Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Carla Buzasi

GET UPDATES FROM Carla Buzasi
 

The Week That Was: A War on Every Front

Posted: 11/03/2012 00:00

If war is a psychological game as much as a military one, this week in Afghanistan we suffered one of our biggest set-backs. The numbers add up to a painful equation. Six men dead. The single largest loss of British life in a single incident in Afghanistan since 2006. The roll-call of British men lost to this war tipping over 400. The sums left a nation in shock and thrust the issue of Britain's involvement in Afghanistan back onto the front pages.

As the families of Sergeant Nigel Coupe, Corporal Jake Hartley, Private Anthony Frampton, Private Christopher Kershaw, Private Daniel Wade and Private Daniel Wilford came to terms with their loss, vocal opponents and supporters of our armed forces' deployment in the region stepped in to fill their dignified silence.

In an open letter to David Cameron, the mother of the 100th solider killed in Afghanistan, Carla Cuthbertson, begged the prime minister to bring all troops home. Carla lost her eldest son, Nathan, four years ago when he was killed by a Taliban suicide bomber. Her youngest son, Connan, is due to fly out to Helmand next year. In her heartfelt letter she explained, 'I believed then he had died for a noble cause. Now, as I send my youngest son to war, I beg you to end this bloodshed... No more young men and women should die in this conflict. Nathan did give his life for something he believed in. But when another 100 lives had been lost, I started to question why we were sending soldiers to Afghanistan. Now I feel this is not a war we're going to win and I don't want any more families to suffer like mine.'

Other bereaved parents have taken a different stance. Bob Wright, whose son Corporal Mark Wright GC died in Afghanistan in 2003, urged Cameron to stay the course and not leave until the country was back on its feet. "We are there now, so we need to wipe out the Taliban and get kids back to school and help sort out the country, and then leave," he said.

The commanding officer of the six fallen men, agreed, saying it was their regiment's duty not to abandon the task in hand. "It has been a sad day but as their brothers in arms we remain committed in our duty to continue with our mission," he told reporters outside the troop's barracks in Warminster. "They would want nothing less."

In this war, as in so many others, there aren't just two sides to the argument, and every one affected deserves to have their voice heard.

Tragedy too struck in Nigeria this week when hostage Chris McManus and his Italian colleague Franco Lamolinara died during a failed rescue mission by British and Nigerian Special Forces. Abducted last year while working on a construction project, the two men have been the subject of an intense search and intelligence mission ever since. Predictably, the bloodbath left by their kidnappers - many of whom also died during the cross-fire - has sparked a war of words between the two men's governments. Is now really the time for recrimination? A far more relevant debate would, it seems, be around the growing terrorist cells in the country, and how best to ensure similar catastrophes can be prevented.

On Thursday, we mark the first anniversary of the Syria uprising. Fifty-two weeks after the conflict started, the country is still in turmoil with the tidal-wave of refugees spilling over the border to Turkey gaining momentum by the day.

As Oxfam's Phil Bloomer wrote in his Huffington Post UK blog yesterday, "Nothing is more important than stopping the killing on all sides. Unlike many crises we face, with a tangled mix of political and 'natural' causes, Syria is a political crisis caused by a government refusing its people's right to be heard. Easy to solve? Of course not. But its direct political cause does mean it is amenable to international political pressure - if the world has the will to exert it."

While wars rage oversees, lest we forget the last 12 months weren't exactly peace and happiness at home. Last summer's riots may seem like something of a bad dream now, but loose ends are still being tied up and great swathes of society are still working to ensure they never happen again.

This week, the rioter who broke Malaysian student Ashraf Rossli's jaw, before cycling off and leaving two 'good Samaritans' to help him to his feet and then steal the Playstation out of his rucksack, was jailed for seven years. While judge Witold Pawlak told convicted Beau Isagba he hoped his sentence would serve to "make other like-minded people think before they behave in a similar way to you, and also reassure the public and visitors to our country that this sort of behaviour will not be tolerated", Rossli said he had forgiven all his attackers. "I'm not angry, seriously," he insisted. "The only thing I would think about is, I want to go on with my life and my jaw is healing, so I guess there's no point in worrying about them."

For Charlie Taylor, the government's discipline adviser, this week marked the long-awaited publication of his Improving Alternative Provision report, commissioned after the riots.

"Two-year-olds to have anger-management classes," screamed the headlines, boiling Taylor's recommendations down to one throwaway line. And, in one fell swoop glossing over the whys and wherefores. He might be an ex-Etonian, but Taylor is no stranger to classrooms of angry children, thanks to his six years as the head-teacher of the Willows Special School in west London, which opens its doors to excluded primary school children. He's been attacked, punched, spat and screamed at, ensuring he of many is best placed to remark to The Times, "if we just hope the problem will go away... it will get bigger". He also acknowledges that the riots could easily happen again, that "the social implications of not addressing this are huge".

As we fight wars at home and abroad, it makes sense to listen to every side of the argument, debate every cause and effect, and examine every suggested solution. It is the only way to move forwards.

 

Follow Carla Buzasi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/CarlaBuzasi

If war is a psychological game as much as a military one, this week in Afghanistan we suffered one of our biggest set-backs. The numbers add up to a painful equation. Six men dead. The single largest ...
If war is a psychological game as much as a military one, this week in Afghanistan we suffered one of our biggest set-backs. The numbers add up to a painful equation. Six men dead. The single largest ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:10 PM on 03/11/2012
I am a very proud Brit who's family has served in our armed forces. What I can;t understand is why we cant have real open debates about how we are compromising British Soldiers not for the sake of UK but for the sake of USA. If USA didnt keep messing in everyones back yard then people would not come and mess in theirs.Before people mention 9/11 which was a sad and vile act, lets not forget about over 100,000 Arabs who were slaughtered in one day on the road to Bashra, where US pilots laughed and called it a turkey shoot because they were unarmed.

Now we either stand up for British integrity or we carry on be poodles for the USA and Israel, Latest debates are a joke we talk about Iran and Syria. Why is there no mention of daily abuses by Israel.Why don.t we mention Israel's arsenal of 499+ nukes before Israel pints fingure at others. Sooner our Government and PM put our country first again insted of having the strings pulled from the Whitehouse the better. We find money to bomb other countries while we suffocate the old and the elderly and hospital in our great country and waste money on useless wars for the USA. It seems like our Government MI6 and CIA is now run by Mousad. The New film SafeHouse about sums it up
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roy Fowler
I try....I really do!
07:06 PM on 03/11/2012
Democracy; is an egalitarian form of government in which all the citizens of a nation together determine public policy, the laws and the actions of their state, requiring that all citizens (meeting certain qualifications) have an equal opportunity to express their opinion.

The problem is that the UK Government and the 100,000 civil servants that live in an elite bubble have no concern for the average citizen and have proven time and time again that we are simply an inconvenience to whom they must appeal to once ever four or five years; thus maintaining the idea of true Democracy.

There are many now dying, and yet to die, who sadly will loose their lives because and for the self satisfaction of Bankers, Billionaires and an Elite raised to rule who live without fear of the sytem, its laws and the people.
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
02:41 AM on 03/11/2012
So when are you Brits going to pressure your government to abandon the loser's game of joining in America's wars for plunder? If Iraq didn't demonstrate that you will only get the leavings not desired by the connected American firms, Afghanistan will only provide even less. You Brits know your history better than we Yanks do, and you know you got kicked out of Afghanistan once already. What is there to gain when your lives are the cost of someone else getting rich?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MarxEngelsLeninTrotsky
Einstein: Socialism is the way forward.
03:13 AM on 03/11/2012
I agree with everything you have said.

That said, this war is the politicians war.

Befor the Iraq war 1million people marched in London passed Parliament and did the Government listen? Nope.

I think people are resigned to the fact that no matter what we say or what we do the politicians will do what they want. (Which i find sad)

The PM would rather have a backlash from the British people than from the United States and Obama. Which would happen if he pulled British Troops out of Afghanistan.
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
03:29 AM on 03/11/2012
Just like us, you voters have to take your country back. I hope I don't sound too fabulous when I claim the future of the world depends upon us doing so.
08:13 PM on 03/11/2012
Truth like that is now being suffocated in our so called free press we acuse all other countries of censorship. Sadly even USA has it strings pulled from israel and Zionist lobbys in the USA. So my friend yes democrocy can be bought lol