WARNING: This blog contains adult content
Of late, there have been a number of news stories about anal sex and in particular how it is becoming more common. You might wonder how private sexual acts are newsworthy, but there are a few reasons here.
One is the rather obvious point that not all sexually active people are aware of which STIs they can get from which sexual acts. If more people are having anal sex but are not using proper protection, we could see an increase in the percentage of people with some sort of STI. Thus, this becomes a health issue, potentially an international one.
Another reason is that anal sex is apparently becoming more common in porn, which means that young men, who seem to learn a lot about sex from porn, are starting to expect it as just a matter-of-course sexual act. Young women are thereby feeling pressured to give men access via the back door, something not everyone is comfortable with or finds pleasurable, although there certainly are many who do. So an issue here is whether women have the confidence to speak up and say what they actually want or don't want in bed.
Of course, this affects others as well: there may be some heterosexual men or lesbians who feel pressured to be pegged by their girlfriends, or gay men who feel that in order to be "real" gays, they have to have anal sex. All this means that we need to teach about anal sex in sex education courses and also to discuss ways of talking about desire. Young people need help with this, so they have the strength to only agree to acts that they really want to do.
So naturally, since anal sex isn't a common topic in sex ed, I've turned to young adult literature to see what teenaged readers might learn about the topic from fiction. Interestingly, I've found almost no explicit mentions of it, especially in books with heterosexual or lesbian couples.
I wondered if young adult novels that featured gay males might be more likely to refer to anal sex, even though it is obviously only one of many things that gay male couples (or, indeed, any couple) might do in bed. But even those books are surprisingly shy. Characters might have sex, but there isn't much detail and there's very little reference to anal matters.
In Robin Reardon's Thinking Straight, the main protagonist has to describe having sex with his boyfriend to his reverend as a way of "purging" the feelings. Here, what he describes is oral sex. The bottom is scarcely touched.
In Alex Sanchez's Rainbow trilogy, which follows three male teenagers (two gay and one bisexual) through their high school years, the characters have plenty of sex (or "make love", as they are more liable to put it). However, the sex might be described as "entering one another" (as in Rainbow Road), with no explanation of which body part is entering which other body part. There are many possibilities for a reader to imagine.
Perhaps since anal sex has traditionally been linked to gay men, a reader might imagine that act. But would that tell a reader anything about how anal sex feels, how people engage in it, or what its aftermath might be?
Naturally, fiction need not necessarily reflect what really goes on in the world. But considering that it's a major source for young people in particular to get information, one might think that authors would try to include some beneficial details.
Sanchez, for example, often refers to HIV and the importance of using condoms. So why not talk about what anal sex actually feels like or what would happen if a young gay male wasn't interested in it?
Similarly, authors writing sex scenes featuring other types of couplings in young adult novels might want to start including anal sex. If it is in fact becoming a new form of 'vanilla' sex and if more young people expect to get it from their partners and/or are expected to provide it for their partners, then those young people should get some information about it. And literature is a wonderful way of allowing readers to learn about and experience new things.
In an article in Jezebel, Hugo Schwyzer, a professor at Pasadena City College, calls anal sex "the most selfless of common sexual acts", because it is intimate and can be very painful. He writes, "more than any other sex act, anal simultaneously symbolises both the capacity to push through suffering and the willingness to please. For a generation uniquely acclimated to pressure, anxiety, and pain, It's little wonder that this once taboo act has become so celebrated, so popular, so expected."
If anal sex really is so "expected" and "popular" for the younger generation, adults need to be the "selfless" ones and to give young people information about it. Literature is one of the best ways to talk to people about the pleasures and the pains of the butt, so it's time for authors to enter the conversation about the rear.
Follow B.J. Epstein on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bjepstein
Peter G Tatchell: Needless Restrictions Remain on Gay Blood Donors
B.J. Epstein: Bye Bi: The Case of the Missing Bisexuals
Ashley Hames: Let's Talk About Sex: Pegging
Crowe's Nest: Marianna: Let's Get It On -- Sex Scenes in Young ...
Young Adult Fiction With Sex (214 books)
Young Adult Fiction: Wild Things - New York Times
Teenagers, Sex, and Young Adult Fiction - Attention Rebellious ...
We see this attitude in TV as well, Captain Jack Harkness from Torchwood being the most high-profile example. If that's the case, then it seems this attitude is starting now and we should try to prepare our children for the world ahead, not the one we knew. Logically therefore, if people are going to attempt it, there should be information concerning it, the pros and cons, the risks and the pleasures, available to anyone who wants to look.
It's not something I've ever wanted to try, but as there as those that will, surely it's better that they do so safely?
Whatever the sex act, people should understand how to take care of themselves properly and practice safer sex (note, safeR sex can involve two couples who don't use a barrier method because they are thoroughly tested over the relevant time periods and are completely monogamous).
Being squeamish helps no one. Give people the information and tools that they need. Anyone getting pain needs to be told to try prep, lube and patience for a start.
I had to teach myself, seek out materials, deal with the matter alone. As a gay woman, no one ever gave me a single sex education lesson. When I was at school and all we had was talks on procreation, STDs and diagrams that did not even include a labelled clitoris (obviously, I knew what it was, but what about the boys in the lecture?! It's a pretty important thing to ignore). I knew nothing and didn't have a clue how lesbians could practice safer sex.
Are the Pasadena professor and Ms. Epstein out of their minds? They want to promote this to our young people? "I love you so much, I will endure intense pain for your brief pleasure"??
Why would we link intimacy with acceptance of great pain? If I had a daughter, I would teach her never to tolerate that, and it never occurred to me to teach my son that, because I thought it obvious you don't hurt others for pleasure. Certainly, someone who loves you will not hurt you for their own pleasure.
Mutual enjoyment of any sex act is a great thing. What people do is their own business, and if they like it and no one is physically or emotionally harmed, great. But linking deliberate infliction of pain with a lover's intimacy is completely twisted.
It's what a subservient, abused young woman or other person in a weaker position would be encouraged to offer to an abusive male or otherwise more powerful lover.
If a sex act isn't desirable and pleasurable to both parties, it isn't an intimate act, To teach our youth that sacrificing themselves to the extent of needing to "push through suffering" and thereby "demonstrate the willingness to please" is demeaning to them and sheer lunacy if we expect them to establish healthy, loving, mutually respectful relationships and to have self-respect.
I have two girls and I have listened over the years and we have had some very frank discussions. I always tell them that they should never do something they are uncomfortable doing and under no circumstances should they stay with a guy who tries to guilt them into it.
The only problem with that is that you cannot teach self-esteem. Expecting our education system or government to take responsibility for imparting knowledge on our youth is one thing. Recognising that, as parents and as a society as a whole, we have an even greater responsibility for the self-esteem and emotional development of the younger generation is quite another.
I agree with the premise of what is in the article, awareness is important, but only part of the battle.
'' ..Perhaps since anal sex has traditionally been linked to gay men, ..''
True now. But Kinsey in France in (I vaguely recall) late 1970's found a very high proportion of Roman Catholic married couples using anal sex as a means of preventing conception.
So, for me, habitual use of anal sex was associated with Mediterranean Catholics and gays. What research has been conducted in the Untied States into Roman Catholics using this form of contraception?