Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bill Nighy

GET UPDATES FROM Bill Nighy
 

World Leaders Need to Agree to the Robin Hood Tax at G20

Posted: 03/11/11 10:29 GMT

The Robin Hood Tax has come a long way since I appeared in a Richard Curtis short film to help launch our campaign in February 2010. We now have 115 UK organisations from Oxfam to the Methodist Church and from Barnardo's to the TUC backing us and sister campaigns across the world. We have the support of more than a thousand economists, including Nobel Prize winners. And we have a number of governments including France, Germany, Spain, Austria, Argentina, South Africa and the European Commission backing us.

In the UK the Archbishop of Canterbury this week signalled his support for a Robin Hood Tax, adding to the pressure on David Cameron. Opinion polls show that by a margin of two to one, the public agrees.

It has not been a steady upward curve. When I attended the G20 summit in Toronto last summer, it looked as if determined opposition from the Canadian hosts may force the proposal off the table all together. But a mixture of political leadership by France and the continuing need in this age of austerity for G20 members to find new sources of revenue means I arrived in Cannes yesterday evening in far better heart.

As David Cameron and his fellow G20 leaders meet over the next two days, they are under enormous pressure not just to take action to fix the immediate crisis in the eurozone but to learn the lessons of the past three or four years and ensure that finance works in the interests of society and not the other way around.

Mr Meryn King was right on the money when he said: "The price of the financial crisis is being borne by people who did absolutely nothing to cause it."

At their last summit in Seoul in 2010, G20 leaders acknowledged their responsibility to people forced into extreme poverty as the economic crisis spread around the world via falls in trade and investment. They quoted a World Bank estimate that 64 million more people now live on less than 75p per day, that's more people than live in the whole of the UK.

Yet an analysis of governments' budgets released by Oxfam on the eve of the summit found the UK's insistence that it will stick to its aid promises is the honourable exception rather than the norm. Far from increasing, global aid is expected to fall by a massive $9.5bn (£6bn) between 2010-12. $9.5bn is enough to provide primary school places for more than half the children who currently get no education.

The Occupy protesters outside St Paul's have been criticised for their lack of concrete ideas about what should change. Yet there is a very simple idea - a tiny tax on the financial transactions of banks, hedge funds and other financial institutions - that could go a long way towards making finance pay its fair share to society. Such a Robin Hood tax of just 0.05% could raise tens or even hundreds of billions worldwide if applied to share, currency, bond and derivative transactions.

The billion hungry people in the world (more than the total populations of the US and EU combined) should not have to wait for economic recovery to receive the help promised. Nor is it just people in Africa who cannot feed themselves, as I found out when I visited a food bank in Putney of all places earlier this year.

Given the UK's leadership on aid, it is all the more disappointing that the UK, rather than enthusiastically supporting Gates' recommendation, is instead expected to block progress. The PM knows the US is strongly opposed, yet claims financial transaction taxes must be global to work. Has he not noticed the UK's own unilateral Stamp Duty on share transactions that raises about £3bn every year?

Today, Bill Gates will present a report commissioned by President Sarkozy that will recommend G20 leaders adopt Robin Hood taxes as a way of fighting poverty and climate change. It is a real opportunity and one the G20 needs to grasp.

My hope is that a group of willing leaders will use Cannes as an opportunity to press ahead with Robin Hood taxes to fight poverty in their own countries and overseas. It would be great if David Cameron joined them. For one thing it would make me and possibly the St Paul's protesters a little less angry.

 
The Robin Hood Tax has come a long way since I appeared in a Richard Curtis short film to help launch our campaign in February 2010. We now have 115 UK organisations from Oxfam to the Methodist Church...
The Robin Hood Tax has come a long way since I appeared in a Richard Curtis short film to help launch our campaign in February 2010. We now have 115 UK organisations from Oxfam to the Methodist Church...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:55 PM on 11/06/2011
I bet the US is unlikely to go for this tax so it will never be world wide. Business moves to where taxation is less (witness corporation tax where companies have relocated outside the UK and EU.) Most financial transactions are electronic which makes relocating relatively easy. Companies have people who are many times more intelligent than politicians and bureaucrats will ever be and you can be sure they will find many new ways of organizing their businesses to minimize their tax liabilities. This tax will not be a walkover to impose.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
angler725
It's gotten comical now.
12:55 PM on 11/04/2011
Wasn't the Sheriff of Nottingham in charge of collecting taxes? Confusing.
04:37 PM on 11/03/2011
Quote; "My hope is that a group of willing leaders will use Cannes as an opportunity to press ahead with Robin Hood taxes to fight poverty in their own countries and overseas. It would be great if David Cameron joined them. For one thing it would make me and possibly the St Paul's protesters a little less angry".

In theory it's a good idea, but there's a snag. The very people your asking to introduce such a tax are the ones who'll end up paying it? Turkeys and Christmas comes to mind..

Now if you really want to get Mr Camerons attention suggest a kind of road fund licence for wheel chair users. or a tax on walking sticks and crutches, or even better,,, a 60% tax rate for anyone claiming benefits. There are literally thousands of options available before we need to tax the rich.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gunderan
Who let the Libertarians out without supervision?
02:43 PM on 11/03/2011
Why oh why. Why would anyone listen to the man who defines the 1% u. A person who used personal connections to establish the wolrds biggest control machine, Contributes more to political lobbying to avoid anti trust actions in the states than any other two tech companies combined(although Google may be catching up quick. Bill and mellissa gates are very rich dilitantes who crave attention like some American actors and actresses. Visting a country for a poverty guided tour and then telling people what that coutry is really like isnt real and never will be.Besides that whers my help yes i have gone without food in any form for a weeks at a time been left to rot dispite working all my life just because i choose to have a mental illness. I am part of the 99% in ways that people like the gates and bill nighty will never be.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
angler725
It's gotten comical now.
12:58 PM on 11/04/2011
You could sell your PC and cell phone ......... plus you'd save on monthly charges, yeah?
02:24 PM on 11/03/2011
Quote: "My hope is that a group of willing leaders will use Cannes as an opportunity to press ahead with Robin Hood taxes to fight poverty in their own countries and overseas."

Fat chance!

Before giving this money away governments need to cut their budget deficits, such a tax would certainly help.
photo
DXM
An extreme moderate
01:40 PM on 11/03/2011
Well, there is ZERO chance of any such tax being implemented in the US any time soon. The GOP will not vote to impose ANY new tax (no matter how much sense it might make) never mind support ANY proposal that originated in "socialist" Europe (again, no matter how much sense it might make).
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
06:36 PM on 11/03/2011
I can tell you that there is little chance for this tax in the UK either, as we do not want to lose the Banks and Finance Houses in the City of London.
11:53 AM on 11/03/2011
I reckon it would make quite a lot of people happy, at least 99% of us, but as Cameron and his cohorts in the HoP are in league with the other 1% I'll not be holding my breath waiting for them to support this. I can see the bullingdon boys up in arms, spouting about growth/jobs/economy being affected, well theres no growth, sweet FA jobs and the only economy the 1% are interested in is their own so any hit in this direction will definitely be opposed, the only way forward for the people of this country is to take back our democracy by ousting these crooks, they know it and the people are beginning to realize it too, further blocks on taxing these scum is not going to end well, for them.