In Scotland, where I am from, they want to strike over changes to their pension, they are unhappy about being asked to teach for longer, due to the unsustainable and ridiculous 'McCrone time' being considered for removal. They are not happy about staff losing jobs, as they have every right to be. As a Marketing person, I have seen many colleagues lose jobs during the recession, no pension at all. They never had periods in the day away from contact time. I would love for 2 hours a week to be isolated from phone calls to catch up on work but it won't happen.